I think some of the posts are pretty fair.
Not the Pjanic > Pogba posts of course but Juventus fans over the years have overrated him too much.
He still has some way to go before being put on the level of some legendary midfielders. It was laughable to read some of the posts last season really. And he is not the best CM right now. I would've said this even last year but I would've got bashed for saying that.
As of now , it's an absolute fact that he can't carry a midfield. He thrives best in an already well functioning midfield not when he's asked to be the leader of the pack. We've seen this both with France and Juventus. It's fanboyism to disagree about this.
Pogba is complete but he's still developing.
- - - Updated - - -
Dybala has shown he can be a leader already just like Vidal. It would hurt to lose him, not Pogba. It's not hurting losing him at all.
I fully agree, but saying that makes me "underrate pogba" apparently.
Pogba at juventus was the bomb when the team works. Compare it with a clinical forward to a hugely creative team, its a disgustingly good added bonus.
Pogba... If your team is a well oiled machine and the midfield is rocksolid, Pogba is an insane addition. He'll decide games, and he'll get good numbers, but your midfield needs to work and carry him. I honestly dont really see why putting the finger on this fact is such a problem ?
I absolutely hate how some go like "he'll be a bigger star in their team cause it has less stars". What incredible bullshit. Pogba can become the biggest star he can be, at this very juventus. Where on earth can you play your 100% naturally preferred role with everyone supporting you in some way ? Where ?
He had such insane potential, he could be so insanely decisive, at juventus or similar midfield. Bayern would probably be his best alternative.
But he went to Manchester. He cant carry a midfield, so its a huge mistake.
People need to get off their high horse and look at the simple facts : Pogba works when the other midfielders work. They make him work, not the other way around.
Again, there is nothing wrong with that. A stacked team upgrading with pogba is one of the best things you can do.
But if you have a crappy midfield, buy something else. Like verratti or Marchisio. They uplift whatever they put around them