[ENG] Premiership 2008/2009 (58 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Henry

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2003
5,517
Again, oblivious to the realities of Italy. First I should point out that in calciopoli there wasn't a single instance of actual cheating, merely unspecified "machinations". What you can do from there is piece together hearsay and speculate on what actually happened, and I'm sure there is substance to that. Secondly, frickin eight clubs had points deducted in calciopoli. So if we are the cheaters then we take half the league with us. On top of that you have assorted financial fraud, shady auditing, fake passports, hilarious conflicts of interest (Galliani league president, who I should add received a ban and somehow failed to remove himself from his position, Inter guy delivered wiretaps to the prosection), several clubs in lower divisions relegated for match fixing, Fiorentina dropped down to Serie C1 for bankrupcy, Parma and Lazio run by white collar criminals and so forth. And mind you this is only the football arena, not even beginning to account for the ethical standards in politics, the country ran by a mobster etc.

Once you put all that together the picture becomes considerably more nuanced and if anyone based on that is willing to condemn Juve for being the cheating party is plainly an idiot. It says little to condemn a guy for being corrupt in a culture where corruption is the rule.

So what is a fan to do? Condemn the whole thing and forget about football? I guess that's an option. Or you can live with it despite the obvious flaws, whatever appeals to you.

try telling that to Inter fans

:rolleyes::rolleyes:
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
well, in the league, we've been close, but it has been ages since we actually won it. and yes, I know ferguson's won it twice, but benitez will probably win it twice in far less time. in europe, fergie's not so good. in the league, he's tops, no doubt. and it's not a gazillion league titles, you may not know this, but england did have a league BEFORE the premier league, and liverpool won it several times. in fact, more than anyone else :p
"probably"? You're kidding yourself.

and I agree about people disliking juve because of cheating. that's forming an opinion on the club withouth really knowing about it, or about the league and it's history. what is your opinion on liverpool based on?
I don't know. I've tried to analyze it before and I've come to understand that I don't understand why I dislike certain clubs. Sure, I can find reasons to support it, but it doesn't explain the origins of the sentiment. Would you be able to explain why you like a player in such a way that it would rule out all other players who would also be eligible for that argument? I doubt it. It's just the way we are.

Tottenham, Liverpool, Arsenal, ManU, Chelsea. In order of annoyance. Tottenham are obviously completely harmless.

as for disliking juve, a lot of people dislike it for similar reasons to disliking say, manu; namely, winning everything in their respective country, being favoured, being followed by lots of glory-hunters
I have to say the "gloryhunter" attack is the most pathetic kind of fake elitism I've ever seen. The fact that someone who spent 20 years going to matches and going to the pub with his drinking buddies talking about football and generally hasn't accomplished a damn thing in his whole life (ie. the model supporter) can look down on someone who gets excited about the sport for other reasons about himself is just about the most pathetic thing ever. What's next, homeless people in Europe making fun of starving kids in Africa who have it even worse?

-it's ironic that the person who i keep arguing with on the forums is martin, considering you're probably one of the members I would least expect to argue with :D
now if it was burke, andy, etc, no surprises :spliff:
That's okay, we don't have to agree on everything :wink:
 

Henry

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2003
5,517
"probably"? You're kidding yourself.
??? fergie won has won it twice in more than 20 years. Benitez has already won it once and been to the final twice. Benitez is better tactically, and i could see him winning it again in the next 5 years.



I don't know. I've tried to analyze it before and I've come to understand that I don't understand why I dislike certain clubs. Sure, I can find reasons to support it, but it doesn't explain the origins of the sentiment. Would you be able to explain why you like a player in such a way that it would rule out all other players who would also be eligible for that argument? I doubt it. It's just the way we are.
i can't deny that that's often the case

I have to say the "gloryhunter" attack is the most pathetic kind of fake elitism I've ever seen. The fact that someone who spent 20 years going to matches and going to the pub with his drinking buddies talking about football and generally hasn't accomplished a damn thing in his whole life (ie. the model supporter) can look down on someone who gets excited about the sport for other reasons about himself is just about the most pathetic thing ever. What's next, homeless people in Europe making fun of starving kids in Africa who have it even worse?
it's not about elitism. it's because a gloryhunter, changing the team he "supports" every time a new team is in vogue is BS. someone who says they like a certain team based on how the play, that's fine and understandable. but people who go on about how much they love their teams and then switch all the time, simply stupid



That's okay, we don't have to agree on everything :wink:

but you do have to admit I'm right and you're wrong :D
 

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
i can't deny that that's often the case
I think the biggest problem with the CL right now is Real Madrid. They are the team that really made it fun for me back when they were good. The kings of the CL. Now they suck and it's no fun, they get beaten all the time.

it's not about elitism. it's because a gloryhunter, changing the team he "supports" every time a new team is in vogue is BS. someone who says they like a certain team based on how the play, that's fine and understandable. but people who go on about how much they love their teams and then switch all the time, simply stupid
It's a clash of cultures. The "true supporters" as they like to call themselves (not elitism, riiight) preach that you have to pick a club and stick with it. Can't go around changing your mind, that's not allowed. Riight. Who the feck put you in charge you conceited jackass?

