Mafia Game sign up thread (4 Viewers)

OP
Ford Prefect

Ford Prefect

Senior Member
May 28, 2009
10,557
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #127
    dude no one is going to register you ve been saying that for the last week, if anything the number of participants is dwindling start it up already...
    .....when?

    I said when it hit 16 i would start it at the end of the day, but if i dont start it today it will clash with my exams....
     

    JBF

    اختك يا زمن
    Aug 5, 2006
    18,451
    .....when?

    I said when it hit 16 i would start it at the end of the day, but if i dont start it today it will clash with my exams....
    Then start it already as it is. Make the hat pick for the roles and pm the registered ones for their roles. The question now is how many Gs and Cs should there be in the game? I think having 3Gs and 11Cs and the start would be the right thing, as the recruiter will make his decision later in the game thus making it 4 against 10. But it's your game Jasp.
     
    OP
    Ford Prefect

    Ford Prefect

    Senior Member
    May 28, 2009
    10,557
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #130
    Then start it already as it is. Make the hat pick for the roles and pm the registered ones for their roles. The question now is how many Gs and Cs should there be in the game? I think having 3Gs and 11Cs and the start would be the right thing, as the recruiter will make his decision later in the game thus making it 4 against 10. But it's your game Jasp.
    3gs, 11 cs, 1 recruiter.

    I will draw for it at 8 gmt.
     

    Osman

    Koul Khara!
    Aug 30, 2002
    61,493
    That gives the Gs bit of an advantage, numerically speaking, there shouldnt be 4 Gs to 11 Cs, thats almost half, it means couple of whacks and miss lynches and they can win quick. IMO should be 3 Gs at most, then with 11 Cs, it will be almost a 1 to 4 ratio.
     

    SABSAB

    Snoop Stinks
    Dec 10, 2008
    10,832
    That gives the Gs bit of an advantage, numerically speaking, there shouldnt be 4 Gs to 11 Cs, thats almost half, it means couple of whacks and miss lynches and they can win quick. IMO should be 3 Gs at most, then with 11 Cs, it will be almost a 1 to 4 ratio.
    2 Gs 1 recruiter?
     

    Osman

    Koul Khara!
    Aug 30, 2002
    61,493
    Yeah, thats better. 4 Gs would make sense if we had 16 civilians, but 11, thats quite a difference. As I said, its almost half, with having just 7 more players then the Gs, it would mean 2 days of lynching wrong and 2 whacks, and it would almost be over.
     

    JBF

    اختك يا زمن
    Aug 5, 2006
    18,451
    Keep in mind Osman that the Cs have the advantage of the special roles, many of those can finish the Gs if played smartly. The Detictive's role alone could finish the Gs. I think 4Gs against 11Cs is pretty fair and more interesting too as the Cs will be fired up from the beginning knowing there aint much time to screw around. But as I've said, It's Jasp's game, his rules.
     

    SABSAB

    Snoop Stinks
    Dec 10, 2008
    10,832
    Keep in mind Osman that the Cs have the advantage of the special roles, many of those can finish the Gs if played smartly. The Detictive's role alone could finish the Gs. I think 4Gs against 11Cs is pretty fair and more interesting too as the Cs will be fired up from the beginning knowing there aint much time to screw around. But as I've said, It's Jasp's game, his rules.
    Not at all. First night 2 cs are gone and then it's 4 to 9 plus the one they can recruit and then it's over.
     

    JBF

    اختك يا زمن
    Aug 5, 2006
    18,451
    No Sab, I was talking about 4Gs including the one that will be recruited, as in there will be 3Gs including the recruiter at the start of the game then the recruited C will join the gang. And it's not necessarily that the Cs will lose a 2 Cs on the first day as last game Fred (the detective) made the right assumption suspecting Alen and asking for him to be investigated thus a G would have been lynched had Fred come out claiming he was the Detective and asking for the Bodyguard's protection. And yes Im fan of allowing the Detective to investigate from day one Osman :D
     

    king Ale

    Senior Member
    Oct 28, 2004
    21,689
    Not at all. First night 2 cs are gone and then it's 4 to 9 plus the one they can recruit and then it's over.
    You still have the previous game in your mind where the detective and the bodyguard went down at the first night. It's very rare to happen. In the last game, if the BG was still alive, the Gs wouldn't have won so easily like they did.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 4)