The battle of the Vampires (17 Viewers)

Apr 15, 2006
56,640
You sound like Janna.
They can check 4 times during the game who the D investigated. When they chose to send a request they get the result after the D gets it.
I have a question: what if the D doesn't investigate on a day, and the Crooked Cop asks the narrator for the results? Does that mean the CC will now be able to ask for the results only 3 times more, or still 4?

Alen, can you answer this?
Theres a user called aris? I should pay more attention.
How dare you now notice my sister!

jasper
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Are you completely bananas? The D better not contact anyone except the BG. The Gs can see who he investigates and what the role is. They'll try to get an investigated person, special role or not, doesn't matter. If the D contacted the investigated person the Gs know his name and he's dead.
No! Have we changed the rules? They can only know what player was investigated. They would never know what the role is. And they shouldn't either actually.
 

Lilith

Immortelle
May 19, 2006
6,719
No! Have we changed the rules? They can only know what player was investigated. They would never know what the role is. And they shouldn't either actually.

I was wondering why no one posted rules such as this in the rules thread...especially for the mafia newbies.



Yup, she's my fairy godsister. The sister I never had.

:heart: I am. :D
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Oh I hadn't noticed that, it makes no sense at all. That gives the Gs an unfair advantage. They should only know who the detective investigates, not what role the investigated player has. We might as well hope the D won't investigate a special role this way while it must be normally an achievement for the D.
 
Apr 15, 2006
56,640
Oh I hadn't noticed that, it makes no sense at all. That gives the Gs an unfair advantage. They should only know who the detective investigates, not what role the investigated player has. We might as well hope the D won't investigate a special role this way while it must be normally an achievement for the D.
Well guess who was a D in the last game and ended up investigating the BG and Lawyer? :sergio:
 

Kate

Moderator
Feb 7, 2011
18,595
Oh I hadn't noticed that, it makes no sense at all. That gives the Gs an unfair advantage. They should only know who the detective investigates, not what role the investigated player has. We might as well hope the D won't investigate a special role this way while it must be normally an achievement for the D.
I thought that too.
 

Azzurri7

Pinturicchio
Moderator
Dec 16, 2003
72,692
Rab you talk as much as Pesci in Goodfellas. Just sayin
I don't know man, I might cool things down today because I see no one is making a real move.

You sound like Janna.
They can check 4 times during the game who the D investigated. When they chose to send a request they get the result after the D gets it.
I understand this. But lets say today I was investigated, do the G's get the results if they send the request TODAY or after after dead-line/Tomorrow? That was my point. If the answer is after dead-line or tomorrow like I guessed, then Detective has a slight advantage when he investigates a C.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 17)