[Serie A, 20th round] Fiorentina 2-1 JUVENTUS [15th January, 2017] (2 Viewers)

May 26, 2016
4,073
I find it very worrysome that a softie like Khedira is our undisputed starter. The guy is VERY average for a team like Juventus and totally done at top level.

He is a box to box that cant box to box because doesnt have the stamina nor the defense, and who feels more comfort playing practically as a treq, but at the same time has zero endproduct and zero shooting.... so in the end he is everywhere doing fukin nothing.

Completely agree. Very average player. He's just there.

He is very skilled in shying away from the limelight as well, so he keeps himself out of criticism, because he simply does nothing.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,988
:tup:

What a downgrade compared to vidal and Pogba who never shyed away from responsabilities. Pogba had issues in being an egomaniac and was kinda dumb sometime, but when on his day, both of those 2 dudes practically carried the mdifield.

Our current crop is just too average in comparison.
 

Buck Fuddy

Lara Chedraoui fanboy
May 22, 2009
10,888
you've got to be the most hipster poster here,
I try :D

despises Higuain signing,
I despise his cost.
Or in other words: There are smarter ways to spend such an amount.


doesn't rate Benatia,
I don't think he's a bad player though.

But he might just be the most overrated player on the entire forum. :D


has a soft spot for Sturaro,
Not really. But I do find it amusing how he's always the one being singled out.

Look at last night: for the life of me, I can't even come up with 3 players who performed better than him. But hey, Sturaro is clearly a limited player, so let's bitch about him anyway.


did I miss something? :D
Yeah, I'm not a fan of Pjanic either. :D


That's not true at all. We spent big on Higuain, but let go of Pogba for even more.
Spending over 120 million on 2 players is considered being cautious these days?
 

Red

-------
Moderator
Nov 26, 2006
47,024
I wonder if Juve will ever accept the need to play long and miss out the midfield in certain games?

Fiorentina blocked up the midfield effectively. With little danger of Juve playing though the midfield and no sign of Juve playing long, Fiorentina were able to keep their defensive line high and keep the game almost entirely in Juve's half of the pitch and press Juve hard.

Juve failed to address this issue and kept playing the game Fiorentina wanted and kept playing short passes into midfield that just invited more and more pressure from Fiorentina.

Just the occasional long ball could have helped to force Fiorentina's defence back a bit and/or force Fiorentina's midfield to think about the space between them and the defence. Both those things would make it harder for Fiorentina to commit to such an intense press.

And then Juve might have been able to start playing the ball through midfield.


Fiorentina certainly didn't bother playing the though midfield much. Their first thought was mostly to go long to Kalinic and then squeeze players up behind him to compete for the lose ball (see first goal). It was tricky, windy conditions and so it was going to be hard for defenders to consistently judge the flight of the ball and make proper clearances and so Fiorentina made use of that and played a low-risk style that put Juve under considerable pressure.

This approach was more effective than it should have been due to Juve's defenders not dealing with Kalinic. Kalinic's movement was good, as it always is, and he showed a bit more aggression than he usually does, but he wasn't doing anything that should have allowed him to occupy three defenders in the way he did. Real lack of aggression from Juve's back three.


In years gone by it was understandable that Juve were very much wedded to the idea of always playing through midfield. I didn't necessarily think it was the right thing to do at times, but with the extraordinary midfield they had, that approach could be justified. Juve no longer have an exceptional midfield, but their approach to games hasn't really changed and that is causing problems.
 

Hydde

Minimiliano Tristelli
Mar 6, 2003
38,988
I wonder if Juve will ever accept the need to play long and miss out the midfield in certain games?

Fiorentina blocked up the midfield effectively. With little danger of Juve playing though the midfield and no sign of Juve playing long, Fiorentina were able to keep their defensive line high and keep the game almost entirely in Juve's half of the pitch and press Juve hard.

Juve failed to address this issue and kept playing the game Fiorentina wanted and kept playing short passes into midfield that just invited more and more pressure from Fiorentina.

Just the occasional long ball could have helped to force Fiorentina's defence back a bit and/or force Fiorentina's midfield to think about the space between them and the defence. Both those things would make it harder for Fiorentina to commit to such an intense press.

And then Juve might have been able to start playing the ball through midfield.


