Give it to Xavi if there's justice (27 Viewers)

Hist

Founder of Hism
Jan 18, 2009
11,603
Robben was hard done by too ya know. If milito should be there... then robben deserves it more. Robben literally carried bayern munich to the CL final. He also won the double and reached a world cup final. He is far more important to bayern than Sneijder is to Inter (inter was more of a unit). Looking at his goals... all beautiful.

Forlan had a terrible snub as well. The best player in the world cup and won the Europa League with Athletico... what more can be asked of a player like him?

Forlan & Robben & Sneijder had better seasons than the barca boys... especially messi and iniesta.
 

Trezegol17

Senior Member
Nov 1, 2006
9,131
Robben was hard done by too ya know. If milito should be there... then robben deserves it more. Robben literally carried bayern munich to the CL final. He also won the double and reached a world cup final. He is far more important to bayern than Sneijder is to Inter (inter was more of a unit). Looking at his goals... all beautiful.

Forlan had a terrible snub as well. The best player in the world cup and won the Europa League with Athletico... what more can be asked of a player like him?

Forlan & Robben & Sneijder had better seasons than the barca boys... especially messi and iniesta.
I agree , Robben should been at least in the top 5, I was to focussed on Sneijder that i forgot how important Robben was for Bayern!
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Why would anyone laugh at Xavi being in top 3?
Firstly, I was laughing at the "Xavi, Messi, Iniesta" joke not merely at Xavi and second, it's not like Xavi had a special season performance-wise either. In a world cup year though, the winners' players traditionally have a better chance of winning the best player of the year so I guess he is the most deserved to win it especially while competing with Messi and Iniesta.
 
OP
Azzurri7

Azzurri7

Pinturicchio
Moderator
Dec 16, 2003
72,692
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #266
    Firstly, I was laughing at the "Xavi, Messi, Iniesta" joke not merely at Xavi and second, it's not like Xavi had a special season performance-wise either. In a world cup year though, the winners' players traditionally have a better chance of winning the best player of the year so I guess he is the most deserved to win it especially while competing with Messi and Iniesta.
    Is this a joke?

    Special season? Seriously? If everything is working for Barcelona it's because of this man. But then again it can be matter of taste and how I see football is different from the way you do. But to me, Xavi is the engine, the brain in Spain and Barcelona much more than anyone.

    No player has been as consistent as Xavi, not even Sneijder, Robben, Messi, Ronaldo combined.

    Sneijder deserves to be there? Yes he does, who deserves to win this one? Xavi without thinking twice.
     

    king Ale

    Senior Member
    Oct 28, 2004
    21,689
    Why should you two disagree? They are Barcelona players :eyebrows:

    Consistency means nothing when we are talking about the best player of ONE year. It's not like this prize is given to a player for his 10 year service. Sneijder too had a consistently excellent season. Xavi's was no particularly special compared to Sneijder's. He won the world cup though and this is why he probably deserves to be among the top three.

    Messi and Iniesta being there is ridiculous enough for laughing at the the chosen top three.
     

    Dostoevsky

    Tzu
    Administrator
    May 27, 2007
    88,978
    Why should you two disagree? They are Barcelona players :eyebrows:

    Consistency means nothing when we are talking about the best player of ONE year. It's not like this prize is given to a player for his 10 year service. Sneijder too had a consistently excellent season. Xavi's was no particularly special compared to Sneijder's. He won the world cup though and this is why he probably deserves to be among the top three.

    Messi and Iniesta being there is ridiculous enough for laughing at the the chosen top three.
    Sneijder had a pretty average season when it comes to Serie A. He was shining in the CL.
     

    ALC

    Ohaulick
    Oct 28, 2010
    46,524
    Robben was hard done by too ya know. If milito should be there... then robben deserves it more. Robben literally carried bayern munich to the CL final. He also won the double and reached a world cup final. He is far more important to bayern than Sneijder is to Inter (inter was more of a unit). Looking at his goals... all beautiful.

