Non-Juve Transfer news (official or rumors) (12 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bianconero81

Ageing Veteran
Jan 26, 2009
40,168
#41
The Magic that got us Higuain for 90 million, weakened our midfield year after year (never properly replacing Vidal), and sold Vidal and Coman for peanuts? OK.

Yes, he has done a marvelous job for Inter, and he was good for us, but it was time to move on.

The mistake was not letting Marotta go, but allowing Tootsie to replace him, hiring Sarri, Pirlo and bringing Failegri back.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Osman

Koul Khara!
Aug 30, 2002
61,478
#42
No wrong still habibi, the mistake was DEFENITELY letting Marotta go. We have painfully learned that for past 5 years. The depths of lows we reached litterally as soon as he left.



You can defenitely critique and judge his mishaps, but how key the insanely competent hand he steered our ship with cant be stressed enough.
 

Bianconero81

Ageing Veteran
Jan 26, 2009
40,168
#43
It was wrong to let him go because of how events transpired. However, had we released Marotta and brought in someone like Luis Campos, Andrea Berta or even Cristiano Guintoli back then, we would not be in this mess.
 

s4tch

Senior Member
Mar 23, 2015
33,502
#44
It was wrong to let him go because of how events transpired. However, had we released Marotta and brought in someone like Luis Campos, Andrea Berta or even Cristiano Guintoli back then, we would not be in this mess.
letting marotta go was still a mistake. agnelli's arrogance not only weakened juventus, but certainly strengthened inda, which is unacceptable. look at how adl resists to release giuntoli. he knows that giuntoli is an effective director, he knows that he can't keep the guy for too long, but he tries to delay it as much as possible. and aa gifted marotta to inda.

marotta is the best in italy and one of the best around in europe. you keep him until you can, easy. bringing him back is an other matter. but letting him go was easily the worst decision of the post-calciopoli era.
 

Strickland

Senior Member
May 17, 2019
5,859
#45
No wrong still habibi, the mistake was DEFENITELY letting Marotta go. We have painfully learned that for past 5 years. The depths of lows we reached litterally as soon as he left.

You can defenitely critique and judge his mishaps, but how key the insanely competent hand he steered our ship with cant be stressed enough.
some of those depths were reached also due to the decline that started under Marotta. the plusvalenza problem was inherited, the squad was getting old and already back then we had a lot of deadwood.

I've no doubt he'd have steered the ship in a better direction than Tici, but in hindsight with Covid looming, our big money bets Higuain, Berna, Costa losing all of their value + the structure of the squad there still would've been a significant dip from the times we were a top team in Europe, it was inevitable.
 

JuveJay

Senior Signor
Moderator
Mar 6, 2007
74,874
#46
Marotta will do his magic again.

Chelsea will get Onana for alot of money, Marotta will get Lukaku and Koulibaly (could even see them go on loans)

Then he sell Gosens and buys Carlos Augusto for less money.

Then Frattesi/SMS or Scalvini.

Biggest mistake ever to let go of Marotta.
These are all common sense moves. Some short term, some longer. He just shuffles the pack around.

It remains to be seen if we are going to take advantage of the inevitable fire sale at Chelsea, but I'm pretty sure whoever we sign will end up a dud, going by our recent track record.
 

Akshen

Senior Member
Aug 27, 2010
10,608
#47
plus Scammacca as Dzeko replacement. They are pretty well build team. But this is what happens when u really decide if u play with wing backs and full backs before the season starts. If u play 3 or 2 at the back before the season starts, if u play 2 or 3 in mid before the season starts, if u play 1 or 2 strikers before the season starts.
For Juve thats not the case, we buy Di Maria to play him as SS, we have 3 fullbacks, one wing back and one guy who can play both (Cuads).
We buy Kean for CF spot, then in the season our coach decides that Kean is not a CF, but winger and we loan Milik, when we buy Milik, our coach decides Kean is actually a CF and we are stuck with 3 CFs with one, not getting playing time.
We buy Zakaria for peanuts play him in 15 games and decide that he is not fit for our tactics and loan him out.
There is no strategy here at all and imo its both on sporting managment and Allegri.
 

Strickland

Senior Member
May 17, 2019
5,859
#48
These are all common sense moves. Some short term, some longer. He just shuffles the pack around.

It remains to be seen if we are going to take advantage of the inevitable fire sale at Chelsea, but I'm pretty sure whoever we sign will end up a dud, going by our recent track record.
both Lukaku and Koulibaly are on problematic wages though. Lukaku was on 7.5m at Inter, then went to Chelsea, got a bump to 10.8m and I've no idea if he's eligible for growth decree. Koulibaly was on 6m at Napoli, went to Chelsea and was bumped to 9.8m net, he would have to spend another season at Chelsea to become eligible for growth decree. tbh I wouldn't want either at those wages, Lukaku seems to be troubled by injuries and Koulibaly is a CB. a damn good one, but still a CB.
 