Basically, their reasons for supporting a club are iron clan while some lame gloryhunter's reasons, whatever they may be, are worthless. Be like us or gtfo.

but you do have to admit I'm right and you're wrong :D
why would I do that? :D
 

Henry

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2003
5,517
it is a clash of cultures, and both sides are fine to a certai extant. what bothers me though, is not people that follow football first and specific teams second. nothing wrong with that. it's the purest way to be a football fan. but if you're going to call yourself a supporter of a specific club, and have that has your badge so to speak, then switching at whim is just....kind of lame
 

king Ale

Senior Member
Oct 28, 2004
21,689
Again, oblivious to the realities of Italy. First I should point out that in calciopoli there wasn't a single instance of actual cheating, merely unspecified "machinations". What you can do from there is piece together hearsay and speculate on what actually happened, and I'm sure there is substance to that. Secondly, frickin eight clubs had points deducted in calciopoli. So if we are the cheaters then we take half the league with us. On top of that you have assorted financial fraud, shady auditing, fake passports, hilarious conflicts of interest (Galliani league president, who I should add received a ban and somehow failed to remove himself from his position, Inter guy delivered wiretaps to the prosection), several clubs in lower divisions relegated for match fixing, Fiorentina dropped down to Serie C1 for bankrupcy, Parma and Lazio run by white collar criminals and so forth. And mind you this is only the football arena, not even beginning to account for the ethical standards in politics, the country ran by a mobster etc.

Once you put all that together the picture becomes considerably more nuanced and if anyone based on that is willing to condemn Juve for being the cheating party is plainly an idiot. It says little to condemn a guy for being corrupt in a culture where corruption is the rule.

So what is a fan to do? Condemn the whole thing and forget about football? I guess that's an option. Or you can live with it despite the obvious flaws, whatever appeals to you.
You hit the nail on the head.

Whatever happens off the pitch has its impact on what we see on the pitch. But for me it has another story. I enjoy the play, the show. I enjoy football as a sport with all its excitements, happiness, pities and angers. These are the only things I care about. Our Scudettos were revoked but my joy after Del Piero's freekick against Inter in the last minute or Trez's header against Milan will never be revoked.
 

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
it is a clash of cultures, and both sides are fine to a certai extant. what bothers me though, is not people that follow football first and specific teams second. nothing wrong with that. it's the purest way to be a football fan. but if you're going to call yourself a supporter of a specific club, and have that has your badge so to speak, then switching at whim is just....kind of lame
Who are you to judge people why they like or dislike a club? We just established 15 minutes ago that we can't even articulate our reasons for doing so ourselves, and now you're ready to pass judgment on others? Do you not see how bankrupt this logic is?
 

Henry

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2003
5,517
Who are you to judge people why they like or dislike a club? We just established 15 minutes ago that we can't even articulate our reasons for doing so ourselves, and now you're ready to pass judgment on others? Do you not see how bankrupt this logic is?

I didn't say my reasons for supporting liverpool and juve. anyway, that's not what I'm saying. i don't judge someone on WHY the support a club. rather, if you support a club, and say that you are a supporter of that club, you should continue supporting them whether they are winning trophies or not. to change teams because the new one is starting to win more is not a good enough reason. if you support the club, it should be because of the club, it should be something you like, say, a player, the supporters, etc. to support clubs purely on their money and trophy winning in a particular year is BS
 

Henry

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2003
5,517
a team is like a friend,you support it no matter what. it shouldn't be like clothing, which you change and discard depending on the days fashion. if someone supports a club based in the same way the wear clothes, then yes, I do look down on them. they have no real connection with their club
 

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
I didn't say my reasons for supporting liverpool and juve. anyway, that's not what I'm saying. i don't judge someone on WHY the support a club. rather, if you support a club, and say that you are a supporter of that club, you should continue supporting them whether they are winning trophies or not.
:lol: So you have no idea why someone is supporting a club, and yet you say they are not allowed to change their mind, even though you don't have a clue what reasons they might have for doing it.

to support clubs purely on their money and trophy winning in a particular year is BS
I say again. Why are your reasons for supporting a club more valid than someone else's? Because you say so?

And the zinger:

i don't judge someone on WHY the support a club.
Way to contradict yourself in the same paragraph, buddy :wink:
 

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
a team is like a friend,you support it no matter what. it shouldn't be like clothing, which you change and discard depending on the days fashion. if someone supports a club based in the same way the wear clothes, then yes, I do look down on them. they have no real connection with their club
Again, a matter of culture. Why is your culture better than my culture?
 

Henry

Senior Member
Sep 30, 2003
5,517
sorry, when I say support, i don't mean follow, ie my sentence was talking about follow a specific club without switching around. i don't consider following a club because they're rich and winning things to really be supporting the club. my fault, i wasn't clear. supporting a club is being loyal to that club. following a club is flexible.
 

Martin

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2000
56,913
sorry, when I say support, i don't mean follow, ie my sentence was talking about follow a specific club without switching around. i don't consider following a club because they're rich and winning things to really be supporting the club. my fault, i wasn't clear. supporting a club is being loyal to that club. following a club is flexible.
Your semantics is irrelevant :wink:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 58)