    Forlan had a terrible snub as well. The best player in the world cup and won the Europa League with Athletico... what more can be asked of a player like him?

    Forlan & Robben & Sneijder had better seasons than the barca boys... especially messi and iniesta.
    Robben was definitely the most influential and dynamic of the bunch. I'm still pissed with his two misses in the final. Had he scored, there would have been no contest. It sucks he went to two finals and didn't win.

    I can't wait to see him play again though, he's amazing to watch.
     

    swag

    L'autista
    Administrator
    Sep 23, 2003
    84,749
    Sneijder had a pretty average season when it comes to Serie A. He was shining in the CL.
    I don't buy that. He made a number of amazing passes and assists in Serie A and was very critical to the club's success. Maybe not Milito-level, but close.
     

    Fred

    Senior Member
    Oct 2, 2003
    41,113
    Sneijder had a pretty average season when it comes to Serie A. He was shining in the CL.
    This is true, even Alen would admit to this. However, i'd say he was quite good in the Serie A, just not world class. Still he was world class in the CL and he was amazing in the World Cup, so that has to count for something, he was a big game player. The problem with Ronaldo was he was the complete opposite, he had a poor world cup, had two poor classico's, and was poor when it mattered in the CL, in the other 30 games he played in that year he was better than all players barring Messi. Personally i wouldn't have put Iniesta at all in the top four, Ronaldo and Sneider had much better years than Iniesta, who was absent for 50% of the year, and even when he was around Xavi and Messi were more instrumental for Barca than he was. What he has going for him is an amazing world cup.

    Moving to Xavi and Messi, Messi was Barca's best player scoring a shit load of goals and assisting so many others, he had two very good classico's and he destroyed Arsenal in the CL. But he played two very poor games against Inter, and in the World cup had a few good games, but played bad when it mattered(Greece and Germany). Xavi was very effective for Barcelona and he was very good in the world cup. The only thing he's got going against him, is the two Inter games, to be honest, i think he is the most deserving this season of the best player award, its a tough call though, and i would say Messi comes second. I'd give Ronaldo third, and Sneider fourth.
     

    bartemous

    Junior Member
    Dec 11, 2010
    75
    Only Xavi could match his wonderful season both with Inter and his national team. Can't believe they didn't even rate him among the top three.

    I hope Xavi wins it. He is the only player among the three who deserves to be there.

    Iniesta? It's like nominating Materazzi for the best player of the year 2006.
    I think Iniesta deserves to win he's won of the best players. I have to agree that this season wasn't he's best but he still deservs to win at least more than Xavi I think.
     
    OP
    Azzurri7

    Azzurri7

    Pinturicchio
    Moderator
    Dec 16, 2003
    72,692
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #277
    Why should you two disagree? They are Barcelona players :eyebrows:
    I didn't get it. Am I missing something?

    Consistency means nothing when we are talking about the best player of ONE year. It's not like this prize is given to a player for his 10 year service. Sneijder too had a consistently excellent season. Xavi's was no particularly special compared to Sneijder's. He won the world cup though and this is why he probably deserves to be among the top three.
    I wouldn't blame you really. If you had played a football you would know what it is to be consistent on such a level for a long period. If you think consistency means nothing then I can't really explain it to you.

    Xavi wasn't anything special compared to Sneijder? Do you even realize Xavi's importance for his NT and his club? Do you even know the difference he makes on the field from Sneijder's impact? Sneijder had very special year yes, he deserves to be on the podium true, but was he good enough to over-take Xavi? Never.

    Maybe scoring goals to some sums everything, to me it's not the case and Xavi is the brain and engine that lead Spain and is leading Barcelona to victories/impressing/achievements etc...
     
    OP
    Azzurri7

    Azzurri7

    Pinturicchio
    Moderator
    Dec 16, 2003
    72,692
  • Thread Starter
  • Thread Starter #279
    Another thing, being poor for the last 4months makes it easier on me and other to pick Xavi over the poor Sneijder for the last 4months.
     

    Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 27)