Well since Dybala at this point doesn't fit the question I asked, I won't discuss him specifically. But Even with half a midfield we played our best football in later stages of 2016-17. Anyway, you mentioned Morata, who actually improved much under Max and collapsed elsewhere later. Bernardeschi improved as well. But Sandro actually regressed, and Rugani, Dybala, and Bentancur are kind of in the same level.
Again though, Sandro became his best in his second season here under Allegri. When we bought him everyone thought Danilo was the better Porto fullback. Sandro exploded under Allegri.
Players seem to improve under Allegri for a year or two and then regress. And it’s not just with young players we see this.
My opinion is that he burns players out. A lot of these players that we are discussing as regressed, it looks more like fitness issues to me. Neither Sandro or Dybala look anywhere near as fit as they did in 15-16 and 16-17... neither looks like they have close to 90 minutes of effort in their legs. Same deal with Pjanic who was fantastic for the last 4 months of his first year and first 4 months of his second year. Since then he’s looked lazy and exhausted almost continually. Even Mandzukic seems to have a few months of bombing around the pitch under Allegri and then looks dead the rest of the year.
There seems to be something fundamentally wrong with our fitness and rotation approach, and those are the two biggest issues I have with Allegri.
- - - Updated - - -
It's interesting how majority were pro Allegri before Atletico games, everyone anti-Allegri after Atletico first leg, majority pro Allegri again after Atletico second leg (a tie we won by a goal to keep things in perspective), and everyone anti Allegri again post Ajax lol.
I’m pro-Allegri still, and am fine with him staying, especially if the board backs him this summer and upgrades our mid... I’d like to see what he can do with a midfield at least close to 14-15 Juve level.
But if we aren’t going to deal with the necessary upgrades, and the team is going to largely stay the same with only minor signings, it may be best to get some fresh motivation and ideas into the squad.
Either way, we need some freshness and rejuvenation... players or coach...