I'd have to agree from my perspective.
I gave it a 4.
Reasons to give it lower:
* Refereeing mistakes: way too many, way too many bad ones. Mitigating factor: most of the worst mistakes didn't make that much difference in the ultimate results.
- Also: the refs were too soft on cards in the semi-finals
* Goalkeeping was terrible for the most part. I won't blame the ball, however.
* Level of play was poor sometimes, particularly in the Group Stages.
Reasons to give it higher:
* I cannot say enough about the South Africans as hosts of this thing. The people were not only of good, friendly spirit, these guys love their football as much as any other footballing nation. The electricity in the streets -- the kind of thing you feel when you're at a Juve match and their announcing the players with the loud music -- was all in evidence here among the fans, eventhough their team was well out of the tournament.
- Here's a little video I took yesterday in Cape Town, some 1200km from the Final match:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEUs1vX1Pfw. Doesn't matter who was in the Final, these guys have football fever in spades.
- The vuvuzelas were cool. These aren't a recent invention here: people grew up playing football in school and had vuvuzelas at even those matches. It would have been criminal to deny the home country of something so identified with the passion of the sport represented by South Africans.
* In the end, they may not have played the football everyone expected, but IMO the best team, and most deserving, in the tournament won.
* Teams that didn't deserve to do much got their just rewards -- i.e., France, Italy, England