I quoted FIFA Law 12 to him which states this, and he responded with a link to Goal.com commentary for the game where the random guy writing commentary had said it shouldn't be a penalty.
I am sure there are millions of fans around the world who don't know the rules of the game, but why keep arguing after people have quoted them for you? That's beyond retarded.
OK, guys. You can check, that after I read the quoted rules, I already apologized and admitted twice that they were right by the rules, but the thing to notice here beyond me being wrong(and more important I suppose), is that this particular rule is remarkably illogical and meaningless to even imagine, which led to my mistake .