Does God exist? (William Lane Craig vs Peter Atkins debate) (16 Viewers)

Well, did...

  • Man make God?

  • God make Man?


Results are only viewable after voting.

Zé Tahir

JhoolayLaaaal!
Moderator
Dec 10, 2004
29,281
Gonna read it now. Update*
After reading it as interesting as this hypothesis is , the author speaks of God not being able to give the male chromosomes to Mary because that would make him human and not God. Yet in that same sentence he himself is limiting the creation powers of God. This is the same God which created the universe, Adam and Eve from nothing yet he couldn't implant the 23 male chromosomes into the womb of Mary ?
Does God break his rules? If God created everything than he created the laws of nature right? The author states "This is the design of God" so he's not limiting the power of God, just stating his modus operandi. Of course he can do literally do everything and anything, like change the state of rocks from a solid into a liquid all of a sudden...but that's not really his style is it?

For argument sake if Adam & Eve were the first people and God made them from 'nothing' then why not make Jesus that way? That stands as a bigger 'miracle' than making 23 male chromosomes appear in a woman in a time when people didn't know any of that stuff.
 

AndreaCristiano

Nato, Vive, e muore Italiano
Jun 9, 2011
19,125
But there seems to be no difference between the believers and the non-believers when it comes to sinning; they do the same things (not all, obviously) yet the believer should be motivated by punishment & reward. If you look at a group of believers and non-believers just by their actions, you couldn't separate them, I believe (no, I don't have proof).
That is nowhere near the truth, a true believer strives to not sin, to not mire in those evils, and falls occasionally to varying degrees depending on that persons belief and faith a non religious only regulates to themselves and a amoral belief in what is evil. Not sinning isnt about punishment for a believer its done for love of God as a child tries not to dissapoint his earthly father a believer tries not to dissapoint his father in heaven
 

AndreaCristiano

Nato, Vive, e muore Italiano
Jun 9, 2011
19,125
Does God break his rules? If God created everything than he created the laws of nature right? The author states "This is the design of God" so he's not limiting the power of God, just stating his modus operandi. Of course he can do literally do everything and anything, like change the state of rocks from a solid into a liquid all of a sudden...but that's not really his style is it?

For argument sake if Adam & Eve were the first people and God made them from 'nothing' then why not make Jesus that way? That stands as a bigger 'miracle' than making 23 male chromosomes appear in a woman in a time when people didn't know any of that stuff.
Well if thats accurate wouldnt the first man and woman be against the rules? they were created without those earthly parents so there was none of the chromosomal mathematics!
Also with Jesus he was born the way he was to fulfill the messianic scriptures, to be born of a virgin, prophecy my friend
 

Quetzalcoatl

It ain't hard to tell
Aug 22, 2007
66,757
That is nowhere near the truth, a true believer strives to not sin, to not mire in those evils, and falls occasionally to varying degrees depending on that persons belief and faith a non religious only regulates to themselves and a amoral belief in what is evil. Not sinning isnt about punishment for a believer its done for love of God as a child tries not to dissapoint his earthly father a believer tries not to dissapoint his father in heaven
Just saying based on experience of what I see. Strive to sin or not, they still do it as much as anyone else. The only difference is what they say they believe. What you say about believers actually feeling God's presence would be more convincing if they could behave like it. You would think that if you could feel the presence of the Big Man right over your shoulder, it would provide some kind of push to be more "holy".
 

Linebreak

Senior Member
Sep 18, 2009
16,022
But there seems to be no difference between the believers and the non-believers when it comes to sinning; they do the same things (not all, obviously) yet the believer should be motivated by punishment & reward. If you look at a group of believers and non-believers just by their actions, you couldn't separate them, I believe (no, I don't have proof).
All men are sinners. I would speculate that practising believers in all religions, on average, commit less "sin" than non-practising believers and non-believers. From my personal experience with people this definitely holds true. A study may prove either way.

There are many moral atheists. Moral doesn't necessarily mean religious. But it's certainly the case that one who is serious about practising religion is always being encouraged to behave morally, against their selfishness and desires, they're continually thinking about what they do (seems like a horrible life to an atheist), whereas non-practising and non-believing people will find it much easier to commit a "sin" as other than their conscience, nothing else is really holding them back.
 

