Felipe Melo (30 Viewers)

[Buck Fuddy]

There are still a lot of Juve haters out there.
And the better we become, the more, they hate us...

However is not the phenomenon he was with Fiorentina though. Which i believe its normal, for many reasons.

I believe he is there, mostly because of the expectations, his salary has arisen...

True.

Couple that with his transfer price and you can't deny the fact that he has not yet delivered what people expected.

 

Buy on AliExpress.com

[Alen]

True.

Couple that with his transfer price and you can't deny the fact that he has not yet delivered what people expected.

Neither has Diego, but it still doesn't grant a place among chokers like Huntelaar, Quaresma or Tiago.

Anyway, it's not only about transfers made in 2009. Usually players who didn't deliver what was expected from them, and did much less than the expected, were on these lists and were winning it. Adriano was winning it many years after he was bought by Inter.

So if it's about expectations and failing hard to deliver them, then players like Pirlo, Vucinic, and even Amauri, deserve a place on that list much more than Felipe Melo.

I'm a huge Amauri fan and defender, but 17 months ago we bought him for 22m eur and he was on a 8 month goalless streak in 2009. Why is a DMC bought for almost as much, who scored 2 goals in 2 months with Juve, on the list and not Amauri?

Melo hasn't delivered yet what was expected from him, I agree. He's losing concentration during matches and once it already cost us points. But he's been having monster performances too, and on this list only players who failed hard to deliver what was expected from them should be included.

 

[giovanotti]

Neither has Diego, but it still doesn't grant a place among chokers like Huntelaar, Quaresma or Tiago.

Anyway, it's not only about transfers made in 2009. Usually players who didn't deliver what was expected from them, and did much less than the expected, were on these lists and were winning it. Adriano was winning it many years after he was bought by Inter.

So if it's about expectations and failing hard to deliver them, then players like Pirlo, Vucinic, and even Amauri, deserve a place on that list much more than Felipe Melo.

I'm a huge Amauri fan and defender, but 17 months ago we bought him for 22m eur and he was on a 8 month goalless streak in 2009. Why is a DMC bought for almost as much, who scored 2 goals in 2 months with Juve, on the list and not Amauri?

Melo hasn't delivered yet what was expected from him, I agree. He's losing concentration during matches and once it already cost us points. But he's been having monster performances too, and on this list only players who failed hard to deliver what was expected from them should be included.

Nicely said Alen.

 

[Paolo Sosa]

Forza Melo , prove them wrong

 

[Buck Fuddy]

Neither has Diego, but it still doesn't grant a place among chokers like Huntelaar, Quaresma or Tiago.

Anyway, it's not only about transfers made in 2009. Usually players who didn't deliver what was expected from them, and did much less than the expected, were on these lists and were winning it. Adriano was winning it many years after he was bought by Inter.

So if it's about expectations and failing hard to deliver them, then players like Pirlo, Vucinic, and even Amauri, deserve a place on that list much more than Felipe Melo.

I'm a huge Amauri fan and defender, but 17 months ago we bought him for 22m eur and he was on a 8 month goalless streak in 2009. Why is a DMC bought for almost as much, who scored 2 goals in 2 months with Juve, on the list and not Amauri?

Melo hasn't delivered yet what was expected from him, I agree. He's losing concentration during matches and once it already cost us points. But he's been having monster performances too, and on this list only players who failed hard to deliver what was expected from them should be included.

Hey man, I get what you're saying and you are right. But these kind of lists or competitions always work this way.
For one thing, the majority of the players absolutely need to come from the big 3, or 4 if you count Roma. That's just how it goes since they are most prolific.

I agree Amauri, could & maybe should have been there, but he has had an absolutely great first few months at Juve. This has given him a shitload of credit in Italy (as well as in the rest of Europe).
I mean, how else could you explain the ridiculous frenzy surrounding his possible availability for the NT? There is no way in hell that is based on his performances during the last months.

