I would have agreed up until we signed Higuain. Higuain was a massive risk designed specifically to win us the CL.
Although most of the signings you listed were no-brainers really. And in the past we actually made low risk and high ceiling moves like Coman, Pogba, Pirlo, Barzagli, Vidal, Alves, Tevez where we risked literally nothing but the payoff was huge.
But since then the transfer market has been $#@!ed beyond belief and everyone costs minimum 20M. And Marotta will always take a free player who can contribute.
Listen, I try to recognize Higuain's virtues as most as I can. In Italian football, he's an absolute killer. I have the opinion that last season, we only got scudetto because of him -almost exclusively because of him. But to me it's very clear now that he's not good enought to lead a team to a CL victory.
I'm not exactly talking about costs, but profile. Higuain has the precise profile that would justify a change. He still holds market value; and you have a pretty good idea about what he delivers - and while it's great domestically, it's not near enough in the bigger picture.
Those other guys are not as cheap as it seems. They are experienced players and make big salaries, like Khedira.
I just think the "right mix" between youngsters and experienced players, like Marotta says, absolutely needs more potential, and less certified but limited quality. Matuidi is also a great example - and considering his salary, he's not cheap at all.
- - - Updated - - -
Most importantly, as I've been saying for months now is that we have to choose to play 4-3-3 and we have to choose JUST ONE of Higuain or Dybala.
The team plays better in literally any configuration of players in a 4-3-3 shape.
I'm 100% on selling Higuain and investing on Dybala as a CF, or false CF. This could work out beautifully. Invest the money on fullbacks and midfielders.