Fiorentina certainly didn't bother playing the though midfield much. Their first thought was mostly to go long to Kalinic and then squeeze players up behind him to compete for the lose ball (see first goal). It was tricky, windy conditions and so it was going to be hard for defenders to consistently judge the flight of the ball and make proper clearances and so Fiorentina made use of that and played a low-risk style that put Juve under considerable pressure.

This approach was more effective than it should have been due to Juve's defenders not dealing with Kalinic. Kalinic's movement was good, as it always is, and he showed a bit more aggression than he usually does, but he wasn't doing anything that should have allowed him to occupy three defenders in the way he did. Real lack of aggression from Juve's back three.


In years gone by it was understandable that Juve were very much wedded to the idea of always playing through midfield. I didn't necessarily think it was the right thing to do at times, but with the extraordinary midfield they had, that approach could be justified. Juve no longer have an exceptional midfield, but their approach to games hasn't really changed and that is causing problems.
:tup:
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
I try :D
I despise his cost.
Or in other words: There are smarter ways to spend such an amount.
I don't think he's a bad player though.
But he might just be the most overrated player on the entire forum. :D
Not really. But I do find it amusing how he's always the one being singled out.
Look at last night: for the life of me, I can't even come up with 3 players who performed better than him. But hey, Sturaro is clearly a limited player, so let's bitch about him anyway.
Yeah, I'm not a fan of Pjanic either. :D
so sack Marotta or give him another summer?
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
No point in sacking anyone from the people in charge.

They have done great overall ever since they took over. Exceeded all expectations, if you ask me.
:tup:
IMO Pjanič is a similar situation to Pirlo in his last season with us, he has great overall quality that can contribute much needed goals and assists, but having him on the pitch also is a great disadvantage, because he doesn't put in much work
 

Kopanja

Senior Member
Jul 30, 2015
5,594
:tup:
IMO Pjanič is a similar situation to Pirlo in his last season with us, he has great overall quality that can contribute much needed goals and assists, but having him on the pitch also is a great disadvantage, because he doesn't put in much work
I am not sure it's a correct statement about Pjanic not working much. He runs a lot, yeah he is not Makelele in terms of tackling, but who is? Midfield just doesn't work, click at all. In a proper setup your weakness are covered by teammates, but in our case each players weakness is exposed and exploited by every opponent (Sturaros zero ball skills, Khediras slowness and softness etc.)
 

IliveForJuve

Burn this club
Jan 17, 2011
18,932
I wonder if Juve will ever accept the need to play long and miss out the midfield in certain games?

Fiorentina blocked up the midfield effectively. With little danger of Juve playing though the midfield and no sign of Juve playing long, Fiorentina were able to keep their defensive line high and keep the game almost entirely in Juve's half of the pitch and press Juve hard.

Juve failed to address this issue and kept playing the game Fiorentina wanted and kept playing short passes into midfield that just invited more and more pressure from Fiorentina.

Just the occasional long ball could have helped to force Fiorentina's defence back a bit and/or force Fiorentina's midfield to think about the space between them and the defence. Both those things would make it harder for Fiorentina to commit to such an intense press.

And then Juve might have been able to start playing the ball through midfield.


Fiorentina certainly didn't bother playing the though midfield much. Their first thought was mostly to go long to Kalinic and then squeeze players up behind him to compete for the lose ball (see first goal). It was tricky, windy conditions and so it was going to be hard for defenders to consistently judge the flight of the ball and make proper clearances and so Fiorentina made use of that and played a low-risk style that put Juve under considerable pressure.

This approach was more effective than it should have been due to Juve's defenders not dealing with Kalinic. Kalinic's movement was good, as it always is, and he showed a bit more aggression than he usually does, but he wasn't doing anything that should have allowed him to occupy three defenders in the way he did. Real lack of aggression from Juve's back three.


In years gone by it was understandable that Juve were very much wedded to the idea of always playing through midfield. I didn't necessarily think it was the right thing to do at times, but with the extraordinary midfield they had, that approach could be justified. Juve no longer have an exceptional midfield, but their approach to games hasn't really changed and that is causing problems.
I actually missed your analyses. :D

In your opinion, what do you think should be our starting XI and in which formation?

