'The Broken City' (1 Viewer)

[Alen]

Hmm, really? I thought Jasper said no voting/lynching tonight

He changed it later after he was told by me and Sab that it's wasted time.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Quetzalcoatl]

What are the other options? At best it's 2:2 but big chances for 4:0.

If Hoori lies, its 3-0, 3-1 or 4-0 to the Gs/
If she tells the truth, it could be 0-2 to the Cs at best--if the Gs go for her and she's protected by the BG on both nights. At worst, it could be 3-1 to the Gs.

 

[blondu]

I am here for the rest of the night. I have been checking pms during my lecture breaks. Everyone that has emailed me has had a responce in fairly quick time.

Osman when you read the 19 pages, you will see that i got put in my place. Voting is on today, as is whacking and all roles active. The gangsters have all day to tell me there whacks, there is no voting allowed in the thread between 11.00 - 23.00.

did hoori got that answer sooner?

 

[king Ale]

Scenario:

Fred gets lynched tonight. He's a C.

The Gs whack a C.

We vote Hoori tomorrow.

The Gs whack a C.

---

We get one G and they get 3 Cs after 2 days. Worth the risk?

It won't happen, I'm the detective.

 

[Osman]

hoori, why did you out of nowhere admit to being a detective?

Very good question, its a peculiar call on both scenarios, she is the D, and totally outs herself when she is not desperate to, one in 15 to be whacked (ok realistically way less so, one of the handful likely whack targets as a C). Isnt a tactical necessity (except maybe if she feared being whacked tonight), way too early to be that.

And the other scenario, if she is a G, then she outs herself too, after Fred is lynched and shown to be G (and totally retarded to pull as a G, so very unlikely, civilians kill eachother off left and right, dont need to risk it to take down one). Either way, bit too soon of a card to play.

 

[Ford Prefect]

I vote Janna
---------------------------------
1. Blondu - Alen
2. Janna - Alen
3. Melo - Alen

4. Sab - Hoori
5. Cheese - Hoori

6. Ze Tahir - Blondu

7. Kate - Gabriel

8. Alen - Janna

Everytime you want to vote or change your vote post it like this - accumulating the votes as the day passes. It saves confusion and makes everyones life easier. All you have to do is copy the body of text and add your vote.

did hoori got that answer sooner?

Im not going to confirm or deny anyone sending me pms. You know you shouldn't ask the narrator stuff like this.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

It won't happen, I'm the detective.

We can't be sure. We're looking at all the possibilities.

If you're lying, it could be 3-0, 3-1 or 4-0 to the Gs.

Telling truth, realistically 2-2 or 2-3 to the Gs.

I want to know if others think it's worth it.

 

[Alen]

If Hoori lies, its 3-0.
If she tells the truth, it could be 2-0 to the Cs at best--if the Gs go for her and she's protected by the BG on both nights. At worst, it could be 1-3 to the Gs.

If Hoori is really the D and she's protected then the Cs kill one G (Fred) and Hoori gets to investigate from tomorrow. That's already a big plus for the Cs.

If Hoori is a G and she lynches Fred, then it's gonna be 3:1 for them, which is quite good for only 2 nights. Usually the Gs go 4:0 after the first two days when everyone's confused.

I think there is no risk following her. The only problem is if Fred is a special role (detective or lawyer), but even then it's worth it.

I still don't see why would Hoori go public. I had my reasons back then because I was investigated. But I had luck Fred (the detective) to be jailed and only then I started my show.
Hoori went public out of nowhere. Even if she was investigated, how did she know who to target? I knew back then that Fred is the D becuase he played it bad and made it obvious that he's the D by attacking me. Hoori went public without being attacked.

Everything points out that she's telling the truth. The risk to trust her is worthy.

 

[Cheesio]

This is the vote standing till now.

1. King Ale - Fred
2. Melo - Fred
3. Alen - Fred
4. Cheese - Fred
5. ALC - Fred
6. Kyle - Fred

7. Blondu - Alen
8. Nate - Alen

9. Sab - Cheese

10. Janna - Sabsab

11. Ze Tahir - Blondu

12. Kate - Gabriel

13. Fred- Melo

14. TWW - No Lynch

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

If Hoori is really the D and she's protected then the Cs kill one G (Fred) and Hoori gets to investigate from tomorrow. That's already a big plus for the Cs.

