I'm not even sure I want him to renew or not...
Feel the same but it depends on the cost and this will be long. Juve is between a rock and a hard place. With CR7 gone and no decent replacement what options does AA have? Presently it's a struggle for Juve to score goals and as we have seen of late #10 has played like a superstar. I would tend to sign him to a 3 yr/30M deal with plenty of incentives for him to earn the money he wants (deserves?). His body tells me not to trust he can hold up for a 4/5 year contract. Don't want have another player we have to beg to leave or won't.
Like I stated Dybala holding most of the cards unless Juve says screw this finding replaccements for him and Morata this summer .And I agree with Pegi of his lacking physicality meaning what will this guy play like at 32? Looks like a kid but don't believe his body will hold up for maintaining max performance.
What I do see is how much he loves Juve with wanting to wear the #10 and being captain. And with no guarantee contract past this year he has played his balls off when healthy. See plenty of US players priority being do not get injured in that situation. So good for #10 playing for as much money as he thinks he deserves. My feeling is Dybala has had plenty of chances to leave already and might be bluffing on give in to my demands or I'm gone.
Bottom line is no CR7 so now top dog at a prestigious club like Juve. He might get his money but he'll never be that at a club the level of Juve. Euro soccer signings seems to me different than US ones more based more on what the club thinks you will do instead of what you already done. First 3 years at Juve Dybala in league had 52 goals and 19 assists and I believe paid well. Last 3 years only 20 goals and 13 assists. Blame injuries though but last season only one with 1K less average minutes from previous seasons. Though he has done quite well in CL action.
That's why I go the 3 yrs/30m with incentives. Hey, if #10 is so confident in his ability he should have no problem knowing he will get the money he wants or more either from Juve or another club in a couple years. Just out of Juve desperation I would be quite surprised if he doesn't sign. 90% Y/10% N