Do you agree that a 4312 would work better than our current setup?

Buffon
Licht - Bonucci - Rugani - Sandro
Khedira - Marchisio - Rincon/Lemina
Pjanic
Dybala - Higuain​
 
OP
Marc

Marc

Softcore Juventino
Jul 14, 2006
21,649
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #275
    Here are my ratings:

    Buffon 5.5
    Barzagli 5
    Bonucci 5.5
    Chiellini 5
    Cuadrado 5
    Khedira 5
    Marchisio 5
    Sturaro 5
    Alex Sandro 5
    Dybala 4.5 Worst player on the pitch for Juve
    Higuain 6.5 Best player on the pitch for Juve
    Pjaca 5.5

    - - - Updated - - -

    By the way, :allegri: is :stupid: for not playing Pjanić from the start.
     
    OP
    Marc

    Marc

    Softcore Juventino
    Jul 14, 2006
    21,649
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #277
    We need new, quality players in midfield department, not a new logo, ffs.

    - - - Updated - - -

    I am curious to see what the new logo will look like, though. :D
     

    Red

    -------
    Moderator
    Nov 26, 2006
    47,024
    I actually missed your analyses. :D

    In your opinion, what do you think should be our starting XI and in which formation?

    Do you agree that a 4312 would work better than our current setup?

    Buffon
    Licht - Bonucci - Rugani - Sandro
    Khedira - Marchisio - Rincon/Lemina
    Pjanic
    Dybala - Higuain​
    I'm not sure about the best team just now.

    I don't like 4-3-1-2 as a general rule.

    But broadly speaking Juve are missing a midfielder with energy and drive to give the balance that is needed with Marchisio and Khedira. Juve need to play Sturaro to give the energy to over the space, but that obviously comes at the cost of technique.

    And if you don't have the energy or drive in midfield, you need the forwards to do more. Obviously Higuain and Dybala are good players, but they aren't the players to stretch a game and work a defence in the way that would help Juve's midfield just now. Mandzukic would try, but he isn't quick enough to really do it.

    So those factors push me to feeling more has to come from Juve in wide areas. But only Alex Sandro can consistently give a lot from fullback.

    So I don't think there is a good option for Juve without a new signing.

    Best i could come up with just now would be an awkward lop-sided sort of shape:

    Buffon

    Lichtsteiner-Bonucci-???????-Sandro

    Cuadrado-??????-Marchisio-Pjanic

    Dybala

    Higuain​

    Pjanic can drift towards trequartista as Alex Sandro pushes up that flank.
     

    zizinho

    Senior Member
    Apr 14, 2013
    51,816
    I'm not sure about the best team just now.

    I don't like 4-3-1-2 as a general rule.

    But broadly speaking Juve are missing a midfielder with energy and drive to give the balance that is needed with Marchisio and Khedira. Juve need to play Sturaro to give the energy to over the space, but that obviously comes at the cost of technique.

    And if you don't have the energy or drive in midfield, you need the forwards to do more. Obviously Higuain and Dybala are good players, but they aren't the players to stretch a game and work a defence in the way that would help Juve's midfield just now. Mandzukic would try, but he isn't quick enough to really do it.

    So those factors push me to feeling more has to come from Juve in wide areas. But only Alex Sandro can consistently give a lot from fullback.

    So I don't think there is a good option for Juve without a new signing.

    Best i could come up with just now would be an awkward lop-sided sort of shape:

    Buffon

    Lichtsteiner-Bonucci-???????-Sandro

    Cuadrado-??????-Marchisio-Pjanic

    Dybala

    Higuain​

    Pjanic can drift towards trequartista as Alex Sandro pushes up that flank.
    Thats a 352 mate :allegri:

    But yeah, we need that energetic CM
     

    Red

    -------
    Moderator
    Nov 26, 2006
    47,024
    Thats a 352 mate :allegri:

    But yeah, we need that energetic CM
    Not far off it.

    Juve's squad still looks to me to be built for 3-5-2 more than anything else.

    But if it is 3-5-2 then I think Khedira is the player who needs to miss out to get Pjanic in.

    Khedira is undoubtedly a better player than the other options, but all the other option for midfield (that I can think of) are more suited to playing with Marchisio and Pjanic.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 2)