Paulo Dybala (112 Viewers)

Legend or Rookie? ***non-official poll***


  • Total voters
    140
  • Poll closed .

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
33,739
Nah.

Beginning of February last season Ronaldo had 20 something goals, all the others below including Dybala and Higuain barely combined for his tally.

Dybala scored 6 of his 11 goals in first 7 games post COVID restart last season. Then nothing again in the final 8. So his remaining 5 goals were scored in 23 games before COVID. 5G 7A in 23 games, decent for your average Serie A player, hardly decisive and crucial for us.

He also did not have 14 assists, counting FKs and PKs won as an assist is crazy. Penalties and FKs are also not 'won', they are mistakes from opposing players. If we are praising him for 'winning' penalties why do people blame our players when they concede a PK? Opposing player 'won' it.

He had 8 ast in total on the season.
i didn't even mention how many assists he had... anyway, the best part is this: Penalties and FKs are also not 'won', they are mistakes from opposing players. buddy, let's be real here, 99% of goals happen after defensive mistakes. forcing a defensive mistake is the essential point of the attacking phase of football, and the best attacking players are the best in their jobs because they are able to force those defending errors. of course players who draw more fouls deserve credit for it. it's a skill, and there's a reason why cuadrado and cr are better in it than berna or kulusevski: they are better attacking players. and if drawing fouls happen in the penalty area, that's definitely a decisive skill.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Zzak

Senior Member
Sep 11, 2014
826
He's turning 28 at the end of the year and for a player of his style/build, that's past his prime.
He's been missing that extra hunger that he had when he first joined us and wanted to prove himself. I remember when he wrestled Parrollo and still managed to shoot and score while falling in the dying minutes of a Lazio game.

He's also lost a bit of pace and aggressiveness along the way. I would say 55 million would be a good deal for him considering the Covid situation. Would also give Kulu and Chiesa more playing time.
If we could invest that money in a solid midfielder then I would say it would be a win.
 

IlCapitano

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2012
5,614
i didn't even mention how many assists he had... anyway, the best part is this: Penalties and FKs are also not 'won', they are mistakes from opposing players. buddy, let's be real here, 99% of goals happen after defensive mistakes. forcing a defensive mistake is the essential point of the attacking phase of football, and the best attacking players are the best in their jobs because they are able to force those defending errors. of course players who draw more fouls deserve credit for it. it's a skill, and there's a reason why cuadrado and cr are better in it than berna or kulusevski: they are better attacking players. and if drawing fouls happen in the penalty area, that's definitely a decisive skill.
It is pretty clear when a goal is scored from good team play and when it is a braindead mistake. Nobody is praising Benzema and Bale for 1st and 3rd goal in CL final, they crucified Karius.

Technically every goal is a mistake yes, you can always do better, but as I said it is clear when it is braindead and when it is team play.

Winning PKs and FKs is a pretty thin straw to hold on for someone who is supposed to be decisive. They are random, they are not something you can rely on consitently. Unless you are Ole and Man Utd ofc.

Same thing for a player scoring 6 in 7 games, then 5 in other 31. Not reliable, not consitent and not decisive for some time now.
 

Valerio.

Senior Member
Jul 5, 2014
5,766
See if we don't make a trade for Dybala.

"
Barca to offer Griezmann for Dybala this summer (source: Goal)
"

sadly he is on 1 and half year left of contract and we don't wanna renew for what he ask.

- - - Updated - - -

I would trade him for Griezmann... if we don't need another winger/second striker

- - - Updated - - -

  • All'anno: 23.518.541,00 €
he gets 23.5m gross year so 11.75m/year but coming outside of Italy we would prolly pay 18m gross to give me the same net as he get at Barca
 

IlCapitano

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2012
5,614
Griezmann and Dybala play the same position and tactically we would have the same issues.

Griezz at his best is better than Dybala, but also earns double or triple of him rn.

Much rather sell Dybala and invest in a midfielder
 
OP
Dostoevsky

Dostoevsky

Tzu
Administrator
May 27, 2007
89,018
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #29,536
    Grizzy would be perfect for this team man.
    He's gonna be 30 in a couple of days and he hasn't even scored much for Barca. Just like Pogba's case, it's not just his price, but his crazy high wages. I don't think he's worth it, especially since we'd have him for 3-4 seasons and that's about it. I'd rather invest in younger players.
     

    Bjerknes

    "Top Economist"
    Mar 16, 2004
    116,146
    Griezmann and Dybala play the same position and tactically we would have the same issues.
    Not exactly. Griez can play on the left side and as a central striker if needs be. Dybala is pretty much a left-sided attacker and that's it.

    I don't put as much stake in Griez failing at Barca as others do. That club has been in disarray for a while and everything revolves around one player before, during, and after each match. Griez was excellent in Madrid and did well for France. If we had Allegri here, I would definitely take Griez as he would suit that type of football. Not sure how he would fit in with Pirlo, but he's still a good player.

    I'm still unsure what I would do with Dybala. But his injuries and form issues are making my brain say sell.
     

    X Æ A-12

    Senior Member
    Contributor
    Sep 4, 2006
    87,956
    Good and timely indeed. We're a much better team now :howler: :baus: :b81:
    I guess i didn't think of how good and timely it is to sell Dybala this summer

    - - - Updated - - -

    Griezzman is 30, and past his prime as well. Not a good trade imo. Would be another Arthur - Pjanic where both team lose.
    It would be like the Pjanic - Arthur trade.

    Good. Timely.
     

    Elvin

    Senior Member
    Nov 25, 2005
    36,923
    Griezman is better than Dybala but we need younger and hungrier players. That aside, replacing one capricious player with another capricious player would be dumb.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 86)