Mafia Game Zombie Discussion Thread. (16 Viewers)

[Osman]

For those of you who have XT account and are in the mood for a Mafia game, here's one starting out with a GREAT time

http://www.xtratime.org/forum/showthread.php?t=255805


Especially for me, the perfect theme And prolly for Alen too

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[SABSAB]

Here Alen.

 

[Alen]

Thanks

So, since I think I'm making a valid point about the BG, what do you guys think? Not for today. Janna already said that the BG can protect from jail. What about the other games? What Osman told us now is utter BS imo and I think we shouldn't keep this rule for the next games.

Janna, apparently your inbox is full. Clean it.

 

[Enron]

If you're a special role and you end up in jail, then you can't do your special role. It's as simple as that.

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

Are you really Alen, or are you the killer of Alen?

Janna has stated that you are dead, so are you or are you the killer posting on Alen's account?

 

[Alen]

If you're a special role and you end up in jail, then you can't do your special role. It's as simple as that.

Of course.

That's why I find it strange what Janna and Osman are saying in the game thread.

Janna, why did you tell us that the BG can protect in jail? Where did you read that in the rules and how did you come to that conclusion. Osman has the same opinion as you so I would like to hear the logic that you two had for this.
So Janna, would you like to tell us how did you conclude that the BG can protect while in jail?

 

[SABSAB]

I think we always understood it that special roles can't work from the jail, can still be lynched but are protected from whacking.
We can play it different now but still there should be some mayor rules discussion and an experienced narrator for the next ones.

 

[Alen]

I think we always understood it that special roles can't work from the jail, can still be lynched but are protected from whacking.
We can play it different now but still there should be some mayor rules discussion and an experienced narrator for the next ones.

And we were all right to think that way.

What is said now is what makes no sense. We shouldn't change the way we played it. We played correctly.

 

[SABSAB]

That's why I always complain when things are not done like in the rules. We get a huge mess out of it.

 

[SABSAB]

What I say about the detective not being able to investigate on day one is true. It was always like that. But there is no real day one anymore and we go directly to day 2.

 

[Alen]

That's why I always complain when things are not done like in the rules. We get a huge mess out of it.

This with the BG was a fairly simple rule yet it got changed out of nowhere. I only want to know why was it changed like that and why today?

 

[SABSAB]

This with the BG was a fairly simple rule yet it got changed out of nowhere. I only want to know why was it changed like that and why today?

I understand that Janna just doesn't know better. It's an unfair advantage to the Cs, but she made the decision so we'll have to life with it.

 

[Alen]

I understand that Janna just doesn't know better. It's an unfair advantage to the Cs, but she made the decision so we'll have to life with it.

It's cool if that's the reason.

I just need her to tell us.

 

[Alen]

Ok, Janna just explained the confusion to me and asked me to post here since she's posting from her phone and can't post (??)

Janna actually thought that "jailed people can be whacked because everyone said jailed people can be whacked, Alen!". She understood it that they can be whacked and they can use their special powers.

This settles the discussion about Janna. Klin can use his powers while in jail. That's the narrator's call and it must be respected.

Now I'd hope Osman to explain his logic after Janna explained it and tell us why can jailed special roles use their powers but they can't be whacked.

 

[X Æ A-12]

I think we always understood it that special roles can't work from the jail, can still be lynched but are protected from whacking.
We can play it different now but still there should be some mayor rules discussion and an experienced narrator for the next ones.

And we were all right to think that way.

What is said now is what makes no sense. We shouldn't change the way we played it. We played correctly.

Agree with this

 

[Klin]

Jailed people can be whacked now?

 

[Enron]

Yep.

 

[Bezzy]

We should make all rules clear before a new game. That is easier for the narrator too

 

[Klin]

This game was filled with confusion and wtf moments so I'm not that surprised actually.

 

[ßöмßäяðîëя]

The narrator can barely speak English, what do you expect?