The dark side of Dubai (13 Viewers)

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
for the 9 billionth time, Islam was not designed or produced or written for a medieval desert society...it is applicable to the whole of mankind...if you don't believe it then, just see the millions of people who come to Makkah and Madina for the Hajj pilgrimage
Porno movies weren't designed or produced for +18 people...It is applicable to the whole mankind...If you don't believe it then, just see millions of under 18 teenagers who watch porno movies.
 

Alen

Ѕenior Аdmin
Apr 2, 2007
53,924
When i'd like to know more about Islam in practice then a woman in Iran or a woman in Arabia will be the first person i'll ask.
No disrespect towards Fred, Ahmed, Tahir or the others, but in this particular case, Hoori's opinion counts more to me.
 

Zé Tahir

JhoolayLaaaal!
Moderator
Dec 10, 2004
29,281
Porno movies weren't designed or produced for +18 people...It is applicable to the whole mankind...If you don't believe it then, just see millions of under 18 teenagers who watch porno movies.
Wow what an applicable analogy :tup:

When i'd like to know more about Islam in practice then a woman in Iran or a woman in Arabia will be the first person i'll ask.
No disrespect towards Fred, Ahmed, Tahir or the others, but in this particular case, Hoori's opinion counts more to me.
Oh sure, it's not like we have mothers or sisters.
 

Lion

King of Tuz
Jan 24, 2007
36,185
When i'd like to know more about Islam in practice then a woman in Iran or a woman in Arabia will be the first person i'll ask.
No disrespect towards Fred, Ahmed, Tahir or the others, but in this particular case, Hoori's opinion counts more to me.
how so? Hoori lives in a country where evil dictators have used religion to form a fundamentalist regime that oppresses people's rights and freedoms, while these so called leader get away with bending their own laws.

I would say that she would actually biased.
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Wow what an applicable analogy :tup:
I'm actually not casting doubt on this part of his comment Ze:

"Islam was not designed or produced or written for a medieval desert society". I just wanted to show how lame his concluding was for proving the line above.


how so? Hoori lives in a country where evil dictators have used religion to form a fundamentalist regime that oppresses people's rights and freedoms, while these so called leader get away with bending their own laws.

I would say that she would actually biased.
And you judge me only by that?

In fact, beliefs are more likely to make someone be biased comparing to disbeliefs and this is why the most biased ones in religious threads happen to be the religious ones. They take everything opposed to their creeds as something disrespectful while nothing is able to disdain non-religious people' disbeliefs.

Reading this thread, I'd say Fred, Tahir, Ahmed and Eddy could have defended Islam much better if they hadn't been as biased and easily offended as what they really are.
 

Lion

King of Tuz
Jan 24, 2007
36,185
I'm not judging you Hoori. I'm just saying living in a place where Religions is used as means of opression can sometimes lead to bias, either for or againt that religion, depending or where you stand. Of course neutrality is also possible, but imo it would be rare.
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
When i'd like to know more about Islam in practice then a woman in Iran or a woman in Arabia will be the first person i'll ask.
No disrespect towards Fred, Ahmed, Tahir or the others, but in this particular case, Hoori's opinion counts more to me.

You're being selective though aren't you? You didn't choose to listen to Miss Dubai, Juve Baby or the others, but you so conveniently chose to listen only to Hoori.


@Hoori, how could Eddy be offended, he's not even a muslim.
 

Sadomin

Senior Member
Apr 5, 2005
7,327
I'm not judging you Hoori. I'm just saying living in a place where Religions is used as means of opression can sometimes lead to bias, either for or againt that religion, depending or where you stand. Of course neutrality is also possible, but imo it would be rare.
Isn't an Islamic society ideal according to Islam?
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
Isn't an Islamic society ideal according to Islam?
It is, but i don't see an Islamic society anywhere. Radicals like Saudi Arabia and Iran do not represent the Islam i know. As far as i'm concerned they manipulate religion to satisfy their needs and to control people.
 

Sadomin

Senior Member
Apr 5, 2005
7,327
It is, but i don't see an Islamic society anywhere. Radicals like Saudi Arabia and Iran do not represent the Islam i know. As far as i'm concerned they manipulate religion to satisfy their needs and to control people.
One would have thought that a society with at least some Islamic values, such as Iran or Saudi Arabia, would work better than secular countries.

I suppose, according to you, that it has to do with personal freedom allowing more correct interpretations of Islam being taught and followed.

This leads me to my question: Do you believe that a society which followed the Koran to every word would be compatible with democracy, liberty and human rights (in all departments - no exceptions)? Don't consider this a dig at Islam in particular, I'd just like your unbiased opinion.
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,326
It is, but i don't see an Islamic society anywhere. Radicals like Saudi Arabia and Iran do not represent the Islam i know. As far as i'm concerned they manipulate religion to satisfy their needs and to control people.
Now that's the problem. I won't go into deeper historic interpretations (you could argue that Mohammad did the very same thing, but I won't). What's more important is that the argument you put forward whenever something bad happens in the name of Islam is this: "that's not the real Islam".

But they might say the same thing, Fred. Hell, they might even be right up to a point. Like I said before, if you have a text that is written in the Middle Ages, I am sure that you can find references to a holy war in which you can kill infidels. This is not an Islamic problem per se, because obviously christianity has had to face it as well. The thing is though that christians can change their ideals, they can manipulate their religion so it might fit into today's world. I find that a comforting idea.
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
It is, but i don't see an Islamic society anywhere. Radicals like Saudi Arabia and Iran do not represent the Islam i know. As far as i'm concerned they manipulate religion to satisfy their needs and to control people.
What is the Islam you know? Suppose an ideal (up to your standards) Islamic society. I start with this example: What would happen to someone who insults Muhammad in public in this society?

And tell me what do you find wrong and opposed to the "real Islam you know" in Iran?
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,326
You can't have one right interpretation (as Fred seems to suggest), but I do agree with him that you can have wrong interpretations. It's like catholics telling people you can use violence to spread your faith, because Jesus got angry in some temple.
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
You can't have one right interpretation (as Fred seems to suggest), but I do agree with him that you can have wrong interpretations. It's like catholics telling people you can use violence to spread your faith, because Jesus got angry in some temple.
It's more like something superstitious to me and I assure you that you can't see such things being said and accepted in Iran. Our country is being ruled based on Qoran and I'd be delighted to know what Fred is talking about when he says these are not the real Islam values executing in Iran.
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,326
It's more like something superstitious to me and I assure you that you can't see such things being said and accepted in Iran. Our country is being ruled based on Qoran and I'd be delighted to know what Fred is talking about when he says these are not the real Islam values executing in Iran.
Fred goes by his interpretation of Islam. Anything that does not suit that interpretation is not true Islam according to him. So if Fred does not like Iran, Iran is not an Islamic country.

Which is a load of bullshit, I agree.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 10)