[EU] Champions League 2008/2009 (28 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
Fabregas hardly played at the Euro, Aragones always prefered Xavi to him which was a wrong decision IMO.
But he was their best player in that tournament and they won it, so i don't see how it can be considered a wrong decision.

Plus, doesn't Iniesta play in the same team as Xavi does? How come he hasn't got neither as good a passing rate nor as much assists?
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,352
Not at all. I get mad when people are obvious morons. Vlatko is merely saying he does think Xavi is that great. What does Andy want him to do? Suck Xavi's cock?
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
Not at all. I get mad when people are obvious morons. Vlatko is merely saying he does think Xavi is that great. What does Andy want him to do? Suck Xavi's cock?
I have no problem with Vlatko, he has an opinion, it's valid and we're arguing in a civil manner about it. Just ironic that you call someone else a child that's all.
 

Seven

In bocca al lupo, Fabio.
Jun 25, 2003
39,352
I have no problem with Vlatko, he has an opinion, it's valid and we're arguing in a civil manner about it. Just ironic that you call someone else a child that's all.
I get mad because some people, like DPFL, have been mutilated for life because of some sorry ass regime.

I don't get mad when people say Giovinco's not a good player for example.
 

Bjerknes

"Top Economist"
Mar 16, 2004
116,298
Xavi has the best stats in Europe. I don't care, if people are going to be so moronic, lets have stats prove the ability.

Xavi wins.

Too bad for you.

De Rossi couldn't get it right either. But he's Italian, so of course he's the best.
 

Ahmed

Principino
Sep 3, 2006
47,928
Lionel Messi's home has been burgled...

Police have issued a statement that they will be questioning the Manchester United midfield, as they were nowhere to be seen between the hours of 19.45 and 21.30. :D
 

pitbull

Senior Member
Jul 26, 2007
11,045
1) Why is supporting the Azzurri better than supporting a Spanish club?? All due respect mate, but that doesn't really make any sense.

2) Why do the ones next to him deserve more credit than Xavi does? Doesn't Iniesta play in the same team as Xavi, How come he doesn't have as much assists?

I'm using the Iniesta comparison, instead of Cesc, Pirlo or De Rossi, so that you won't tell me it's easier to pass to Messi and Henry than X and X.

Also, i am not saying Xavi is the better player than Iniesta, i rate Iniesta extremely highly. What i am saying is that Xavi is actually a better passer than Iniesta.

3) How exactly is it easier to find Messi and Henry??
When talking about movement in the final third, Barca are actually a bit lacking in that department imo. Their off the ball movement is brilliant all over the pitch, but when it comes to the final third, Barca's players are actually a bit reluctant to make runs behind the defense, which makes Xavi's task a bit harder actually. Players like Messi, Iniesta and even Eto'o sometimes just want the ball at their feet instead of making runs for Xavi behind the defense.

4) How are you saying Xavi didn't do much special? Do you know why Henry and Eto'o have so much goals? It's because of this man Xavi, i don't know how you can see him pass the ball around with ease, split defenses with his magical through balls and then say he isn't doing anything special.
1) Sorry if you didn't get this, but to support Azurri as a Juve fan is waaaay more logical than support Barca as a Juve fan. My mistake that i didn't clear up about what kind of fans am i talking about in Juventus forum.

2) In some of my posts i said that the thing i adore in football is the strikers, who are able to find space in penalty area, beat his opponent, score hard goals and stuff like Eto'O did yesterday. I didn't compare Xavi with other players, i tried to show that the other players in Barca system (yes, even Iniesta, who were played out of position in semis, but scored the only goal for his team) deserve as much praise. As everyone was praising just Xavi, i thought it's a bit wrong to praise only Xavi, where the other's had great season too (and some guys like Messi have got even greater season).

3) So to play through ball is easier than just to give it to Messi or Henry and hope that they will work something out? :D Interesting logic you got there, the stats, which Andy is constantly giving us, is coming either way.

4) As i said, i've watched only CL with Barca this year, and i've missed many of Xavi's magic in La Liga if the things you are saying is right, but i doubt that without Xavi but with Gleb for example Barca wouldn't have been able to win yesterday or against Chelsea/Bayern/whatever, as i didn't see his big impact in CL.
 

V

Senior Member
Jun 8, 2005
20,110
  • V

    V

Well yes, his poor season can be attributed in part to the lack of quality around him. But even last year, when he was at his best. Xavi was still a better player. Fact of the matter is, that Xavi is the more consistent of the two right now. Which makes him the better player. Even last year, which was Cesc's best season to date, he wasn't as consistent as Xavi was. He just dropped it in the last 2 months of the season.
Fred, one is playing for the superior Spanish team of the last couple of years, one is playing for a team that's in transition for the last couple of years. It's not a fair comparison.

Xavi is the type of player that will always make the right pass, rarely complicate things. Iniesta on the other hand will do the unexpected, pull a pass through 4 defenders to the attackers feet. Xavi never, ever took my breath away, Iniesta and Fabregas did. They've got the inteligence, vision and skill, Xavi's got that all but to a lesser degree.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 28)