I think it's great. It's not story based so in that regard it's average at best. But when it comes to combat and depth plus content, I'd say it's really, really good. There's tons of stuff to do plus classes are great and quite well balanced unlike in WoW that's falling apart.
As for Elden Ring, like I thought even a year ago, it's easily going to be game of the year. It's getting 100% and 10/10 reviews everywhere literally.