Felipe Melo (252 Viewers)

[Juve Material]

IMO this shows that he is really a quality player but the atmosphere and coaching is not helping him here. Besides, he is simply not a regista.

And this is why it's crazy we signed him because D'ago was too pricey - and Melo was MORE expensive.


Every Juve fan hopes Melo will come good. The answer: Prandelli...

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[giovanotti]

-REP
Felipe Melo 19.03.2010 01:10 keep em coming




......and another one....

 

[X Æ A-12]

We can't make a coaching decision based upon making Melo happy tho. We can cut him some slack because the whole team looks poor this season but if he is worth keeping than he should be able to perform for any good coach we get this summer

 

[Esteban]

He is a quality player I totally agree his not made for Juve as soon as he leaves he will be one of the best out there sadly.. we see this all to often and sadly we continue our trend of players just unable to play here. I dont know what we do or feed them but this is getting ridicolous.

Uhm... no? Melo is a poor footballer who won't make it anywhere. And name me some examples of world beaters that excelled only after leaving Juve? (Henry aside)

 

[Nicholas]

Uhm... no? Melo is a poor footballer who won't make it anywhere. And name me some examples of world beaters that excelled only after leaving Juve? (Henry aside)

Zidane

 

[X Æ A-12]

Miccoli, not be a world beater but worth mentioning

 

[Juve Material]

Prandelli is a great coach anyway, him unleashing Melo will be the biggest bonus.

 

[X Æ A-12]

Prandelli has impressed with the gayola but I am not completely sold on him. After this season I want the board to go all out and get the best manager they can, this IMO is far more important than any new signings.

I wouldn't be unhappy to see Prandelli appointed but we need a complete tactical and psychological turn around from a top coach.

 

[Esteban]

Zidane

First of all you were hardly born then, if you're 17 now, so you wouldn't know. And secondly, you're wrong.

Now, what the user Phrozen was thinking about is without a doubt players of recent years, such as Palladino, Criscito, Miccoli, etc. These players couldn't cut it at Juve and are shining at mid table clubs because they are exactly that: stars of mid table clubs, not good enough players to build on to win trophies.

 

[X Æ A-12]

First of all you were hardly born then, if you're 17 now, so you wouldn't know. And secondly, you're wrong.

.

So that somehow unvalidated his point?

And a lot of players have been underperforming at Juve recently, it is difficult to judge who sucks and who is a victim of the situation

 

[Nicholas]

First of all you were hardly born then, if you're 17 now, so you wouldn't know. And secondly, you're wrong.

Now, what the user Phrozen was thinking about is without a doubt players of recent years, such as Palladino, Criscito, Miccoli, etc. These players couldn't cut it at Juve and are shining at mid table clubs because they are exactly that: stars of mid table clubs, not good enough players to build on to win trophies.

19 actually you dolt.

 

[Esteban]

So you guys think Zidane was complete rubbish for Juve and only became a great at Real? That's interesting.

 

[PhRoZeN]

Uhm... no? Melo is a poor footballer who won't make it anywhere. And name me some examples of world beaters that excelled only after leaving Juve? (Henry aside)

world beaters is such a wrong word, Henry was certainly that. However the following players made a bigger impact in their careers after leaving us/ still with us.

Ibrahimovic
Almiron
Appiah
Maresca
Blasi
Boumsong
Brighi
Perrota
Criscito
Palladino
De Sanctis
Gasbaroni
Marchionni
Zanetti
Miccoli
Nocerino
Moretti
Vieri
Van Der Sar
Isaakson

Thats all that comes to mind. Either way im sure quite a lot of them make our our current crop of players look crap.

 

[X Æ A-12]

So you guys think Zidane was complete rubbish for Juve and only became a great at Real? That's interesting.

Ummm... no

 

[Nicholas]

So you guys think Zidane was complete rubbish for Juve and only became a great at Real? That's interesting.

It seems I misunderstood the question, my apologies.

 

[Esteban]

world beaters is such a wrong word, Henry was certainly that. However the following players made a bigger impact in their careers after leaving us/ still with us.

Ibrahimovic
Almiron
Appiah
Maresca
Blasi
Boumsong
Brighi
Perrota
Criscito
Palladino
De Sanctis
Gasbaroni
Marchionni
Zanetti
Miccoli
Nocerino
Moretti
Vieri

Thats all that comes to mind. Either way im sure quite a lot of them make our our current crop of players look crap.

But what you suggested was that Melo would once again be "one of the best out there" and you then went on to suggest that this is something that frequently occurs with players that leave Juve.

None of those players fit the bill except Vieri and Ibra but they weren't exactly crap for Juve either.

 

[PhRoZeN]

But what you suggested was that Melo would once again be "one of the best out there" and you then went on to suggest that this is something that frequently occurs with players that leave Juve.

None of those players fit the bill except Vieri and Ibra but they weren't exactly crap for Juve either.

Ok my wording was certainly wrong there no denying but It wasnt to difficult to figure out what i meant there. What I do believe however is that he will make it bigger than his made it here. Already an international player has a good partner plays it simple and I think an EPL club like Arsenal would suit him best, matter of time.

 

[C4ISR]

he was one of the better ones today for sure

Which says more about the rest of the team than it does his performance.

 

[Juve Material]

Zlatan was missing open goals in his last season.

But there is no logic here - just because it hasn't happened before (debatable) doesn't mean it will not happen in the future.

 

[Esteban]

Ok my wording was certainly wrong there no denying but It wasnt to difficult to figure out what i meant there. What I do believe however is that he will make it bigger than his made it here. Already an international player has a good partner plays it simple and I think an EPL club like Arsenal would suit him best, matter of time.

Alright mate. Sure, there is a slim chance he could be somewhat useful if he had the chance to work with a top coach that believed in him. But then again, I see no reason why a top class coach would do so. After seeing him play since this august I still haven't figured out what his role in the midfield is. Is he a defensively or offensively oriented player? He just isn't very good in any area of the game.