Official: Hargreaves To Manchester (4 Viewers)

Ahmedios

Senior Member
Nov 11, 2006
5,107
#22
Owen Hargreaves is a good player and ManUtd will have a hard-working partnership (Hargreaves + Carrick) in the next season. Although with such a transfer fee, I reckon that the biggest winner of such a deal is Bayern Munich. Bayern are capable of discovering a promising German youngster with less than quarter the transfer fee of Hargreaves.
 

IlDivinCodino

f**king hot prospect
Mar 5, 2006
1,191
#23
if you read my posts i hardly show bias to Juve players. I just don't like Hargreaves and think just cause he shown at the world cup cause all the other english players didn't do well doesn't make him good. Plus Man UTd didn't really need him, cause Carrick has been coping fine this season. As Alen said you underrate Zanetti and overrate Hargreaves.
Fine Utd have the money, does it mean they should pay double the price of what a player is worth?
TBH i think its a great deal for Manchester United. Its not about Carrick you see, I think its more of a replacement for Scholes. Scholes has passed his best and look and the cards his been piling on himself this season because he tries so hard to get the ball but he's an attacking player you see. I'd say Manchester gets another striker and they are all good for next season considering Rooney and Ronaldo are in the squad. They don't need anymore firepower. Defence yes. Carrick and Hargreaves can own the midfield with their passes and defensive techniques. Stabilises the midfield and arrives late to finish off some loose balls which is pretty much what Scholes was doing at late. And I think Carrick and Hargeaves have some pretty good far ranged shots. And yeah, Manchester should do exactly what they did if they have the cash for Hargeaves.
And what do you mean i underrate Zanetti? Did i say he sucked? No. But what I did imply was that I seriously doubt Zanetti is better than Hargreaves. He did not impress me in 2002 because as far as I remember whenever he played, Italy never win a single match in the tournament. In 2004 neither did we. We could blame it on Trappatoni for his ultra defensive stint but he really never make any impact. He sucked for Inter. His career was all over the place. Venezia, Fiorentina whatever. He had one good year with Roma and sucked throughout for Inter again. Okay i admit he did settle down quite well with us this season but i dont want to judge him just yet. We were in Serie B. And to be honest i dont think we had a great season in Serie B. Buck up Juventus!!! And I rate Hargreaves for what he deserves
 

tonykart

Senior Member
Feb 16, 2007
1,595
#25
Owen Hargreaves is a good player and ManUtd will have a hard-working partnership (Hargreaves + Carrick) in the next season. Although with such a transfer fee, I reckon that the biggest winner of such a deal is Bayern Munich. Bayern are capable of discovering a promising German youngster with less than quarter the transfer fee of Hargreaves.
Hargreaves is an excellent player and I think both teams won here. Manchester United did not have the DM they needed for the CL this year and Hargreaves will give them true quality in CM. You are absolutely right about Bayern too, although you don't exactly have to have a great defensive player in CM to win Bundesliga.
 

tonykart

Senior Member
Feb 16, 2007
1,595
#27
TBH i think its a great deal for Manchester United. Its not about Carrick you see, I think its more of a replacement for Scholes. Scholes has passed his best and look and the cards his been piling on himself this season because he tries so hard to get the ball but he's an attacking player you see. I'd say Manchester gets another striker and they are all good for next season considering Rooney and Ronaldo are in the squad. They don't need anymore firepower. Defence yes. Carrick and Hargreaves can own the midfield with their passes and defensive techniques. Stabilises the midfield and arrives late to finish off some loose balls which is pretty much what Scholes was doing at late. And I think Carrick and Hargeaves have some pretty good far ranged shots. And yeah, Manchester should do exactly what they did if they have the cash for Hargeaves.
And what do you mean i underrate Zanetti? Did i say he sucked? No. But what I did imply was that I seriously doubt Zanetti is better than Hargreaves. He did not impress me in 2002 because as far as I remember whenever he played, Italy never win a single match in the tournament. In 2004 neither did we. We could blame it on Trappatoni for his ultra defensive stint but he really never make any impact. He sucked for Inter. His career was all over the place. Venezia, Fiorentina whatever. He had one good year with Roma and sucked throughout for Inter again. Okay i admit he did settle down quite well with us this season but i dont want to judge him just yet. We were in Serie B. And to be honest i dont think we had a great season in Serie B. Buck up Juventus!!! And I rate Hargreaves for what he deserves
It is hard to argue with this post. I like Zanetti though. He is a bit of a journeyman and there is always a reason for that. If teams need a player, they keep him and his prior teams clearly didn't need him. However, I do see a role for Zanetti here, but I think we need to pair him with a WC DM. A lot of people are suggesting a lot of young un-proven talents at CM, but quite frankly he is not the player a young talent needs to be playing along side of.

