Nicholas

MIRKO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jan 30, 2008
38,737
Obvious not, but he's not perfect either.
Lets break it down.

Excellent signings:

Barzagli
Bonucci
Lichtsteiner
Asamoah
Isla
Vucinic
Giovinco
Vidal
Pirlo
Pogba

Solid signings

Storari
Caceres
Padoin
Matri
Quag
Giach
Storari

Terrible signings

Martinez
Lucio(Paid nothing)
Krasic
Ziegler(Paid nothing)
Bendtner(loan)
Borrigol(loan)
Traore(loan)


Marotta has done a very good job here and for anyone to say otherwise is stupid. At the end of this season it'll be his third year in charge and we could've won two championships and Italian cup and potentially another cup. That's some achievement.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

TrezJuve

Senior Member
May 26, 2010
7,414
I said he's not perfect and I stand by it.

He has done a good job at creating a squad, I've already mentioned it in one of my old posts in this thread. It's just sometimes, he gets a player for the sake of getting one (Boriello, Bendtner, etc.).

Also, his statements about the top player in the past few seasons were just irritating. He probably had not enough funds, can't be blamed over that, but he could have restrained himself from making those statements.
 

Xperd

Allegrophobic Infidel
Jun 1, 2012
35,005
I said he's not perfect and I stand by it.

He has done a good job at creating a squad, I've already mentioned it in one of my old posts in this thread. It's just sometimes, he gets a player for the sake of getting one (Boriello, Bendtner, etc.).

Also, his statements about the top player in the past few seasons were just irritating. He probably had not enough funds, can't be blamed over that, but he could have restrained himself from making those statements.
Well said. :tup:

+ rep
 

.zero

★ ★ ★
Aug 8, 2006
82,893
Lets break it down.

Excellent signings:

Barzagli
Bonucci
Lichtsteiner
Asamoah
Isla
Vucinic
Giovinco
Vidal
Pirlo
Pogba

Solid signings

Storari
Caceres
Padoin
Matri
Quag
Giach
Storari

Terrible signings

Martinez
Lucio(Paid nothing)
Krasic
Ziegler(Paid nothing)
Bendtner(loan)
Borrigol(loan)
Traore(loan)


Marotta has done a very good job here and for anyone to say otherwise is stupid. At the end of this season it'll be his third year in charge and we could've won two championships and Italian cup and potentially another cup. That's some achievement.
Bukakke much lately?
 

Lion

King of Tuz
Jan 24, 2007
36,185
Lets break it down.

Excellent signings:

Barzagli
Bonucci
Lichtsteiner
Asamoah
Isla
Vucinic
Giovinco
Vidal
Pirlo
Pogba

Solid signings

Storari
Caceres
Padoin
Matri
Quag
Giach
Storari

Terrible signings

Martinez
Lucio(Paid nothing)
Krasic
Ziegler(Paid nothing)
Bendtner(loan)
Borrigol(loan)
Traore(loan)


Marotta has done a very good job here and for anyone to say otherwise is stupid. At the end of this season it'll be his third year in charge and we could've won two championships and Italian cup and potentially another cup. That's some achievement.
how can you classify isla as an excellent signing is beyond me. he hs barely played for juve, and whe he has he has been either ok, or awful.

and if you say it's because he was great for udinese i hope you get perma banned
 

JCK

Biased
JCK
May 11, 2004
125,386
how can you classify isla as an excellent signing is beyond me. he hs barely played for juve, and whe he has he has been either ok, or awful.

and if you say it's because he was great for udinese i hope you get perma banned
Curva said he was great which means he is great. End of.
 

Zacheryah

Senior Member
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
I said he's not perfect and I stand by it.

He has done a good job at creating a squad, I've already mentioned it in one of my old posts in this thread. It's just sometimes, he gets a player for the sake of getting one (Boriello, Bendtner, etc.).

Also, his statements about the top player in the past few seasons were just irritating. He probably had not enough funds, can't be blamed over that, but he could have restrained himself from making those statements.
I usually allways defend marotta, and you didnt mention the financial aspect like cutting wage bill etc.

But the part on bold is nail on the head.

- - - Updated - - -

how can you classify isla as an excellent signing is beyond me. he hs barely played for juve, and whe he has he has been either ok, or awful.

and if you say it's because he was great for udinese i hope you get perma banned
cmon lion, cant diss a player in this circumstance


he came from a long injury, then had to go against lichtsteiner. played some decent games showing bits, but 2 bad games, and benched for licht since.

He simply needs more time


Mind you, if we would rate players like this, zidane would absolutely suck and be sold. He only started to shine at the second half of the first season
 

Lion

King of Tuz
Jan 24, 2007
36,185
i am not dissing isla.

i just think it's foolish t classify him as a great transfer when he has played a whopping 5 games for juve and been rubbish in 4 of them, just as it's unfair to pass judgment on him until the end of the season.

also its not my problem or your problem that he comes from a long injury. marotta and conte should have thought about that before they decided to go for him
 

Zacheryah

Senior Member
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
i am not dissing isla.

i just think it's foolish t classify him as a great transfer when he has played a whopping 5 games for juve and been rubbish in 4 of them, just as it's unfair to pass judgment on him until the end of the season.

also its not my problem or your problem that he comes from a long injury. marotta and conte should have thought about that before they decided to go for him
ah that i agree to, far to early to rate


i think conte and marotta have long therm plans for him and know he wasent going to be rigth back
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 45)