Louie Simmons. Please. You lost pretty much all credibility you had. What next? Rippetoe? These are people who have defined their own squatting styles. They've engineered a style, away from a natural Olympic squat, in order to be able to lift more weight.
And there's nothing wrong with that, but there is something very wrong with what you're taking away from it.
I'd hardly say I am the one stirring controversy. If you read my posts, you'll see that I clearly say both squat styles have their advantages. You on the other hand are claiming some sort of weird superiority on part of the low bar squat, which makes no sense whatsoever.
Why the high bar squat would be less of a compound baffles me. It works the quads, glutes, hamstrings, back and abs. That's pretty much a compound exercise if you ask me.
I'm glad however that we both agree the deadlift is king.
- - - Updated - - -
Look at this and tell me that:
- this guy has no glute development
- this doesn't look like a compound exercise
- there is no sense of inherent fluidity and thus safety in the way he's performing this exercise.
And there's nothing wrong with that, but there is something very wrong with what you're taking away from it.
I'd hardly say I am the one stirring controversy. If you read my posts, you'll see that I clearly say both squat styles have their advantages. You on the other hand are claiming some sort of weird superiority on part of the low bar squat, which makes no sense whatsoever.
Why the high bar squat would be less of a compound baffles me. It works the quads, glutes, hamstrings, back and abs. That's pretty much a compound exercise if you ask me.
I'm glad however that we both agree the deadlift is king.
- - - Updated - - -
Look at this and tell me that:
- this guy has no glute development
- this doesn't look like a compound exercise
- there is no sense of inherent fluidity and thus safety in the way he's performing this exercise.
I named louie as an example. I'm not a fan of him. I'm a raw powerlifter. Tutchscherer and Sheiko are the trainers of reference.
I quite dislike how multiply powerlifting is tarnishing the squat with their 4 inch roms. Konstantinovs pulling 420kg deadlifts without a suit or even a belt, thats what i call impressive
I need to add an exception byw. Mikhael Koklyaev. Excellent olympic lifter. And later strongmen. And later powerlifter. And currently probably the best deadlifter in the world with a straight bar
- - - Updated - - -
Lastly, during the steroid era of the 80s, O-lifters managed to lift competitively right into their late 30s, especially in the heavier weight classes. The problem for this isn't joint destruction though, it's more so what you first mentioned, flexibility, and diminishing returns from speed-strength training, the elasticity of the muscles has lessened, making it much harder to compete at a high level in an exercise that requires taking advantage of tissue viscoelasticity in order to succeed.
Unless you are taking deca, wich borderline cures a destroyed joint as long as you are injecting it.
I've seen quite a few bodybuilders, who offcourse do everything with a bar wrong, with various degrees of joint issues. Who completely dissapeared as soon as the second half life of the deca they were injecting passed.
But yeah, flexibility and speed. The latter is also a killer for the more lightweight powerlifters it seems
- - - Updated - - -
I squat high bar but I want to stop that shit and front squat instead.
I dont understand, what is the problem with high bar squats for you ?
