Pfff.
I don't hate him, it's just that you aren't a top manager if your gameplan is always the same no matter what, and you can't do jack shit during the game to influence it.
Reading a game and making game changing subs? Never heard of it.
Definition of a one-trick pony.
But aren't results what matter for us to evaluate a manager?
What if a manager has one game plan, but that game plan gets him very good results. Surely he should get credit for the results he got, despite any apparent weaknesses that he may have?
Klopp plays in one way, but that way has been enough for him to beat some very good managers, and get results that have made him legendary for B.Dortmund and soon for Pool as well.
Would he be a better manager if he was able to be more tactically flexible, and read games better? Of course, but has he been achieving results above and beyond what is expected of him? IMO that is unarguable.
- - - Updated - - -
In my opinion Allegri is a good coach but Juve isn't the right team for him anymore. Against Real Madrid and Napoli at home, the two most important games of the season, he decided to play like a scared chicken? And two times you get screwed in your ass. Over the seasons he did ok in Serie A ( winning the tittles) and in the CL he did good with two finals. But it's time for another coach in my opinion and maybe Max should join a team abroad.
The guy reached a CL final last season FFS, not 5 years ago, last season.
I really don't understand how managers are evaluated over here, its like you are only as good as last weeks result. I cannot fathom how anyone can say Allegri hasn't done a fantastic job at Juve. Sure he is expected to win Serie A every season, but look at his results in the CL, he's had better results than teams that have much better squads and bigger budgets like Barcelona and Bayern. Allow him to buy superstars, and guarantee that he doesn't have to sell important stars every season, and then blame him for not winning the CL. Until then, its extremely unfair for anyone to say he has done anything short of a fantastic job.