Diego, for some reason, is very loved around Italy (especially the media) it seems. Perhaps it has something to do with the fact that he is the kind of player that has become "uncommon" in Serie A over the past few years.
Then there's the fact that everybody seems to agree that we bought him for very little money.
Couple that with his workrate, which has surprised a lot of people (including myself) and I understand why he isn't in the list.

Melo on the other hand is regarded as a player that we did not really need. The consensus in the press (Italian as well as foreign) seems to be that we overpaid to get him.
Now, couple that with some of the mistakes he made & with the at times uninterested (for lack of a better word) performances he has been giving.

So, even if I don't necessarily agree with it, I can definitely see why they put him in the list. I'm not even surprised to be honest.

 

[Suns]

I hope this shit doesn't have a negative effect on him.

 

[Salvatore]

Melo won't win it so it doesn't really matter, I think Huntelaar will

It will matter if he tries to impress more and fuck up. I'd like to think that the people who hand out awards for football actually have a clue as well, but as shown in this edition of the Fifa world player of the year awards, hardly anyone does.

Is he there in the Brazil squad for the friendly against Oman?

Yes. Hopefully dropped for Lucas or someone though.

 

[X Æ A-12]

I don't really see the point of caring about pointless personal awards. We have seen in the past that when an award is chosen by critics their personal bias has a huge effect on their decisions, what is important is winning team trophies

 

[giovanotti]

The list was made by inter bastards I can feel it,they know how important he is so they want to destroy his moral.

 

[Nicholas]

To include him on that list is laughable. He had a great year, how did he turn into a flop? laughable.

 

[giovanotti]

To include him on that list is laughable. He had a great year, how did he turn into a flop? laughable.

Agreed!!

 

[X Æ A-12]

Neither has Diego, but it still doesn't grant a place among chokers like Huntelaar, Quaresma or Tiago.

Anyway, it's not only about transfers made in 2009. Usually players who didn't deliver what was expected from them, and did much less than the expected, were on these lists and were winning it. Adriano was winning it many years after he was bought by Inter.

So if it's about expectations and failing hard to deliver them, then players like Pirlo, Vucinic, and even Amauri, deserve a place on that list much more than Felipe Melo.

I'm a huge Amauri fan and defender, but 17 months ago we bought him for 22m eur and he was on a 8 month goalless streak in 2009. Why is a DMC bought for almost as much, who scored 2 goals in 2 months with Juve, on the list and not Amauri?

Melo hasn't delivered yet what was expected from him, I agree. He's losing concentration during matches and once it already cost us points. But he's been having monster performances too, and on this list only players who failed hard to deliver what was expected from them should be included.

Good post especially about Amauri, btw isn't the bidone D'or supposed to follow the calender year, Melo spent half of that on great form at Fiorentina and he delivered with Brazil in the confed cup so him making that list doesn't make sense. Amauri might actually deserve a place on that list since he was horrid for the first half of 09 and pretty poor during this season

 

[X Æ A-12]

The list was made by inter bastards I can feel it,they know how important he is so they want to destroy his moral.

I don't know about Inter but there is clearly some anti-Juve sentiment around

 

[giovanotti]

I don't know about Inter but there is clearly some anti-Juve sentiment around

Sure the thing is obvious.

 

[sallyinzaghi]

Melo'd probably laugh this one off, it's not like he's going to win it

 

[giovanotti]

Yes ,but beeing the best in the group of the worst wouldn't make him feel good.
This thing could affect his moral,that's what I'm afraid of.

 

[X Æ A-12]

Melo is a crazy fuck he won't let this get him down, if anything it will just make him angrier and even more dangerous

 

[Buck Fuddy]

Apparently there's an interview with him in today's Gazzetta about the criticism he has been receiving (plays better for Brazil than for Juve, not worth all the money we paid for him, ...).

So look out for the English translation to pop up later today.

 

[Hust]

Why the hell won't the media just leave the guy alone?

 

[giovanotti]

What the hell is happening???
I meen I 'd be the first one to attack the player if he is not good if he is a flop,but Melo really impressed me ,honestly one of the best midfielders in serie A.He is proving his price he is scoring he is fighting and beside 2silly lacks of concetration he was perfect!