It's quite obviously a shitty deal in isolation. But it's not happening in a vacuum. You have to take into account context. And that is the Ronaldo deal. And the fact we are upgrading are starting XI.
You called Bonucci a top 3 CB in football and had a little fit when we sold him last summer. You're not willing to consider he might return to his best next season, under Allegri again?
But you're so ready to ignore two mediocre years of Pogba at ManU, dude was even benched this year for Mctominay and Fellaini at one point, and willingly sacrifice our current best CM Pjanic for him?
That seems a little hypocritical.
Neither Caldara or Rugani is yet close to the level of player Bonucci was the last three years. So I fail to see how upgrading Caldara + Higuain to Bonucci + Ronaldo is as bad as you are making it out to be? Unless it's entirely due to dislike and disgust with Bonucci the person. And there I am with you.
Point 1 : Fair. But my irritation is for different reasons.
Point 2: I was more annoyed by the fact that we donated him for peanuts to FUCKING MILAN of all clubs. And i wont deny our passing from the back we suffered without him.
Point 3: Pogba is 25, a superstar. He has way more years ahead of him. He played like a superstar at the World Cup. Considering his marketing potential alone, i'd have had him back especially with Ronaldo there. Bonucci is old is nowhere near his marketing potential.
Point 4 : They arent but we're letting go of potential, simple as that. In hindsight the Higuain-Pogba deal which was virtually a swap deal turned out to be bad business in the end considering how desperate we are to offload him.
I know we're going all in for the short term, but if we dont win CL in the next couple of years, we'd have failed badly with these short term business deals. Just my opinion.