Zanetti will do for next season, and he is a good stop-gap solution. At the very least, he gives us experience where we need it badly.
 

IlDivinCodino

f**king hot prospect
Mar 5, 2006
1,191
#28
What did you expect Juventus to do before the start of the season?
You quote my sentence specifically so i'll explain to you.......We had Serie A material. Nedved, DP, Camoranesi, Chielini, Balza and Buffon. If I remember correctly we used them alot in 05/06 and look at the point gap we opened up with Milan. We still have them. Several changes. And a 9 point deduction and we more or less struggled with draws and losses. Unless you wanna tell me that we were nothing in 05/06 without Moggi and his phonecalls then i expect much more from our players in Serie B. Its new to them yes, but c'mon......we are Juve. I'm still thanking God for a mere 9 points deduction and not 17 or whatever.
Nways, you shouldnt ask me that question. If I could answer you, I would be the manager of Juve. Because unlike some people who thinks they are better than Fabio Capello, I'm not. I just want Juve to show me some actions instead of overflowing soccernet and skysports.com with transfer rumors. Give us something solid
 

Ahmedios

Senior Member
Nov 11, 2006
5,107
#30
You quote my sentence specifically so i'll explain to you.......We had Serie A material. Nedved, DP, Camoranesi, Chielini, Balza and Buffon. If I remember correctly we used them alot in 05/06 and look at the point gap we opened up with Milan. We still have them. Several changes. And a 9 point deduction and we more or less struggled with draws and losses. Unless you wanna tell me that we were nothing in 05/06 without Moggi and his phonecalls then i expect much more from our players in Serie B. Its new to them yes, but c'mon......we are Juve. I'm still thanking God for a mere 9 points deduction and not 17 or whatever.
Nways, you shouldnt ask me that question. If I could answer you, I would be the manager of Juve. Because unlike some people who thinks they are better than Fabio Capello, I'm not. I just want Juve to show me some actions instead of overflowing soccernet and skysports.com with transfer rumors. Give us something solid
Why I do feel that you underrate the Serie B teams. These teams have faced Juventus and they've been sure that their matches with Juve are the best chance for them to prove themselves. I'm not saying that they're good teams that can compete with us, but against Juve they change their skins.

As for our squad, you mentioned most of our heroes who decided not to escape the drowning ship and you forgot the ones who left it already; Zambrotta, Thuram, Cannavaro, Vieira, Emerson, Mutu and Ibrahimovic, plus the coach. Any team who loses more than half of its regular players must be affected, this is an unarguable point. Also taking into consideration that we didn't have enough time to replace the departed players, I think that Juve's mission in Serie B wasn't that easy.

And my question was pretty obvious, you think that Juve haven't had a great season, and I asked why? Even though, you're talking as if Juventus should have collected 110 points, Serie B with all the pressure and criticism the club has been facing since our demotion isn't a piece of cake!

One last thing, Juventus aren't responsible for what is written by the media. And for the transfers, haven't you noticed that the mercato closes on August 31?! Actually, I don't see your point.
 
Apr 12, 2004
77,165
#31
Bayern are gonna be dancing all the way to the bank...what a ripoff!!! and what must Carrick be thinking...he did really well the whole season and now they buy another DM
Carrick isn't a DM, and yea baby, it was a ripoff....I'm happy he is away, he is way too injury prone.

So that makes 4 players leaving the club.

We are going to make no less than 6 signing, that is what Hitz and the Kaiser said.
 
Jul 2, 2006
19,451
#33
ßömßäяdîëя™;1350004 said:
Carrick isn't a DM, and yea baby, it was a ripoff....I'm happy he is away, he is way too injury prone.

