Sebastian Giovinco (31 Viewers)

Would you bring Giovinco back next season?

  • Yeah, we could use him

  • Nope, get rid of him


Results are only viewable after voting.

Raz

Senior Member
Nov 20, 2005
12,218
I'm all for Gio to play, to get his chance ant to prove that he is capable.

But i don't think that Gio is the same player as Diego is and i think he should play more in the sides then in the middle. Unless he muscles up more then he might be good in the middle too. Anyway, I'm all for giving Gio chances to shine and play.
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
116,877
You know, I understand that everyone wants him to be a regular on the starting XI.


I get that. I would like that as well.

But maybe, just maybe, how he has been used, as far as being a super-sub, might be the best thing for him
That is what I am trying to say.


There is nothing wrong with him playing 30-40 minutes per match, or coming on when Juve need a boost to take advantage of the opposition's tired legs.

But if you want him to play 90 minutes per match, then unless he greatly increases his physical stamina and strength, he is eventually going to be a liability.

My issues with Ranieri's handling of him wasn't so much the fact that he didn't play him every week, it was just that when there were moments when this team really could ahve used his energy and creativity, the fucking knucklehead didn't play him.
But Sergio, where have we seen Giovinco get outmuscled constantly that it affects his game?

Against sides for the U-21's, I've never seen him really get destroyed and then become too physically weak to keep competing. Sure, I've seen him become exhausted and have to be subbed, but that happens to everyone.

From what I saw last season, I only saw Sebastian get outmuscled and look weak once in Serie A. But on the other hand, he played 30 good minutes against Chelsea, basically owning strong players such as Essien and Bosingwa, so he's shown he can play with the big boys in every sense of the wordage.

I just think we need to give him more chances, consistently, before we start saying we should only use him as a super sub. This may be extremely premature. After all, the boy is still young and I'm sure he has tons of stamina, so all he needs to do is hit the gym. If he does that, still gets outmuscled consistently by a variety of teams later in the game, then we can think about using him as a sub, IMO.

You could be right, but I hope not. :D
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,789
But Sergio, where have we seen Giovinco get outmuscled constantly that it affects his game?

Against sides for the U-21's, I've never seen him really get destroyed and then become too physically weak to keep competing. Sure, I've seen him become exhausted and have to be subbed, but that happens to everyone.

From what I saw last season, I only saw Sebastian get outmuscled and look weak once in Serie A. But on the other hand, he played 30 good minutes against Chelsea, basically owning strong players such as Essien and Bosingwa, so he's shown he can play with the big boys in every sense of the wordage.

I just think we need to give him more chances, consistently, before we start saying we should only use him as a super sub. This may be extremely premature. After all, the boy is still young and I'm sure he has tons of stamina, so all he needs to do is hit the gym. If he does that, still gets outmuscled consistently by a variety of teams later in the game, then we can think about using him as a sub, IMO.

You could be right, but I hope not. :D

But that is my point. These, and other moments like these, are when we see him at his best.

In controlled doses, so to speak
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,789
Andy, you mentioned that he could hit the gym.

Do you think that he has the type of frame that he could add 10-15 lbs of muscle, and still retain all of that quickness of which his game is predicated upon??

You're trading one aspect of his game for another.

If he can add that kind of muscle and still be explosive, hey, that's all the better for everyone involved.

But unfortunately, I can't base my opinion on "what ifs" in this circumstance
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
116,877
Andy, you mentioned that he could hit the gym.

Do you think that he has the type of frame that he could add 10-15 lbs of muscle, and still retain all of that quickness of which his game is predicated upon??

You're trading one aspect of his game for another.

If he can add that kind of muscle and still be explosive, hey, that's all the better for everyone involved.

But unfortunately, I can't base my opinion on "what ifs" in this circumstance
Hmm, didn't Zola do something similar?

And even if he isn't able to add any muscle, we still shouldn't count him out yet.
 

Cronios

Juventolog
Jun 7, 2004
27,526
Mature players are stronger than U21, but they are not as fast and agile.
Every time Giovinco enters as a sub, one marker of the opposition gets booked, trying to catch/stop him.
He is very "explosive" at this age, we must harvest this advantage asap...
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,433
But Sergio, where have we seen Giovinco get outmuscled constantly that it affects his game?

Against sides for the U-21's, I've never seen him really get destroyed and then become too physically weak to keep competing. Sure, I've seen him become exhausted and have to be subbed, but that happens to everyone.

From what I saw last season, I only saw Sebastian get outmuscled and look weak once in Serie A. But on the other hand, he played 30 good minutes against Chelsea, basically owning strong players such as Essien and Bosingwa, so he's shown he can play with the big boys in every sense of the wordage.

I just think we need to give him more chances, consistently, before we start saying we should only use him as a super sub. This may be extremely premature. After all, the boy is still young and I'm sure he has tons of stamina, so all he needs to do is hit the gym. If he does that, still gets outmuscled consistently by a variety of teams later in the game, then we can think about using him as a sub, IMO.

You could be right, but I hope not. :D
There's your problem, Andy. Giovinco's already strong. He's quite broad and is very agile, but I don't think he can build that much more muscle mass. Look at his legs for instance. They're hardly skinny. At some point the gym will affect his game.
 

KB824

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2003
31,789
Mature players are stronger than U21, but they are not as fast and agile.
Every time Giovinco enters as a sub, one marker of the opposition gets booked, trying to catch/stop him.
He is very "explosive" at this age, we must harvest this advantage asap...
So the question that remains, given everything that is in front of us, is, how does he get used, so that his talent is maximized every time he is on the pitch
 

Suns

Release clause?
May 22, 2009
22,107
He should be a starter and play as any other player from start. Not play the last 20 minutes as if he was a 39 year old retard. He played a few games as a starter last season and did well. If he gets tired then we should sub him, that's all.
 

Luca

Senior Member
Apr 22, 2007
12,751
He should be a starter and play as any other player from start. Not play the last 20 minutes as if he was a 39 year old retard. He played a few games as a starter last season and did well. If he gets tired then we should sub him, that's all.
so then how do we accomodate him in a balenced formation and why does he deserve to start ahead of the others?
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 29)