Whoever we lynch, because all we have still are just guesses, should be someone's whose death will give us some answers about others. If we lynch Sheik, for example, would him being a C tell us about any Gs?
I'm suspicious of Deneb, but not certain. If he's lynched and is a G, we have Hoori and possibly others to look at. If he's a C, we have Nzoric and others.
Whoever we lynch, because all we have still are just guesses, should be someone's whose death will give us some answers about others. If we lynch Sheik, for example, would him being a C tell us about any Gs?
This is true, I have no idea as to Sheik's role, or anyone's, and my earlier vote was simply because he seemed a bit suspicious, but I have nothing concrete
Whoever we lynch, because all we have still are just guesses, should be someone's whose death will give us some answers about others. If we lynch Sheik, for example, would him being a C tell us about any Gs?
Whoever we lynch, because all we have still are just guesses, should be someone's whose death will give us some answers about others. If we lynch Sheik, for example, would him being a C tell us about any Gs?
This is true, I have no idea as to Sheik's role, or anyone's, and my earlier vote was simply because he seemed a bit suspicious, but I have nothing concrete
I'm suspicious of Deneb, but not certain. If he's lynched and is a G, we have Hoori and possibly others to look at. If he's a C, we have Nzoric and others.
I checked the mafia game for dummies, it was stated there too that the crooked cop gets to know about both the name and the role of the investigated player. Funny thing is that I have played this game several times here and I didn't know that. We played without a crooked cop when I was a G and then I never needed to specifically check the rules as I have always been a C after getting the gangster role for three times in a row.
I think we should definitely change this rule. It doesn't make any sense. The crooked cop must only know who the D investigates. Based on that, the Gs can read into players and try to figure out the D. But to get the role of the investigated player is ridiculous. Normally, it must be considered an achievement for the D to investigate the BG but with this rule, it will only backfire on the Cs.
No, because anybody can be wrong about who they suspect. It's those that are most certain of their choices and those protecting others that are questionable.