So that makes 4 players leaving the club.

We are going to make no less than 6 signing, that is what Hitz and the Kaiser said.
what is your opinion about Toni and that young striker's(I cant remember his name) signing

imo Makay will leave, after this transfers
 
Apr 12, 2004
77,165
#34
Makaay won't leave, he may, but I don't think so....are you talking about Jan Schlaudraff? If so, he is very promising, he may be the next Mueller. He has that much talent, some are calling him the next big thing, like another Podolski.

And Toni, we are fucking dumb to get him. He will settle in to Bayern one year after he arrives, then he will have one good year, then he will just blow because he will be 32.....but then again he could just light it up and score 40 goals a season for 3 years.
 

Ahmed

Principino
Sep 3, 2006
47,928
#35
Carrick and Hargreaves combined cannot manage the number of goals that Scholes has scored for Man U...and Scholes couldnt tackle some1 to save his life...and these two are essentially holding midfielders not attack-minded players like Scholes...now there will be more emphasis on C-Ro and Giggs to create the attacks from midfield...b4 it was Keane + Scholes with Keane holding it together and Scholes going forward...
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
116,298
#36
Carrick is a deep-lying playmaker of sorts, great player in my opinion and wish he had an Italian grandparent who loves Juventus. There shouldn't be any question now that Hargreaves is overrated but he will provide Manure with more bite in midfield, something Carrick nor Scholes really give. Now Fletcher won't play much unless he somehow is used on the wing so haha to him.
 

IlDivinCodino

f**king hot prospect
Mar 5, 2006
1,191
#37
Why I do feel that you underrate the Serie B teams. These teams have faced Juventus and they've been sure that their matches with Juve are the best chance for them to prove themselves. I'm not saying that they're good teams that can compete with us, but against Juve they change their skins.

As for our squad, you mentioned most of our heroes who decided not to escape the drowning ship and you forgot the ones who left it already; Zambrotta, Thuram, Cannavaro, Vieira, Emerson, Mutu and Ibrahimovic, plus the coach. Any team who loses more than half of its regular players must be affected, this is an unarguable point. Also taking into consideration that we didn't have enough time to replace the departed players, I think that Juve's mission in Serie B wasn't that easy.

And my question was pretty obvious, you think that Juve haven't had a great season, and I asked why? Even though, you're talking as if Juventus should have collected 110 points, Serie B with all the pressure and criticism the club has been facing since our demotion isn't a piece of cake!

One last thing, Juventus aren't responsible for what is written by the media. And for the transfers, haven't you noticed that the mercato closes on August 31?! Actually, I don't see your point.
Yes I do. I do rate Serie B very low because why? Like I said, we are Juventus. About you saying that teams in B purposely change their skins just to face us so what? Every team should play to their best in every single game. That's what we call professionals. Not to save up to play for your country nor just to play in certain matches, no. Every player should go all.
Vieira and Ibrahimovic. Perhaps not you but as far as I remember there were many Juventus fans around who kept saying these 2 are simply worthless to us and adds nothing to the squad. Basically they suck. I dont disagree though. Vieira and Ibra had no impact on us in 05/06. And a squad turnover does affect the team but then again look at Chelsea. Their squad are basically inside out since Abramovic. But because their players are somehow extremely expensive with class they play well. This shows what class of players we have at our disposal. Our attacking force are more or less full strength only our defense. And no we had some time to purchase players. But who did Deschamps bought? Boumsong! And even with Buffon just look at the goals we conceded this season. If the time's not enough, what about January transfers. But still I'm talking about our current squad. Screw buying players. They scraped through B and they are bound to struggle in serie A.
So you still dont get my point? Seriously, I will not be surprised if Juve gets 110 points - 9 points = 101 points. I think Juve did not have a great season because look at Inter. Where are they? When did they win the serie A? Almost a fricking month before we win the serie B. And what do you mean pressure, criticism and stuff? Shouldnt that trigger the team to play even better? Not like they are dumb kids who gets bullied by the media and cries on the field. They are Juventus players who should go out there and prove everyone wrong. Or else, they are just basically another excuse for you to say that we had a wonderful season even under pressure, half the 1st team squad and a 9 point deduction. We did fantastic
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)