OP
'The Broken City' (21 Viewers)
- Thread starter Ford Prefect
- Start date
He's just trying to save his ass hoping to confuse the more naive civilians. Leave him to me 
He was 100% investigated and he is a G. The civilians can not take another risk with a lucky guess like yesterday because it will make it 6:4 and the gangsters will win after that (most probably).
If I made a wrong investigation today I was gonna tell you that I investigated a civilian. I was gonna have to tell you because we can't take any more risks.
I investigated Osman today and he is a G. As simple as that.
He was 100% investigated and he is a G. The civilians can not take another risk with a lucky guess like yesterday because it will make it 6:4 and the gangsters will win after that (most probably).
If I made a wrong investigation today I was gonna tell you that I investigated a civilian. I was gonna have to tell you because we can't take any more risks.
I investigated Osman today and he is a G. As simple as that.
You are most likely the D, or another double whammy, 2nd layer of defence for the D. Though doubtful, only you and Hoori could somehow trust eachother enough in the firsr hours of the first day, to tell eachother your roles and believe one another to the point she pretends to be D. But either way, doesnt mean you arent BSing as heck right now, like you have most of the game.
And lets take a little break from the game. We're all just players now, not Gs nor Cs....
I read what is said about "only me and Hoori trusting eachother in the early hours". I got the same accusation from Matt and I think that Tahir was complaining about the same.
What you're saying is that Hoori and I exchange screenshots and proved our roles to each other.
This is complete nonsense. Not just because Hoori of all people would have never done it, nor would have I ruined a game like that. You don't deserve this but I will swear in my sons that we didn't exchange screenshots. I simply went with my guts to trust her.
I investigated Fred and I saw that he's a G. I knew that not a single soul will believe me if I told you that I am the D. You all remember what I did in the previous game. I knew that I must find a C to act for me. My first choice was Janna. I was 100% sure that she's a C. I almost sent her the PM but I changed my mind in the last moment. I decided that Janna isn't capable of performing that role and lie to be the D.
I then proceeded to observing the players. Two of them caught my eye with what they said (if you want me I will find their posts). Hoori and Tahir. I was 99% sure that Tahir is also a G and that Hoori is a C in this game.
I had to take a risk and I took it. I told her everything. It worked. I got lucky. I had no other choice.
Now, bitch as much as you want, but nothing illegal happened. I just took a risk like I took yesterday (game related so I won't talk about it).
Now please lets end this silly discussion. There was nothing illegal.
I read what is said about "only me and Hoori trusting eachother in the early hours". I got the same accusation from Matt and I think that Tahir was complaining about the same.
What you're saying is that Hoori and I exchange screenshots and proved our roles to each other.
This is complete nonsense. Not just because Hoori of all people would have never done it, nor would have I ruined a game like that. You don't deserve this but I will swear in my sons that we didn't exchange screenshots. I simply went with my guts to trust her.
I investigated Fred and I saw that he's a G. I knew that not a single soul will believe me if I told you that I am the D. You all remember what I did in the previous game. I knew that I must find a C to act for me. My first choice was Janna. I was 100% sure that she's a C. I almost sent her the PM but I changed my mind in the last moment. I decided that Janna isn't capable of performing that role and lie to be the D.
I then proceeded to observing the players. Two of them caught my eye with what they said (if you want me I will find their posts). Hoori and Tahir. I was 99% sure that Tahir is also a G and that Hoori is a C in this game.
I had to take a risk and I took it. I told her everything. It worked. I got lucky. I had no other choice.
Now, bitch as much as you want, but nothing illegal happened. I just took a risk like I took yesterday (game related so I won't talk about it).
Now please lets end this silly discussion. There was nothing illegal.
Get off your high horse, I didnt say anything about illegal or such, but that its a huge risk to trust someone in first hours in first day (I seen best friends play this game, tell eachother their roles, and lose because the D one of them told a G), and it makes sense it would only be Hoori that you would trust to tell, since its a huge make or break play. FYI, the only reason I didnt even consider cheating or such for a second its because Hoori would be one of the parties in it.
Fred was naive enough to do what the Gs usually do. In Juventuz the mistake is this:
" I'm not sure about Alen/Osman/Hoori guys. Just because he/she is experienced it doesn't make them Gs. I'm willing to give him/her the benefit of the doubt"
A civilian Fred or Tahir will never give us the benefit of the doubt. They will be super suspicious. They are both smart and they don't give a benefit of the doubt to Osman, me or Hoori in the mafia games.
They both said the same and defended me. It made me sure that they are Gs and I was right.
Hoori on the other hand said in her own "civilian innocent" way how I sound like a G to her. Whenever she's a C I am the first person she thinks is a G. When she is a G she is completely different player. I just knew that she was a C at that point.
I took the risk not just because there was a chance that she's a G but also because there was a chance that she'll be recruited that same day and fuck me up.
I simply took a risk as much as you can't comprehend why I did it. You can call it foolish, and maybe it was, but it was a simple risk. Nothing else.
" I'm not sure about Alen/Osman/Hoori guys. Just because he/she is experienced it doesn't make them Gs. I'm willing to give him/her the benefit of the doubt"
A civilian Fred or Tahir will never give us the benefit of the doubt. They will be super suspicious. They are both smart and they don't give a benefit of the doubt to Osman, me or Hoori in the mafia games.
They both said the same and defended me. It made me sure that they are Gs and I was right.
Hoori on the other hand said in her own "civilian innocent" way how I sound like a G to her. Whenever she's a C I am the first person she thinks is a G. When she is a G she is completely different player. I just knew that she was a C at that point.
I took the risk not just because there was a chance that she's a G but also because there was a chance that she'll be recruited that same day and fuck me up.
I simply took a risk as much as you can't comprehend why I did it. You can call it foolish, and maybe it was, but it was a simple risk. Nothing else.