Igor Tudor - Manager (88 Viewers)

May 11, 2005
14,621
Got it badly wrong today.

Completely outthought by Juric. Starting lineup was terrible too. Some key points which are a concern given how much he makes these mistakes:

- Openda is not a number 9 and cannot play through the middle on his own.
- Kalulu at RWB is a complete waste. We lose any attacking threat down the right which puts all the focus on Yildiz and allows them to double mark more easily.
- Gatti is a liability. He makes brainless mistakes but what's worse he can't do the basic defending you'd expect from someone his size. Kalulu should be our RCB.
- We need a centre mid to sit and protect the defence. Koop is not capable of this. Based on the squad Locatelli is the player for that role. He has limitations but is the only one who can defend.
- Kelly makes brainless mistakes and his gets caught out positionally. We absolutely cannot afford both him and Gatti in the starting lineup.

Really poor dropping points at home to a weakened Atalanta side, who aren't the same level as previous years. The most annoying thing is how avoidable the goals we have conceded have been. Individual mistakes are costing us hugely.
 

Xperd

Allegrophobic Infidel
Jun 1, 2012
35,913
You only know what you know. He lacks the experience and at this point it’s impossible to tell if his career will be a successful one as a coach.

I do feel these players have more to offer than he’s able to get out of them.
He's spent 12 years as a coach. Thats a long time. Not lasted more than a year at any club side. How did we expect him to become magically successful when there's no previous history of success? He would've never got the job if he wasn't a former player. Lets not forget that he wasn't even first choice for coach to begin with.

Just another stupid hire that we'll cut our losses with once this season ends.
 

Xperd

Allegrophobic Infidel
Jun 1, 2012
35,913
I'm not blaming him at all. Too many trash players in the squad.
Every year we'll keep peddling this nonsense about having trash players.

True to an extent but guess what, we are not going to sign world class players. The squad isn't going to be magically fixed with billion dollar investments so you would need a coach who can make the most out of existing personnel.

It's the coach's job to identify the weaknesses in the squad and put together a formation that can mitigate that impact.

Why is he insisting on playing a 2 man midfield when midfield has been identified as the weakest area of the team?

Why does he insist on playing CB's as WB's? What purpose is he trying to achieve? Why even play a wingback system when we don't have quality wingbacks on either side?

The gap in quality in Serie Ass teams isn't huge but the coaching certainly is. We have the weakest coach out of all top 4 candidates.
 
Aug 10, 2017
16,762
Every year we'll keep peddling this nonsense about having trash players.

True to an extent but guess what, we are not going to sign world class players. The squad isn't going to be magically fixed with billion dollar investments so you would need a coach who can make the most out of existing personnel.

It's the coach's job to identify the weaknesses in the squad and put together a formation that can mitigate that impact.

Why is he insisting on playing a 2 man midfield when midfield has been identified as the weakest area of the team?

Why does he insist on playing CB's as WB's? What purpose is he trying to achieve? Why even play a wingback system when we don't have quality wingbacks on either side?

The gap in quality in Serie Ass teams isn't huge but the coaching certainly is. We have the weakest coach out of all top 4 candidates.
Balkan Motta though it is not easy situation to be at Juve with the mess that Giuntoli has left behind.
 
Nov 9, 2005
16,697
The problem is that while in the past you had Chiellini-Bonucci-Barzagli backline where we could sometimes say if play back 3 or back 4 and you just couldnt drop them. Both Gatti and Kelly are droppable players. Just arent at the level. And i dont understand why both Tudor and the management werent pushing harder for another CB. Im not asking them to sign prime Nesta. We cant do better than Gatti and Kelly? Juventus football club cant scout better defenders?

How much longer are we playing Koopmeiners? There are options, there are solutions. Its not like he is the only midfielder we have.
 

Scottish

Zebrastreifenpferd
Mar 13, 2011
10,983
You only know what you know. He lacks the experience and at this point it’s impossible to tell if his career will be a successful one as a coach.

I do feel these players have more to offer than he’s able to get out of them.
For me the most frustrating thing is that we see periods of play when it all clicks and you see what we could (or maybe should) be doing all game.

But 80% or more of games we're plodding through. We still can't unlock a structured defence which is a huge issue because most Serie A teams will look to sit back against us and that's what they'll all tend to do if they score against us.

Openda in the centre on his own was a disastrous idea. Koop was better than normal but still well under par. Cambiaso put in the usual frustrating performance (when he let the ball run through his legs to nobody I had to leave the room for a second).

He needs to have strategies for when subs come on rather than subbing in whichever forward when we need a goal. We can't just rely on individual moments because none of the players are reliably good enough.

On the plus side I do like that he is clearly trying to mould the tactics for the players he has and is also giving players time to grow into their roles, but not too much time. Not starting Locatelli was ballsy even though it didn't work out. Just not close to good enough consistently enough.
 
May 14, 2006
11,929
Harsh.

Zero midfield, Bricklayer at CB and has the balls to start a youngster who everyone wanted to see playy but it's backfired due to Adzic being a retard.
Yet he refuses to balance the midfield, yet he rather starts Kalulu as RWB and Gatti as RCB. He could use Kalulu as RCB and has a few options down the right. Team looks gassed and absolutely shattered after week 4 and uses tiredness as an excuse…. He’s stubborn and his freaking formation does not work.

His rocky balboa dna speeches don’t work no more - get rid before the damage is done


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
 

Lion

King of Tuz
Jan 24, 2007
36,523
Yet he refuses to balance the midfield, yet he rather starts Kalulu as RWB and Gatti as RCB. He could use Kalulu as RCB and has a few options down the right. Team looks gassed and absolutely shattered after week 4 and uses tiredness as an excuse…. He’s stubborn and his freaking formation does not work.

His rocky balboa dna speeches don’t work no more - get rid before the damage is done


Gesendet von iPhone mit Tapatalk
Why do you think he is stubborn? His idols are allegri and Capello
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 18, Guests: 65)