Paulo Dybala (195 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***


  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

Monty

Tuz Royalty
May 2, 2017
2,592
Of course not Roma

But Juve for sure as the foundations are there

My point is Juve is only a messi away from being CL favourites, and Dybala can raise his level one more notch higher and we'd be there

He's been given the tactical freedom to do that here as well as the iconic 10 shirt

If he goes anywhere else, because he thinks he'll have a better chance to win the CL, well at RM and Barca it'll still be because of Ronaldo and Messi, at Man City it will still be Guardiola and he woudnt add much to what they are doing, and Man united and PSG still dont have the foundations

That leaves bayern and I dont watch them much, but take out lewa and I dont know how they'd fare

As Nedved said yesterday , " I reiterate that it is up to him to make the history of Juventus and, if he wants, that of world football"
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
Barcelona had Messi, Neymar, Suarez, Iniesta, etc lasts year and they still weren't CL favourites and got absolutely thrashed by us.

Roma CL favourites with Messi? Lol no. Not even close.
Depends on the coach imo. If a great coach like Simeone had made this Roma into a grit machine with Dzeko-Messi upfront and fit de Rossi-Nainggolan in the middle, I'd say they are CL contenders. CL favorites? Aint no such thing, thats why I love football, we're in March and no ones got any idea who are clear CL favorites, is it Barca, Real, Bayern, City, Juve? Could make a case for all, maybe a bit of a longshot for Juve
 

Post Ironic

Senior Member
Feb 9, 2013
42,253
Of course not Roma

But Juve for sure as the foundations are there

My point is Juve is only a messi away from being CL favourites, and Dybala can raise his level one more notch higher and we'd be there

He's been given the tactical freedom to do that here as well as the iconic 10 shirt

If he goes anywhere else, because he thinks he'll have a better chance to win the CL, well at RM and Barca it'll still be because of Ronaldo and Messi, at Man City it will still be Guardiola and he woudnt add much to what they are doing, and Man united and PSG still dont have the foundations

That leaves bayern and I dont watch them much, but take out lewa and I dont know how they'd fare

As Nedved said yesterday , " I reiterate that it is up to him to make the history of Juventus and, if he wants, that of world football"
:tup:
6 of last 9 CL titles have been won by Real Madrid and Barcelona not because they play "attacking football", but because they play attacking football with some of the best attacking players in the history of the game.

People here whine about us not playing "attacking football" but if we focus on all-out attack we will get beat by the rich teams with better attackers. We would have lost to Barca last year in the quarters and Madrid in 14-15 in the semis without our organization and defensive focus. We don't have the class of attackers to win a shootout with these teams and thankfully Allegri knows this. We've closed the gap, certainly, which is why we can compete and get to CL finals by playing organized, tactically sound, defensive football. It is the same thing with Atletico Madrid.

Give us a Messi and we become the best team in football because we would then have the firepower to win shootouts against top teams.
 
OP
Dostoevsky

Dostoevsky

Tzu
Administrator
May 27, 2007
88,980
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #14,924
    :tup:
    6 of last 9 CL titles have been won by Real Madrid and Barcelona not because they play "attacking football", but because they play attacking football with some of the best attacking players in the history of the game.

    People here whine about us not playing "attacking football" but if we focus on all-out attack we will get beat by the rich teams with better attackers. We would have lost to Barca last year in the quarters and Madrid in 14-15 in the semis without our organization and defensive focus. We don't have the class of attackers to win a shootout with these teams and thankfully Allegri knows this. We've closed the gap, certainly, which is why we can compete and get to CL finals by playing organized, tactically sound, defensive football. It is the same thing with Atletico Madrid.

    Give us a Messi and we become the best team in football because we would then have the firepower to win shootouts against top teams.
    Gap might be closed but not because we have gotten better but because Ronaldo and Messi are starting to fade away due to their age. If anything, we have gotten weaker over the past years.
     

    Post Ironic

    Senior Member
    Feb 9, 2013
    42,253
    Gap might be closed but not because we have gotten better but because Ronaldo and Messi are starting to fade away due to their age. If anything, we have gotten weaker over the past years.
    We are weaker this year, mostly because Khedira has fallen off a cliff and Marchisio has never recovered form. Add to that we have no starting quality RB.

    But we certainly were not weaker last year. A domestic double, and a CL final. We improved our attack and our FBs by a large measure from 2014-15 at the expense of our midfield. The two team had very different strengths, but were of a very similar level of quality.

    Ronaldo has 22 goals in his last 13 CL matches. Hardly fading. He will fade, but it has not happened yet.

    We need to fix our midfield aside from Pjanic and Matuidi. And we need a top class RB. While keeping our team together. Then we have the strongest Juventus post-calciopoli. Unfortunately I don't see that happening without selling. So 1 step forward, 1 step back remains the name of the game. (or in the case of this past summer, probably 1.5 steps back :( )
     
    OP
    Dostoevsky

    Dostoevsky

    Tzu
    Administrator
    May 27, 2007
    88,980
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #14,926
    We are weaker this year, mostly because Khedira has fallen off a cliff and Marchisio has never recovered form. Add to that we have no starting quality RB.

    But we certainly were not weaker last year. A domestic double, and a CL final. We improved our attack and our FBs by a large measure from 2014-15 at the expense of our midfield. The two team had very different strengths, but were of a very similar level of quality.

