I would consider Immobile a mistake since he scored 36 goals in a single season and was a constant threat for Lazio for years. One could make the argument we wouldn't have needed to buy Higs, although I'm not saying they're the same quality. We could have used the money elsewhere.
Romero and Coman were definitely mistakes.
Like I said, I don't know about Immobile. Of course, selling for 13.500.000 someone who can in a year or two make it to serie A's all time top 5 goalscorers, or even top 3, can be called a huge mistake in hindsight.
However, back when we sold him he wasn't worth more than that, and it's a huge question mark if he would have became the player he was if he remained with us. It's also a big question if he was gonna bring us to the next level the way Tevez and Morata did.
Perhaps one could say that we might have kept him instead of getting Llorente for free in 2013. But even if we did, I don't think that he was going to become a top player for us, or that we would have sold him for more than 30 millions. Higs was bought in 2016/17, and I doubt that having Immobile here would have prevented that transfer.
- - - Updated - - -
so what we discovered:
- players' market prices usually get higher until their prime
- inflation exists
- clubs make transfers that can be called as mistakes in hindsight
- tici is an idiot
more news at 11
No need for smartassing here.
Even though inflation is there and players become more expensive in their prime, about 3/4 of our sales of u23 players are positive, perhaps even 4/5s or 5/6s. None of these youngsters became more expensive in their prime.
We are usually selling youngsters well, and still that is not the general opinion of this forum. Quite the contrary.
I mentioned only the "mistakes", in order to see how few they were, and how a lot of them aren't even mistakes when one takes inflation and age into consideration.
In my opinion, even though we were dealing with more than 70-80 youngsters sold for 2m or more, only in the case of Romero and Coman one can say that we made a clear mistake. Two out of 70/80 is an excellent achievement.