This has to be the most stupid thing if we send him on loan
Who gives a RAT FUCK about experience?
Haven't you people ever heard of something called BUILDING A TEAM?
If you loan out your players constantly, how the hell are you going to get them used to being part of the team, forming partnerships with the players on said team, and building for the future? How are they going to even feel like they're part of the team if you always loan them out? It makes no sense whatsoever.
Again, the clubs in Europe with the best youth systems never loan out their young starlets. Never. Hmm, wonder why.
Even Inter don't loan out Balotelli and Santon.
But it's only the idiots at Juventus(z) who approve of this nonsense.
Haven't you people ever heard of something called BUILDING A TEAM?
If you loan out your players constantly, how the hell are you going to get them used to being part of the team, forming partnerships with the players on said team, and building for the future? How are they going to even feel like they're part of the team if you always loan them out? It makes no sense whatsoever.
Again, the clubs in Europe with the best youth systems never loan out their young starlets. Never. Hmm, wonder why.
Even Inter don't loan out Balotelli and Santon.
But it's only the idiots at Juventus(z) who approve of this nonsense.
Marchisio and Giovinco played in Serie B, showing their were capable.
Perhaps if we had kept them they'd be better off by being used regularly in our own team.
Perhaps if we had kept them they'd be better off by being used regularly in our own team.
I bet some of you would make awful awful parents.
That is such a random thing to say. It's not even close, tbh. None of us here can honestly say that we'd feel even remotely safe having Ariaudo starting for us against a tough opponent. Kid is talented but still very raw, and from what we saw last season there is a lot that he needs to learn. There's only one way to do that; by playing consistently against Serie A opposition.
To me, it's incomprehensible that you two are still obsessing about this no loaning whatsoever thing, because I don't take you for fools otherwise. Maybe just swallow that pride and admit that loaning out in some cases makes sense? :smile:
To me, it's incomprehensible that you two are still obsessing about this no loaning whatsoever thing, because I don't take you for fools otherwise. Maybe just swallow that pride and admit that loaning out in some cases makes sense? :smile:
I would start him in a heart beat. I would certainly sub him in games to get him PT. What exactly did you see from him where you ascertained the inclination he needed to learn a lot? How many times did you see Chiellini make a mistake? Or legro? Or grygera? Or Moli? It is insane to say he is too raw but our current crop at defense makes plenty of mistakes themselves.
And the only way is to play a lot of serie A competition you say? He would play with us, and what makes you so certain he will play at another club? Maybe the pressure there at being a foreigner at another club will make him crumble. Maybe being the young kid that no one there wants will get to him? Whatever team he goes to, he will be surrounded by players that are part of a project...part of a bigger picture, except him. How do you think that makes a young player feel? "Well, the club I played for my whole life doesn't think I'm good enough, they don't want me, the team I play for on loan is awkward because I don't feel part of the project...etc. etc." Look what happened to Criscito. He got tired of being a fucking pawn in a chess game and now he is loving life at a club that believed in him. Your post was random piece of thoughtlessness.
No, it makes no sense at all when:
1) You have no control over the kid's training regime for the season.
2) You cannot have your own coaches train the kid.
3) You're trying to build a team for the future, developing relationships on and off the pitch with individuals on said team.
4) You don't even know if the kid will get playing time at the other club.
Basically, this loaning thing is nothing more that freeing up space on the team sheet. Everything else is bullshit, including experience. Nobody factors in the experience the kid gets while training with the team, playing in reserve matches, playing Coppa, et cetera. Totally forgetting that experience also includes playing with your teammates here... it's not like this is singles tennis.
1) You have no control over the kid's training regime for the season.
2) You cannot have your own coaches train the kid.
3) You're trying to build a team for the future, developing relationships on and off the pitch with individuals on said team.
4) You don't even know if the kid will get playing time at the other club.
Basically, this loaning thing is nothing more that freeing up space on the team sheet. Everything else is bullshit, including experience. Nobody factors in the experience the kid gets while training with the team, playing in reserve matches, playing Coppa, et cetera. Totally forgetting that experience also includes playing with your teammates here... it's not like this is singles tennis.
Yeah, which he can do, practicing every day with our own team.

The experience which a player gets solely through training with great players, great coaches, and practice matches is obviously of high importance to development. But there comes a time when young players need truly competitive action, to cement what they have learned, and to improve under pressure. If they cannot get that at their own club, it makes sense for them to get it elsewhere as long as the training facilities and personnell at the LOAN club are of a decent standard. I doubt very much that Ciro would let any of our young players head to clubs where he thought their involvement in training and proper matches could prove at all detrimental to their development. Also, if a player does go out on loan and doesn't get a game, they can be recalled, as long as that is stipulated in the loan agreement. Same applies if we lose two centrebacks to a random Wolverine attack...
Giovinco would not be a first team regular now had he stayed with us, rather than gone to empoli, because we had a coach who was uninterested in using him in his natural position.
Our coaches can not teach a player what competitive action can teach them. Its that simple.