AndreaCristiano

Nato, Vive, e muore Italiano
Jun 9, 2011
19,125
Just saying based on experience of what I see. Strive to sin or not, they still do it as much as anyone else. The only difference is what they say they believe. What you say about believers actually feeling God's presence would be more convincing if they could behave like it. You would think that if you could feel the presence of the Big Man right over your shoulder, it would provide some kind of push to be more "holy".
People i know who are true believers do not sin as much as non believers not even in the same stratosphere
 

Linebreak

Senior Member
Sep 18, 2009
16,022
Does God break his rules? If God created everything than he created the laws of nature right? The author states "This is the design of God" so he's not limiting the power of God, just stating his modus operandi. Of course he can do literally do everything and anything, like change the state of rocks from a solid into a liquid all of a sudden...but that's not really his style is it?

For argument sake if Adam & Eve were the first people and God made them from 'nothing' then why not make Jesus that way? That stands as a bigger 'miracle' than making 23 male chromosomes appear in a woman in a time when people didn't know any of that stuff.
Start a new thread if you want to get into religious polemics, in this thread AC is on your side of the equation.
 

Quetzalcoatl

It ain't hard to tell
Aug 22, 2007
66,757
All men are sinners. I would speculate that practising believers in all religions, on average, commit less "sin" than non-practising believers and non-believers. From my personal experience with people this definitely holds true. A study may prove either way.

There are many moral atheists. Moral doesn't necessarily mean religious. But it's certainly the case that one who is serious about practising religion is always being encouraged to behave morally, against their selfishness and desires, they're continually thinking about what they do (seems like a horrible life to an atheist), whereas non-practising and non-believing people will find it much easier to commit a "sin" as other than their conscience, nothing else is really holding them back.
The difference there is just not convincing enough. The vast majority of believers that I've witnessed live like they aren't believers. They may have their one or two sins that they're totally against, like the chicks that keep sex until marriage, but they still lie, gossip, steal like everyone else. How much of an impact does God really have on their lives? How present is he really to them?
 

Quetzalcoatl

It ain't hard to tell
Aug 22, 2007
66,757
People i know who are true believers do not sin as much as non believers not even in the same stratosphere
Well you always seem to know about the extremities, exceptions and anomalies. The church going crowds that I used to be among every Sundays were the most gossipy, judgmental, unsympathetic, uncharitable (except when many eyes were on them) and un-Christ-like people ever. Yet they were adamant that God was ever present in their lives.
 

Linebreak

Senior Member
Sep 18, 2009
16,022
The difference there is just not convincing enough. The vast majority of believers that I've witnessed live like they aren't believers. They may have their one or two sins that they're totally against, like the chicks that keep sex until marriage, but they still lie, gossip, steal like everyone else. How much of an impact does God really have on their lives? How present is he really to them?
I won't doubt your personal experience one bit. If one is practising a religion they should be willing to go all or nothing. In between is simply hypocrisy as you quite rightly allude to.
 
Jul 1, 2010
26,352
You didn't answer me Treq, How if man was the author of the Quran, how he could wriitten facts in the the 7th Century that are shown to be true now by modern science. ?
I've answered you two times already.

Like I said again and again, people approach these scriptures with 21th century scientific knowledge and try to understand what they want from them.
 

Quetzalcoatl

It ain't hard to tell
Aug 22, 2007
66,757
Wasn't Jesus all about humility and sacrifice? Who the hell does that these days anyway? Certainly not us guys who drive nice cars, go on vacations to nice places. And certainly not our church leaders, pastors, Pope. Again, it's all talk and no action by those who preach God is in their lives.
 

Cheesio

**********
Jul 11, 2006
22,514
TWW, Prophet Muhammad said that the you are not a true believer until you love to the others what you love for yourself. There aren't many true believers unfortunately.
 

AndreaCristiano

Nato, Vive, e muore Italiano
Jun 9, 2011
19,125
Well you always seem to know about the extremities, exceptions and anomalies. The church going crowds that I used to be among every Sundays were the most gossipy, judgmental, unsympathetic, uncharitable (except when many eyes were on them) and un-Christ-like people ever. Yet they were adamant that God was ever present in their lives.
Believe me I know those types and they are not Christians like I said its easy for people to profess God with their lips not with their heart. They forget as Christians when Jesus said worry not about the splinter in your brothers eyes, first remove the beam from yours!
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 16)