This season aside from his very high consistency:
Scored and Assisted against Juve
Scored Twice against Lazio
Assist against Milan
Scored against fiorentina
Scored twice against Inter
Last Season:
Scored Twice against Lazio
Scored against Milan
Assist against fiorentina
Scored against Inter
Scored against Lazio
Scored twice against Juve
Scored against fiorentina
Scored and assisted against Roma
Season before last:
Scored a hatrick against Lazio
Scored against Roma
Scored 2 against Milan
Scored against Lazio
Scored against Inter
Scored Twice against Lazio
Assisted twice against fiorentina
Scored against Milan.
You consider Dnipro the kind of big team match that he flops in so your standards for a big match are actually quiet low. By higher standards than yours (teams bigger than Dnipro) you should include all these exceptions:
BVB Dortmund (H) UCL: Scored
Marseille (A) UCL: Assisted
Marseille (H) UCL: Scored 2
BVB Dortmund (A) UCL : Assisted
Arsenal (H) UCL: scored.
Athletic Bilbao (H) UCL: scored
Dinamo Moscow (H) Europa: Scored a Hatrick
Wolfsburg (A) Europa: Scored and Assisted
Wolfsburg (H) Europa: Assisted
By your standards (Dnipro standard) you'd have to include Warsaw, Trabzonspor and the likes whom he has more than a good record against him.
Again Morata showed very good nerves last season but as an overall player he is still far from Higuain's level. Morata has been flopping this season against both small and big teams.
The legend said Higuain is a big game choker with just a few exceptions. You seem to misunderstand the meaning of the term few and exceptions. If anything (statistically), he performs on big occasions much more than he does not. No one is claiming he is the new R9, or the new messi, but morata still has a lot of growing to do to be as good as higuain.
- - - Updated - - -
and we all know that Morata is already much better than Ibra ever was