I don't post here, but I read this thread regularly. It's getting damn near impossible to read this though. The way people overreact is embarrassing. People throw around numbers like they know exact details of negotiations. Where have you gotten all of these details? From the same media that reported Aguero was a done deal. Dzeko was a done deal. RVP was a done deal. Draxler was a done deal. So these people were wrong on all of this, but they know exact details of the negotiations? No.
Then you crucify people that defend this mercato.
To me, the reality of this situation is clear. Last summer Conte wanted to rebuild with a younger team. Management didn't, so he left. Juve made the CL final, which meant a huge financial windfall. Older players like Tevez and Pirlo wanted to leave. They realized that this team's cycle was over. They could not improve on last season's results.
That made this summer the perfect time to start the revolution of the team. They had a huge influx of $. The team was getting old and needed to refresh.
People assume that they could've gotten more $ for Vidal. How do you know that? Juve has had issues with his character since he's been here. He spent last season recovering from a major knee injury. He had a down year last season. He blew up in the CL final. During the copa america, he got popped for DUI. They got a major offer for him and he wanted to leave, so they took it. That's probably a wise decision. If they kept him for another season, do they get more $ for him when he's a year older and they have concerns over his previous issues? Again, this was the perfect time to move on from him.
They decided to refresh the team now. They do it now before Roma has a completed stadium and the means to compete financially with them. That way, they can stay competitive while they rebuild. They don't drop down to the EL or worse. They still have a chance to compete.
Are they a better team this season? No they aren't and they know it. Are they good enough to compete for the scudetto and the final 16 of the CL? Absolutely. And that's okay. The kids gain a valuable year of experience and the hope is they continue to progress.
Is every move going to work out? No. Of course not. Does the Zaza deal like like good business? No. My guess is there was some type of obligation to purchase him. Not to mention that they were probably able to stretch the payments over a number of years rather than paying a slightly smaller fee completely upfront.
That seems like the plan to me. No guarantee that it works but it looks to me that the future is much brighter than it was a year ago. It's about continued and prolonged success rather than trying to recreate a season of great over-achievement. It may be a little bumpy along the way, but they believe this is the best way forward.
They knew this was a necessity and things broke right to set them up to do this with more financial power than they expected.