Jul 2, 2006
19,431
#53
marotta praising still going on here is loathsome. you can't even realize it was all downhill for us since 2015. then again, you guys also thought allegri is a good manager and celebrated his second coming. that is how bad you are at understanding football.

i fully support marotta's work at inter. i hope he brings that peanut brained defender and the furniture with zero to none skills with ball striker from chelsea. then they will have a squad full of old rejects who worth jack shit if you want to get rid of them. it was truly regretful that he missed his main target nacho though.
 

DAiDEViL

Senior Member
Feb 21, 2015
64,566
#54
marotta praising still going on here is loathsome. you can't even realize it was all downhill for us since 2015. then again, you guys also thought allegri is a good manager and celebrated his second coming. that is how bad you are at understanding football.

i fully support marotta's work at inter. i hope he brings that peanut brained defender and the furniture with zero to none skills with ball striker from chelsea. then they will have a squad full of old rejects who worth jack shit if you want to get rid of them. it was truly regretful that he missed his main target nacho though.
Dunning Turk strikes again.
 

PhRoZeN

Livin with Mediocre
Mar 29, 2006
16,926
#55
I'm in the middle on this one, yes Marotta did his fair share of mistakes. Yes, there were many happy to see him go and yes, the appointment of ticci influenced our feelings for the great man. Its a hindsight bias.

We were not to know how incompetent ticci would turn out. We did know how difficult it became to sell marottas dead wood, tici decided to use his own valuating algorithms in helping to do that. Inter will have the same issues that we had, but they also have a team that is built to deliver in short term. Finances screwed us, buying low selling lower worked till it could, on the other hand ticis buy higher sell low screwed us even more. That said marotta was great for us, but not for one to win our CL obsessesion, unless he got lucky. Helping us to win countless leagues, shouldn't be taken away from him. Agnelli wanted us to go the next level, but knows we don't have the finances, yet he goes and approves the buying of Ronaldo because somehow that will improve our finances. Agnelli reminds me of the kid who always looks over at their rivals to see how he can improve, and then thinks as entrepreneur and gambles like it's his first business. Stability was important, and for that marotta should be praised (other than the 90m higgy fuck up).

Right now, we need marotta again, but once we're back on top of serie A, I agree we need to find a better replacement.
 

Mokku

Senior Member
Apr 17, 2019
2,708
#58
Marotta gets massive credit for building a solid foundation, he made his mistakes when trying to move us into the most elite group but the fact is, we probably needed that 90M player to push us over the line and win the CL. Higuain though, was not the answer. He's done the same with Lukaku who like Higuain, choked hard at the vital moment. Taking that gamble meant overlooking other players but I see the process and appreciate that he did some risk management.

Tici saw a declining squad but still got Ronaldo thinking he would do miracles in the CL. That was naive because we're stuck with a bunch of finished players now. I love Ronaldo's time with us but we cut corners everywhere to accommodate him and when he took his goals and left us, we were left exposed. That is pure gambling along with poor managers, Ramsey and Arthur etc.
 

Scottish

Zebrastreifenpferd
Mar 13, 2011
10,176
#59
I'm in the middle on this one, yes Marotta did his fair share of mistakes. Yes, there were many happy to see him go and yes, the appointment of ticci influenced our feelings for the great man. Its a hindsight bias.

We were not to know how incompetent ticci would turn out. We did know how difficult it became to sell marottas dead wood, tici decided to use his own valuating algorithms in helping to do that. Inter will have the same issues that we had, but they also have a team that is built to deliver in short term. Finances screwed us, buying low selling lower worked till it could, on the other hand ticis buy higher sell low screwed us even more. That said marotta was great for us, but not for one to win our CL obsessesion, unless he got lucky. Helping us to win countless leagues, shouldn't be taken away from him. Agnelli wanted us to go the next level, but knows we don't have the finances, yet he goes and approves the buying of Ronaldo because somehow that will improve our finances. Agnelli reminds me of the kid who always looks over at their rivals to see how he can improve, and then thinks as entrepreneur and gambles like it's his first business. Stability was important, and for that marotta should be praised (other than the 90m higgy fuck up).

Right now, we need marotta again, but once we're back on top of serie A, I agree we need to find a better replacement.
In fact I recall even while Marotta was still here Tuzzers were calling Paratici the real power behind the throne, and when he was promoted to Marotta's job people were cool with it.
 

Akshen

Senior Member
Aug 27, 2010
10,608
#60
In fact I recall even while Marotta was still here Tuzzers were calling Paratici the real power behind the throne, and when he was promoted to Marotta's job people were cool with it.
Sampa president was saying the same, that he is not missing Marotta, but Tici. Maybe Tici is good at scouting talent and finding a good player for the team, but he was given the financial powers and it seems he has no idea about that and sinked our ship. Marotta on the other hand is top manager when it comes to managing finances and creating a team.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 10)