Judging by the Interisti's reactions already, don't think we'd regret this move however impractical it may be. These awkward neanderthals are literally panicking and shitting themselves and going in and out of various coping mechanisms at the thought.
It's a win-win scenario. Win if we're prudent about it, win if we start a meltdown shitstorm by signing him.
Generally, don't like characters like them at the club, but they'd definitely cause less trouble at Juve than they've done at Inter. And would be shipped out promptly before something gets too far.
- - - Updated - - -
But Dybala played 9 for his whole career outside of Juve. Still, even if you think he's not a natural 9, would Icardi actually score more in that position and by how much? And is it justifiable to spend so much money on him if he would score 30 goals and Dybala would score like 28? And is this even the profile we need next to Ronaldo considering Icardi has about 2 or 3 assists in the last two years combined?
We have so many bigger needs.
Both Icardi and Dybala can partner Ronaldo, but all three can't (or rather shouldn't) play together just like Ronaldo-Mandzukic-Dybala shouldn't.
If Allegri stays, he seems settled on a CF next to Ronaldo.
In that sense, Icardi is an improvement of course, but yeah, another season of "improving" the midfield but not completing it.