Player ratings after each match (20 Viewers)

[Stu]

[EDIT: Creating a new thread for this discussion of how we could create a sort of panel of Juventuz members who could provide player ratings after each match ... and possible technologies to help support showing average match ratings, etc. (An idea originated by Andy/RochemBeck.) -- swag]

Actually, I've made a post about it in the bat cave, asking Keith if he could make something for us. I was also thinking about selecting 10-15 members who get to see the matches, and who are at least somewhat objective.

I think having ten or so objective members who see a lot of our games give the ratings is the best thing to do otherwise we might have people voting Del Piero for MOM every game just because he's their favourite player.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Zlatan]

Exactly. I'm thinking about 10-15 so that even if not everyone votes, whether it's because they didnt see that particular match, or didnt have time or the opportunity, we'd still get a decent average from several members.

 

[Seven]

Exactly. I'm thinking about 10-15 so that even if not everyone votes, whether it's because they didnt see that particular match, or didnt have time or the opportunity, we'd still get a decent average from several members.

So how will these 15 members be selected?

 

[Zlatan]

TBH we'll probably pick them in the mods room based on who we think would be right for the job. No other way is realistic.

 

[Seven]

TBH we'll probably pick them in the mods room based on who we think would be right for the job. No other way is realistic.

I'm a bit scared it'll be a one sided affaire in that case.

Anyway, if you need me, here I am, but somehow I doubt you'll select me

 

[Zlatan]

I wouldnt worry about that TBH.

 

[Seven]

I do hope Keith manages to get us a rating system though. It's a lot more fair than selecting a MoM.

 

[Zlatan]

I do hope Keith manages to get us a rating system though. It's a lot more fair than selecting a MoM.

Keith is good at what he does, I dont think it should be a big issue.

 

[Dragon]

I'm a bit scared it'll be a one sided affaire in that case.

Anyway, if you need me, here I am, but somehow I doubt you'll select me

If I were a mod Id choose

- Vinni
- Z
- Jack
- Andries
- Andy
- Gino Genesio
- Stu
- Isha00 (I dont know her real name)
- Denco
- Pado
- Tom
- Azzurri7
- Espectro

This way there would be a mix of most mentalities

 

[JCK]

Who's Jack?

 

[Seven]

If I were a mod Id choose

- Vinni
- Z
- Jack
- Andries
- Andy
- Gino Genesio
- Stu
- Isha00 (I dont know her real name)
- Denco
- Pado
- Tom
- Azzurri7
- Espectro

This way there would be a mix of most mentalities

Seems decent, although I haven't seen Isha00 around lately.

 

[Dragon]

Who's Jack?

You


Isnt that your real name?

 

[Zlatan]

If I were a mod Id choose

- Vinni
- Z
- Jack
- Andries
- Andy
- Gino Genesio
- Stu
- Isha00 (I dont know her real name)
- Denco
- Pado
- Tom
- Azzurri7
- Espectro

This way there would be a mix of most mentalities

Without Vinni and Denco IMO.

Vinnie tends to overreact when we lose and denco isnt regular enough to be able to cound on him. If he logged every week then he'd be a given.

 

[Dragon]

Without Vinni and Denco IMO.

Vinnie tends to overreact when we lose and denco isnt regular enough to be able to cound on him. If he logged every week then he'd be a given.

That is exactly why I put Vinni on the list. There are some fans that are just like him, and what we want is a representation of every kind of Juve fan.

About Denco, I guess youre right

 

[JCK]

You


Isnt that your real name?

 

[Zlatan]

I dont think we need a representation of every Juve fan, we need members that will tell it like it is. I fear Vinni would give everyone a 1 when we lose

 

[Dragon]

I dont think we need a representation of every Juve fan, we need members that will tell it like it is. I fear Vinni would give everyone a 1 when we lose

Sometimes some members are blinded by the real truth and Vinni tells it like it is. I will admit that he overreacts sometimes, but he's also realist. We dont want members who live in a Juve Fantasyland filled with black and white unicorns

 

[Zlatan]

True, and I dont think any of the others on the list live in that land.

 

[Tifoso]

True, and I dont think any of the others on the list live in that land.

JUVE rocks!

 

[Zlatan]

JUVE rocks!

Except Lou