Ariaudo himself would surely be more confident and useful to us if he plays a season at Livorno, does well, develops his own game through the hustle and bustle of competitive, meaningful matches where there is always much at stake...than if he spends the whole season at Juve, playing perhaps a couple of coppa games, unless we face anyone decent in the early rounds. He is now sitting behind Chiellini, Cannavaro, Legro and Caceres. I can imagine problems with Canna and Legro, but then Caceres will play. At left back, we have 3 players...Right back, two.
Yes its a risk...but I think that Ciro has a decent understanding of how young players are trained at our club and other clubs, and also, of the importance of first team action in regards to player development. I trust him.
Giovinco would not be a first team regular now had he stayed with us, rather than gone to empoli, because we had a coach who was uninterested in using him in his natural position.
Our coaches can not teach a player what competitive action can teach them. Its that simple.
Ariaudo himself would surely be more confident and useful to us if he plays a season at Livorno, does well, develops his own game through the hustle and bustle of competitive, meaningful matches where there is always much at stake...than if he spends the whole season at Juve, playing perhaps a couple of coppa games, unless we face anyone decent in the early rounds. He is now sitting behind Chiellini, Cannavaro, Legro and Caceres. I can imagine problems with Canna and Legro, but then Caceres will play. At left back, we have 3 players...Right back, two.
Yes its a risk...but I think that Ciro has a decent understanding of how young players are trained at our club and other clubs, and also, of the importance of first team action in regards to player development. I trust him.
Maybe Ariaudo will be more confident coming in off the bench or starting some games with Buffon behind him guiding him, Chiellini, Zebina, Caceres and Cannavaro along side him (and Legro) all the while Ciro teach day in and day out in training versus some no named below average players and coaches teaching him at some smaller club? Answer that for me if all the games he plays at a small club, losing 75% of the games, allowing goal after goal to better teams against better players making the his loan team look bad when he could be playing for a better team, better players, winning games with a more positive winning atmosphere. How is that good for him at a small, lower level team? I would not find playing for a team that loses and concedes more often than score very beneficial to my development.
Do you folks who are so against the idea of loaning out some of our youngsters seriously think that Ciro would let any player he valued as a potential first team player, of the future, get lost in a team of hacks and become bench fodder????
If you think that, you clearly have little faith in our manager.
For older players, loans are more often than not, arranged to get a player off a club's books, to give him the chance to earn a new contract elsewhere, or for him to shine brightly and prove a point to the manager of his official club.
For young players, it gives them the chance to develop under competitive match conditions, and to in the process, show their true manager what they can do, that they are ready.
I have zero suspicion that any of our youngsters who are loaned out, will be left to rot, and not checked out, regularly by scouts or our youth coaches. Especially, if they are earmarked for a future possible first team role. That would be unproffesional and failing to work towards the club's best interests.
There are obvious benefits of staying with us, but there are also benefits of going to another team, improving under match conditions, and putting their Juve training into practice.
Wherever any of our youngsters go, they will be watched. Their links with Juve will not be severed, at all. Not under Ciro.
If you think that, you clearly have little faith in our manager.
For older players, loans are more often than not, arranged to get a player off a club's books, to give him the chance to earn a new contract elsewhere, or for him to shine brightly and prove a point to the manager of his official club.
For young players, it gives them the chance to develop under competitive match conditions, and to in the process, show their true manager what they can do, that they are ready.
I have zero suspicion that any of our youngsters who are loaned out, will be left to rot, and not checked out, regularly by scouts or our youth coaches. Especially, if they are earmarked for a future possible first team role. That would be unproffesional and failing to work towards the club's best interests.
There are obvious benefits of staying with us, but there are also benefits of going to another team, improving under match conditions, and putting their Juve training into practice.
Wherever any of our youngsters go, they will be watched. Their links with Juve will not be severed, at all. Not under Ciro.
Yeah, and all that pressure mounts on the player as well because he knows if he flops, he has no future in his original team.
And we saw how great loaning out Criscito was, too. Now he'd rather not come back.
People are too focused on Serie A playing experience and overlook other areas of player development. Again, if this is such a great way to train youngsters, then why don't Barcelona or Arsenal treat their starlets the same way?
We all know the answer, but people don't want to admit it.
And we saw how great loaning out Criscito was, too. Now he'd rather not come back.
People are too focused on Serie A playing experience and overlook other areas of player development. Again, if this is such a great way to train youngsters, then why don't Barcelona or Arsenal treat their starlets the same way?
We all know the answer, but people don't want to admit it.
Carlos Vela was loaned out and he has heeps of potential not forgetting kieron gibbs last year,senderos,traore and injanuary alone they loaned out 5 youngsters
barca dont loan out youngsters but look at what that has done to the likes of giovanni dos santos and caceres who have found a lot of quality and established players ahead of them
and ppl keep bitching bout loans...we had fukin ruineri who was as dumb as a fukin ant but with ciro weve already seen how hes integrated marchisio,giovinco and to a lesser extent marrone into the first team
if ciro thinks this is the right move then im all for it
barca dont loan out youngsters but look at what that has done to the likes of giovanni dos santos and caceres who have found a lot of quality and established players ahead of them
and ppl keep bitching bout loans...we had fukin ruineri who was as dumb as a fukin ant but with ciro weve already seen how hes integrated marchisio,giovinco and to a lesser extent marrone into the first team
if ciro thinks this is the right move then im all for it
