Here is my point of view:
Lets start with the management:
-They signed Capello who is well known to be one of the best coaches in the world
-They signed the following players:
1- Cannavaro (which obiously is one of the best defenders in the world) a direct trade with our loaned out Carini
2- Zebina: he was for free, plus he showed some good performances
3- Emerson paid around 12 million
4- Blasi back from loan
5- Zlatan: paid around 19 million if I am correct.
6- Mutu: for free but during winter
And signed out:
1- Maresca: on loan (this I don't understand I really wished he stayed, a very good player in the midfeild that we need but the budget was tight).
2- Micolli: part ownership, we have enough attackers
3- Davids: We got emerson and blasi
4- and lately Legrotellia, iuliano and Tudor: which I understand their performance has been weak
So I think the management did their job well in the transfer market, only down side is we dont have a very good replacement for Nedved, although Olivera/kapo might cover on easy to moderate clashes but not against big clubs.
====================================================
Coach:
Positive: Did well with th team, well organized especially after last season where all players weren't playing well. Motivation was back.
Negative: The Del Piero issue is very controvertial. I don't want to comment on that except I feel that he didn't handle the situation well. I am biased to Alex but I am not blinded.
In comparision with Lippi, the team feels less active and less surprising.
We won against Udinese because we changed the formation to 3-4-3 which was surprising.
====================================================
Players:
Buffon: Gigi enough said.. no comments on that, best goal keeper in the world
Ferrara: I think he is now there to motivate the players more than paticipate in the matches. he knows that. Gave Juve alot in the past.
Tacchinardi: I read somewhere that the only person in the world that can actually tell him that he played badly is his mom LOL. He didn't play enough, but when he played he was ok.
Montero: His mistakes are life threatning. e.g. parma
Pessotto: Although he's aging, he's playing ok. Not spectacular but ok. He has to work on his fittness more.
Zlatan: He plays well. One of the most spectacular Juve players this season. Only downside that sometimes he does play team work which leaves the team'd hands tied.
Del Piero: His season hasn't been that impressive, reason well he's been injured alot. His fittness is still not 100% reached (thats because he is not participating with the 1st team enought). He didn't play enough but managed to score 7 goals never the less. I am positive if he played more he would have improved alot.
Nedved: Good season cut by unfortunate injury which left the team without a playmaker
Chementi: His participation in Coppa italia wasn't that impressive. But then again the whole coppa italia formation was not impressive at all.
Birindelli: Not playing well this season.
Camoranesi: Started low this season, but currently one of the vital Juve players.
Trezeguet: Give him time to recover from injury
Appiah: PLEASE SELL THIS PLAYER.
Zambrotta: Used and abused.. Still he was better programed with Lippi. Capello has still to find how to make him work. He is one of the best side players in the world. When he is working he is absolutely UNSTOPABLE.
Blasi: Great player and good season
Thuram: His placement next to Cannavaro showed his streangth.
Olivera: Started the season well, but his latest matches are disasters.
Zalayata: Good season, but he is a good substitute, not a first line player.
Kapo: Didn't take enough feild time to be judged.
Cannavaro: Best juve player of the season.
====================================================
It seems that our problem is that we don't have a reliable replacement for Nedved. I think if Capello started playing 3-4-3 once Nedved got injured the outcome would've been much much better.
Currently Del Piero is the spirit of Juventus. This is something Capello has to understand. Del Piero got injured alot during the past 7 years. We are lucky that he is still playing and scoring. Many players who went through 2/3 the number of injuries are not even playing now.
I just want you all to remember 2~3 seasons ago when Del piero go injured. When he got back Lippi feild him no matter what, after few games he was back scoring. he ended scoring 16 goals in two consecutive Serie A seasons with Lippi. Mind you he is not a finisher, i.e. not trezeguet.
I think Capello should concentrate more on making the 3-4-3 formation work. This way the team feels more alive. Even after Nedved is back this formation feels more alive and ready to surprise.