If Hoori is a G and she lynches Fred, then it's gonna be 3:1 for them, which is quite good for only 2 nights. Usually the Gs go 4:0 after the first two days when everyone's confused.

I think there is no risk following her. The only problem is if Fred is a special role (detective or lawyer), but even then it's worth it.

I still don't see why would Hoori go public. I had my reasons back then because I was investigated. But I had luck Fred (the detective) to be jailed and only then I started my show.
Hoori went public out of nowhere. Even if she was investigated, how did she know who to target? I knew back then that Fred is the D becuase he played it bad and made it obvious that he's the D by attacking me. Hoori went public without being attacked.

Everything points out that she's telling the truth. The risk to trust her is worthy.

I don't disagree. We'll leave it as Fred for now then.

 

[X Æ A-12]

If Hoori is G then I'm willing to bet Alen and TWW are too.

 

[Osman]

He changed it later after he was told by me and Sab that it's wasted time.

Good, its defenitely wasted time. I will be bit busy working next week, I would like it if we dont waste time/a night. Take it the game will take around 5 days atleast.

 

[king Ale]

Very good question, its a peculiar call on both scenarios, she is the D, and totally outs herself when she is not desperate to, one in 15 to be whacked (ok realistically way less so, one of the handful likely whack targets as a C). Isnt a tactical necessity (except maybe if she feared being whacked tonight), way too early to be that.

And the other scenario, if she is a G, then she outs herself too, after Fred is lynched and shown to be G (and totally retarded to pull as a G, so very unlikely, civilians kill eachother off left and right, dont need to risk it to take down one). Either way, bit too soon of a card to play.

I already said, possibility of me being whacked tonight was not low, I am the D and I had a G. We will have one G lynched tonight and considering the reactions, Alen and TWW are also almost certainly Gs. People will trust me and we will win

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

If Hoori is G then I'm willing to bet Alen and TWW are too.

Gimme a kiss.

I already said, possibility of me being whacked tonight was not low, I am the D and I had a G. We will have one G lynched tonight and considering the reactions, Alen and TWW are also almost certainly Gs. People will trust me and we will win

Who are you gonna investigate tomorrow?

 

[Osman]

I am here for the rest of the night. I have been checking pms during my lecture breaks. Everyone that has emailed me has had a responce in fairly quick time.

Osman when you read the 19 pages, you will see that i got put in my place. Voting is on today, as is whacking and all roles active. The gangsters have all day to tell me there whacks, there is no voting allowed in the thread between 11.00 - 23.00.

Thats all good, very good to use tonight IMO. But what do you mean with the bolded? Naturally between 11-23 is daytime, hence the voting until it unfolds at night. I take its a typoe and you meant no voting between 23-11, from night time til next days voting starts.

 

[Ford Prefect]

Thats all good, very good to use tonight IMO. But what do you mean with the bolded? Naturally between 11-23 is daytime, hence the voting until it unfolds at night. I take its a typoe and you meant no voting between 23-11, from night time til next days voting starts.

That was a typo lol, i've edited it now.

Voting is 11.00-23.00

23.00 - 11.00 is no voting.

 

[X Æ A-12]

Gimme a kiss.Who are you gonna investigate tomorrow?

You can kiss the noose.

 

[Quetzalcoatl]

Fred voted Melo. Did he say why?

 

[Osman]

I already said, possibility of me being whacked tonight was not low, I am the D and I had a G. We will have one G lynched tonight and considering the reactions, Alen and TWW are also almost certainly Gs. People will trust me and we will win

Agreed on both accounts (your role and your suspects), I just aired the 2nd possiblity as technicality, not a probality, its 3 times more risky as a G to do what you did, then out yourself as the D. Which I wish you hadnt, even if I get it in part, the threat of whacking is somewhat little more likely with you and handful other experienced players, then with the other possibly Cs. But still, I dont like the D being known this early, you wont survive long (unless we have a good BG).


About that, The Bodyguard, take the hint and protect Hoori tonight, dont be as some others have played BG, only protect yourself all the time.

 

[Alen]

Either way, The Bodyguard, take the hint and protect Hoori tonight, dont be as some others have played BG, only protect yourself all the time.

But just in case, the BG should not reveal his role. That way even if Hoori is lying, the BG will be safe (unless the Gs get lucky and kill him tonight).