    Ronaldo has 22 goals in his last 13 CL matches. Hardly fading. He will fade, but it has not happened yet.

    We need to fix our midfield aside from Pjanic and Matuidi. And we need a top class RB. While keeping our team together. Then we have the strongest Juventus post-calciopoli. Unfortunately I don't see that happening without selling. So 1 step forward, 1 step back remains the name of the game. (or in the case of this past summer, probably 1.5 steps back :( )
    Yeah. It's not like I can disagree with that but from a fan standpoint of view it's rather annoying to see our club selling players. It's going to be pointless if we sign a good mid or a RB but end up selling Sandro or Dybala. IMO it's 1.5-2 steps backwards :D and imo we won't see anything different this summer. It's gonna be another huge break if Allegri decides to leave or we fire him. I can't see the light at the end of the tunnel at the moment. We're a good team. But we can't break it through nor it looks likely to change that.
     

    Nedved96

    Senior Member
    Sep 1, 2017
    7,198
    Of course not Roma

    But Juve for sure as the foundations are there

    My point is Juve is only a messi away from being CL favourites, and Dybala can raise his level one more notch higher and we'd be there
    No we are not, our midfield is terrible. Tottenham walked through us at Wembley, and a better side would have punished us much harder.
     

    Bianconero81

    Ageing Veteran
    Jan 26, 2009
    40,174
    Of course not Roma

    But Juve for sure as the foundations are there

    My point is Juve is only a messi away from being CL favourites, and Dybala can raise his level one more notch higher and we'd be there

    He's been given the tactical freedom to do that here as well as the iconic 10 shirt

    If he goes anywhere else, because he thinks he'll have a better chance to win the CL, well at RM and Barca it'll still be because of Ronaldo and Messi, at Man City it will still be Guardiola and he woudnt add much to what they are doing, and Man united and PSG still dont have the foundations

    That leaves bayern and I dont watch them much, but take out lewa and I dont know how they'd fare

    As Nedved said yesterday , " I reiterate that it is up to him to make the history of Juventus and, if he wants, that of world football"
    Incredibly simplistic notion. One Messi doesn't simply mask midfield deficiencies that are evidently there, particularly when compared to the top teams. One Messi and a top quality midfield reinforcement and we can be considered CL favorites.
     

    Maddy

    Oracle of Copenhagen
    Jul 10, 2009
    16,545
    Incredibly simplistic notion. One Messi doesn't simply mask midfield deficiencies that are evidently there, particularly when compared to the top teams. One Messi and a top quality midfield reinforcement and we can be considered CL favorites.
    :agree:

    We are one Messi, one Kroos and one Casemiro away from being CL favourites.
     

    Maddy

    Oracle of Copenhagen
    Jul 10, 2009
    16,545
    And one Carvajal

    Although if we had Kroos, Casemiro and Carvajal, then I don’t think we would need Messi. Dybala would be good enough to win us the CL.
    No need for Carvajal. But I agree with two world class midfielders we wouldn't need Messi to be among the favourites (perhaps the favourite).
     

    Cerval

    Senior Member
    Feb 20, 2016
    26,829
    So inconsistent, can't rely on this guy at all.
    I'm curious as to why you didn't post this in Higuain's thread too

    I don't think either is deserving of saying that. Dybala scored four goals in the last three games coming back from injury. He's still not completely consistent and his period of form comes into burst periods, that's still confidence related and he's working on it.

    Given the fact he was productive before coming into the game, why saying we can't rely on him based on one game?
     

    DAiDEViL

    Senior Member
    Feb 21, 2015
    64,590
    I'm curious as to why you didn't post this in Higuain's thread too
    Because i expect more from a player with Dybala's skillset. He's so frustrating to watch, knowing what he can do on his day. Can't build a team around a player that shows up every 2nd game.

    - - - Updated - - -

    No, not based on one game. He's having plenty of games in which he doesn't get the simplest things right and i don't see it improving much. You never know which version of him shows up.
     

    Quetzalcoatl

    It ain't hard to tell
    Aug 22, 2007
    66,755
    Because i expect more from a player with Dybala's skillset. He's so frustrating to watch, knowing what he can do on his day. Can't build a team around a player that shows up every 2nd game.

    - - - Updated - - -

    No, not based on one game. He's having plenty of games in which he doesn't get the simplest things right and i don't see it improving much. You never know which version of him shows up.
    Agreed.

    Slightly overrated but he's the best we got, on his day
     

    Cerval

    Senior Member
    Feb 20, 2016
    26,829
    Because i expect more from a player with Dybala's skillset. He's so frustrating to watch, knowing what he can do on his day. Can't build a team around a player that shows up every 2nd game.

    - - - Updated - - -

    No, not based on one game. He's having plenty of games in which he doesn't get the simplest things right and i don't see it improving much. You never know which version of him shows up.
    I agree with the bolded part although I do think he has it in him to fulfill expectations, it's up to him in the end. In regards to the rest we relied on him during crunch time against both Lazio and Spurs, so I can't care less about him not showing up against SPAL - once in 4 games after getting back from injury. I'd much rather him being decisive when it matters and besides nobody showed up today. Still think he's actively working on being more consistent and that he'll improve
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 167)