[Serie A] Fiorentina 0-2 JUVENTUS [February 9th 2018] (1 Viewer)

[Hængebøffer]

there's no "last touch" in the rule. simeone either played the ball towards his team mate and in that case, it was a clear offside (regardless of sandy touching the ball or not), or he didn't play the ball, so fouled sandy. either way, it was just right to stop the action.

You're right. This case is all fucked up. I've come to the decision that it wasn't an offside. We got lucky here.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[GiocataGrande]

A $#@!hole, like Haiti

calma

 

[Salvo]

Is there a team that has a better set of free kick takers than us?

Dybala, Pjanic and Bernie

 

[X Æ A-12]

Douglas Costa and Piggy actually aren't bad either when given the chance

And no. There isn't.

 

[Post Ironic]

You're right. This case is all fucked up. I've come to the decision that it wasn't an offside. We got lucky here.

I disagree. It's either offside because Simeone played the ball, or it's a foul because he took out Sandro without playing the ball. I don't see any grey area there.

 

[Hængebøffer]

I disagree. It's either offside because Simeone played the ball, or it's a foul because he took out Sandro without playing the ball. I don't see any grey area there.

I genuinely don't know. I just don't want to look biased.

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

Great troll win. Love it. From the VAR non-penalty call, to Berna’s goal and celebration, to Pipita sticking it up them at the end, it was a brilliant nights entertainment. Whenever most of Italy is in tears it’s a good thing.

 

[Lapa]

Great troll win. Love it. From the VAR non-penalty call, to Berna’s goal and celebration, to Pipita sticking it up them at the end, it was a brilliant nights entertainment. Whenever most of Italy is in tears it’s a good thing.

Dem aussiegays softening up on Berna. @Post Ironic

 

[X Æ A-12]

I disagree. It's either offside because Simeone played the ball, or it's a foul because he took out Sandro without playing the ball. I don't see any grey area there.

I agree, Simeone either doesn't touch the ball and therefore fouls Sandro or he touches the ball to Benassi who was in offside position when the challenge was made. Either way the penalty was not legitimate props to VAR review.

 

[Ali]

After checking the replays am going for the foul. I can clearly see Simione's foot on Sandro, taking him out.

 

[JCK]

Been a while since victory tasted so sweet. wow, this is a good feeling.

This!

- - - Updated - - -

Great troll win. Love it. From the VAR non-penalty call, to Berna’s goal and celebration, to Pipita sticking it up them at the end, it was a brilliant nights entertainment. Whenever most of Italy is in tears it’s a good thing.

Do you know what I love most about this win? It came so early in the weekend and now we just sit back and enjoy the drama. Let's hope there's lot of it.

 

[Lapa]

It was a clear penalty really.

 

[Juve_fanatic]

It was a clear penalty really.

It may have been a penalty but it was a clear fpul on Alex Sandro before that

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

This!

- - - Updated - - -



Do you know what I love most about this win? It came so early in the weekend and now we just sit back and enjoy the drama. Let's hope there's lot of it.

100%. I thought of you when I posted that Now let’s hope for some nice surprises this weekend.

 

[Bianconero_Aus]

Dem aussiegays softening up on Berna. @Post Ironic

I’ve been a Berna gayboy since day 1, Ludvig Borga

 

[JuveJay]

Bit harsh no?

I don't think so. Pjanic should have 5.5 (typo) but don't let the result gloss over the performance. Our full backs did nothing, the midfield was non-existent (and yes I include Marchisio in that, he doesn't have the legs to chase a midfield on his own). Khedira was a passenger for a full 90 mins and Mandzukic's performance on a technical level was appalling. The game was decided by two clinical moments, one in part a goalkeeping mistake and the other was set up by Chiellini.

No other team in the league (or in Europe) could play this shit and come away with a 2-0 win, but our defensive core, battle-hardiness and extra individual quality saw us through. I'd always prefer us to have Chievo at home or something before a big CL game because we all know what is coming, but we squeezed our way through this one. Obviously that's what wins titles over a season.

 

[Xperd]

It may have been a penalty but it was a clear fpul on Alex Sandro before that

Ref cancelled the penalty for the offside not for the foul on Sandro which could have gone either way.

We just got lucky at that moment.

 

[s4tch]

Ref cancelled the penalty for the offside not for the foul on Sandro which could have gone either way.

We just got lucky at that moment.

it was an offside.

 

[Dino_mk]

..... Our full backs did nothing, the midfield was non-existent (and yes I include Marchisio in that, he doesn't have the legs to chase a midfield on his own). Khedira was a passenger for a full 90 mins and Mandzukic's performance on a technical level was appalling.......

The performance was like it was in big part because of the fiorentina tactical setup in the defense. The absence of Dibala in the middle of our attack, and don't having Cuadrado or Costa on the wing, allowed them to double their defenders on the wings living more space through the middle which Juve couldn't use.
I don't give too much credit to rat's players, I also think that our players were having bad performances.

 

[Boksic]

there's no "last touch" in the rule. simeone either played the ball towards his team mate and in that case, it was a clear offside (regardless of sandy touching the ball or not), or he didn't play the ball, so fouled sandy. either way, it was just right to stop the action.

Imagine Pjanic played a through ball to an offside attacker but it took a deflection off a defender on the way. It doesn't suddenly make the attacker onside.

The Fiorentina started the action of the ball going to the offside player, so it's offside.

- - - Updated - - -

I disagree. It's either offside because Simeone played the ball, or it's a foul because he took out Sandro without playing the ball. I don't see any grey area there.