Juventuz man of the match 2012/2013 (3 Viewers)

[Quetzalcoatl]

Nice, well I hope you two make that bet

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Fake Melo]

Updated.

 

[Fake Melo]

Marchisio has been our MOTM the last three matches (Roma, Shakhtar, Siena). Interesting.

 

[ZoSo]

This isn't even up to date.

 

[Buck Fuddy]

Since Fake Melo is too busy doing nothing useful, I went ahead and updated it myself. We're halfway through the season, so this could be quite interesting.

Results are quite similar to what I personally would come up with.




Serie-A

Round 1: Juventus 2 - 0 Parma (Kwadwo Asamoah MOTM with 69 votes)

Round 2: Udinese 1 - 4 Juventus (Sebastian Giovinco MOTM with 91 votes)

Round 3: Genoa 1 - 3 Juventus (Mirko Vucinic MOTM with 48 votes)

Round 4: Juventus 2 - 0 Chievo (Fabio Quagliarella MOTM with 102 votes)

Round 5: Fiorentina 0 - 0 Juventus (Kwadwo Asamoah MOTM with 36 votes)

Round 6: Juventus 4 - 1 Roma (Claudio Marchisio MOTM with 66 votes)

Round 7: Siena 1 - 2 Juventus (Claudio Marchisio MOTM with 42 votes)

Round 8: Juventus 2 - 0 Napoli (Sebastian Giovinco MOTM with 40 votes)

Round 9: Catania 0 - 1 Juventus (Arturo Vidal MOTM with 70 votes)

Round 10: Juventus 2 - 1 Bologna (Paul Pogba MOTM with 113 votes)

Round 11: Juventus 1 - 3 Inter (other)

Round 12: Pescara 1 - 6 Juventus (Fabio Quagliarella MOTM with 102 votes)

Round 13: Juventus 0 - 0 Lazio (Arturo Vidal MOTM with 52 votes)

Round 14: Milan 1 - 0 Juventus (no MOTM selected)

Round 15: Juventus 3 - 0 Torino (Claudio Marchisio MOTM with 75 votes)

Round 16: Palermo 0 - 1 Juventus (Stephan Lichtsteiner MOTM 48 votes)

Round 17: Juventus 3 - 0 Atalanta (Andrea Pirlo MOTM with 53 votes)

Round 18: Cagliari 1 - 3 Juventus (Alessandro Matri MOTM with 90 votes)

Round 19: Juventus 1 - 2 Sampdoria (no MOTM selected)

---------------------------------------

Champions League:

Chelsea 2 - 2 Juventus (Arturo Vidal MOTM with 107 votes)

Juventus 1 - 1 Shakhtar Donetsk (Claudio Marchisio MOTM with 25 votes)

Nordsjælland 1 - 1 Juventus (no MOTM selected)

Juventus 4 - 0 Nordsjælland (Claudio Marchisio MOTM with 42 votes)

Juventus 3 - 0 Chelsea (Giorgio Chiellini MOTM with 79 votes)

Shakhtar Donetsk 0 - 1 Juventus (Giorgio Chiellini MOTM with 46 votes)
---------------------------------------


Coppa Italia

Juventus 1 - 0 Cagliari (Sebastian Giovinco MOTM with 27 votes)

--------------------------------------



So far:

Kwadwo Asamoah: 2

Sebastian Giovinco: 3

Mirko Vucinic: 1

Arturo Vidal: 3

Fabio Quagliarella: 2

Claudio Marchisio: 5

Paul Pogba: 1

Giorgio Chiellini: 2

Stepghan Lichtsteiner: 1

Andrea Pirlo: 1

Alessandro Matri: 1

 

[icemaη]

You don't say

 

[Ahmed]

not bad for a Calciopoli beneficiary.

 

[Cheesio]

Not bad for someone who has been underperforming this season. @Dule90;

 

[Klin]

Results are quite similar to what I personally would come up with.

 

[Buck Fuddy]

Don't be silly, Brows.

My excel records put less or no emphasis at all on 1 mom each game, but rather all player's performances for each game


But this list of MOM's makes sense. Guys like for example Barzagli & Lichtsteiner have been among our best & most consistent performers, but have very few or no games where they stand out individually so I wouldn't expect them to feature much in this particular list.
Others like Quag & Gio for example are not consistent at all, but they have been clear MOM's for certain games.

 

[Klin]

It's all about consistency.

 

[Fake Melo]

Thanks Buck, I was supposed to do this after the Atalanta match, but totally forgot. Will update the first post.

 

[Ahmed]

#FakeMeloMerda

 

[Cheesio]

 

[Red]

Don't be silly, Brows.

My excel records put less or no emphasis at all on 1 mom each game, but rather all player's performances for each game

You do ratings for players in every game?

Who are the players with the highest ratings to this point?

 

[Buck Fuddy]

I do.

Looking at the ones who play regularly, so far I have: Marchisio, Vidal, Lichtsteiner, Giovinco, Barzagli. In that order.

Giovinco being someone who may not "deserve" to be there. Then again, he has been quite prolific.

 

[Red]

Slightly surprised to see Vidal that high up.

While he's had some very good games, feel as though he's had quite a few poor ones.

- - - Updated - - -

Then again, doing this sort of rating usually throws up something interesting.

Niall McGinn - Aberdeen's top scorer by miles and the leading SPL scorer from open play - is only fourth in my Aberdeen ratings (admittedly, he'd probably be top, but he's played a starring role in games I haven't seen, so can't rate).

As much as I approve of them, I find it quite hard to rate players who do almost nothing apart from score.

 

[Buck Fuddy]

Yeah, there's always the issue of games you miss, and those will lead to (subtle) differences. But it's still quite interesting to have some sort of overview, to have something that you can look back on, rather than going by your own selective memory.

For instance, I'd never come up with Gio (and possibly Vidal, like you mentioned), if someone were to ask me who have been the best performers so far. Because that's not how I recall the season so far at this moment. But adding up all individual games/performances, that's what comes up...

 

[Fake Melo]

Vidal and Marchisio both with 5 matches each now. Pretty sure one of them will have win Juventuz player of the year.

 

[Fake Melo]

Updated: Unless Marchisio has great 3-4 games at the end of the season, Vidal will win it. Vucinic in his current form could get nr 2.