Kirev has no chance of playing though, Ariaudo has a much stronger chance of playing more first team games. Ariaudo trains with the first team, Kirev is still in the primavera.
To me, it is better to stay with Juventus, train next to the likes of Chiellni and Canna with Ciro as his coach than go to a team like Livorno where he isn't even guaranteed to play.
First of all I am against loaning him, but I definitely not against the loan system overall. Consider the smaller clubs that loan fringe( fringe not young) to survive a relegation fight or increase their depth.
I understand that your point is playing time at juventus. But for me the biggest point for dismissing the loan idea for players like Ariaudo is because the mental factors, training regimes than actual playing time.
About the faith in the youth players and loaning. I've seen it mentioned that had gio and Marchisio stayed with us then maybe we wouldn't need imports like Diego and Melo. Well, Palladino was supposed to be the next big thing and he played wonderfully in Serie B just like those two did. We placed a lot of faith in him and he let us down. Maybe because he was loaned out as youngster or whatever, he had two full years in the team and failed to assert himself.
We couldn't and cannot afford to sit around and build a team from scratch. We need to win because this team needed to get back to its stature asap or then we wouldn't be talking the scudetto but about reaching the CL. As good as both gio and marchisio were they still needed a lot of developing last year. Since they are great talents we cannot take that chance of putting too much pressure on them. Look at Criscito, he just crumbled and lost all confidence because that douche threw him in the deep end.
It all depends on the player and how much confidence he has as well. Gio, Marchi and De Ceglie all had the confidence in their own abilities to know they would get called back. Memmo didn't and thats why he prefers Genoa where its a safer environment with less pressure.
Anyway, i hope he stays because I liked what I saw last year and hopefully he would improve even more. Who would've thought he would get games last year, so you never know this year (even though the chances are remote).