I think so too. I do believe that Allegri wants them to play with creativity, based on how he seems to approach it. I think he wants the 10 to be given full freedom but his risk-avoidance-personality gives mixed signals. It's like his message is: Control the game, play with full flair, from the defender to the attacker should be no longer than 30m, we need width, roam into open spaces, play with intensity, attack spaces, don't give away possession, play simple passes, pass vertically, and I could go on. It's like playing FM and just clicking on all boxes even if they are counter-intuitive.
I understand he wants the players to find their own solutions to problems on-field and I enjoy the idea of entrusting the players. But it is a team-game that requires certain clear ideas on how to transition, when to press high and specifically how, who distributes the ball in which areas. With all these instructions that are counter-intuitive he creates more problems for each player. Whenever someone gets the ball they rarely have someone to pass to. The only players that can do something are those with a vision no one else has (Pirlo, Dybala, Di Maria, and so forth). Dusan has been poor here, no doubt, but he is also playing down his own half and even then rarely has any passing options. Milik is better at it but it suits his style and how he wants to play. We are asking a poacher to be a target player (should do better, absolutely) and then complain about goals etcetera. Dusan is a huge disappointment but for the same reasons I doubt Soulé is ready to carry this team, I believe there are very few players that can consistently do well under these circumstances.
Allegri is a great tactician which makes us harder to beat because we adapt to opponents. Yesterday was very clear in how we stretched out and coped under pressure that it was all adapted to Inter. But it also means we have no philosophy of our own except we're aiming to not loose. If I only adapt to my environment I have no core of my own. Allegri is liberal in certain regards but his personality influences players to be risk-avoidant too and in some regards he is even too liberal and should be more hands on to create principles within the players can be more liberal in.