Yes, but then you go down to the player details, they don't just give players a rating off the top of their head either, it's all down to the various attributes. Videogames will always struggle to replicate mental attributes of a real life player, which are often decisive. Woodgate has a lot of strong attributes for a defender but he is always injured, so, assuming FIFA caters for his injury status, the stats are in effect not wrong.
Does anyone have any examples of full stats for players?