Diego, Silva or Ribéry? (10 Viewers)

Diego, Silva or Ribéry?

  • Diego Ribas da Cunha (Werder Bremen)

  • David Silva (Valencia)

  • Franck Ribéry (Bayern Munich)


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

only-juve

Senior Member
Jan 5, 2008
7,451
well if you are thinking that we can't pay 60 , 70mil. or more for a single player then i agree . But if lets say Ribery can be bought for 40 -45 mil. i don't see why we can't be competitive with other clubs. we have been spending 40-50 mil for the past two seasons and buying 5-6 players of which half of them are just average who bring nothing to them team except squad depth( which is good considering the problems we are having with injuries this season) , but IMO it's time to spend big and get 2 , 3 players which will greatly improve this team
In theory what you're saying is 100% right, but people on charge of this club can't make such decisions. If they spend 10 mil euros or less on a player and that player fail to deliver for one reason or another (almiron, andrade...) they can find a way to get away with it. But if they pay 25-30 mil for a player and that player was a failure they can't simply face the owners or the fans.

Thats why i honestly don't think we'll get a big star next summer. Names like ribery, diego, silva are out of reach (even though i truelly believe we can afford some of them ). The more likely names for us are diego capel, malouda.... players that would cost around 15 mil max and not many clubs are after them.
 

Buy on AliExpress.com

Orgut

Senior Member
Dec 31, 2002
19,317
statistics of silva, ribeiry and diego (in that order)


white balls goals, green balls assists
According to statistics Ribery would be an excellent buy while Silva is more about show than effectiveness Diego is somewhere in the middle

ofcourse football is more than statistics but still...

by the way what is the site you got this from?
 
Apr 12, 2004
77,165
Ribery is like DP and Camo combined, Silva is like a better Camo, and Diego is like a mediocre or just better Nedved in his prime, just in the middle.

The best thing that could happen to your club is to not get any of them and get Vand der Vaart or Sneijder.
 

Cronios

Juventolog
Jun 7, 2004
27,519
As long as we have Secco, we dont have any realistic chances to buy any of those gents. We tend to overpay players and sell our own for ridiculous sums.
Our owners would rather fund the new stadium and our next forward instead...
 

RAMI-N

★ ★ ★
Aug 22, 2006
21,470
ßüякε;1897768 said:
Ribery is like DP and Camo combined, Silva is like a better Camo, and Diego is like a mediocre or just better Nedved in his prime, just in the middle.

The best thing that could happen to your club is to not get any of them and get Vand der Vaart or Sneijder.
:tup:
 

Enoran

Senior Member
Nov 3, 2007
1,739
According to V1rtual's data ...

Its like this ...

Silva
08/09 - 0.2 goals, 0.2 assist per game
Career - 0.14 goals, 0.11 assist per game

Ribery
08/09 - 0.38 goals, 0.46 assist per game
Career - 0.26 goals, 0.33 assist per game

Diego
08/09 - 0.38 goals, 0.21 assist per game
Career - 0.32 goals, 0.26 assist per game


Stats dun tell everything as they are playing in different league and teams with varying competence level of teammates but looking at it, Ribery justified why he's the most exp of the 3.
Diego is probably playing in the weakest of the 3 teams overall ...

Ribery and Diego are more of a goal threats than Silva ...
 

Red

-------
Moderator
Nov 26, 2006
47,024
As long as we have Secco, we dont have any realistic chances to buy any of those gents. We tend to overpay players and sell our own for ridiculous sums.
Our owners would rather fund the new stadium and our next forward instead...
Damn them for moving to look after the club's long term interests. :rolleyes:
 

Osman

Koul Khara!
Aug 30, 2002
61,480
Its ridicolous to actually nag about the stadio. But he mentionned next forward too, even if its not the major priority, but one we should look for after getting the other parts, we have to realise our forwards are all 30 or nearing 30. They are players we really can only have short term wise. If one of them leaves, I wouldnt nag at the club at all if they went after one of these young starlets like Rossi.

Not only to rejuvenate with quality, but young players of quality dont tend to wait around for you to sign them til next summer or the one after (like for example, if Salvio is someone we think is a future top dog, dont pass on him, unless he turns out to be the next Aguero and be impossible to sign later on). Usually you have to pounce when they are on the market, so in that kind of scenario, if they see someone thats too good to pass and is possible, then why not? Even if yes, getting service to the forwards are the main goal of summer mercato.
 

Fred

Senior Member
Oct 2, 2003
41,113
ßüякε;1897768 said:
Ribery is like DP and Camo combined, Silva is like a better Camo, and Diego is like a mediocre or just better Nedved in his prime, just in the middle.

The best thing that could happen to your club is to not get any of them and get Vand der Vaart or Sneijder.
Silva, Ribery and Diego would all be better options than VDV and Sneider imo.


Damn them for moving to look after the club's long term interests. :rolleyes:
WORD!!!!

People just don't realize that there is a difference between long term planning and short term planning.
Agreed, moving to the new stadium will pay its dividends in the long run.
 

Slow_Roll

In Love with a Feelin'
Mar 4, 2008
344
Man you reminded me of Salvio, he would be great position and age wise as he could replace Camo in the future and act as a back-up forward should we sell IQ or Trez.
 

Snoop

Sabet is a nasty virgin
Oct 2, 2001
28,186
Damn them for moving to look after the club's long term interests. :rolleyes:
I didn't criticize them about the new stadium before, but he has a point here. Is it the right time to invest on new stadium,? when you lost your entire team 3 seasons ago. Wouldn't it be wiser to build the team, then the stadium later in 5 years let's say?

You guys need to be more objective, you can't defend the board for everything they do just because some members bash the same way..
 

Azzurri7

Pinturicchio
Moderator
Dec 16, 2003
72,692
ßüякε;1897768 said:
Ribery is like DP and Camo combined, Silva is like a better Camo, and Diego is like a mediocre or just better Nedved in his prime, just in the middle.

The best thing that could happen to your club is to not get any of them and get Vand der Vaart or Sneijder.
:lol2:

Sorry bro but I just couldn't help it.

Ribery like Dp and Camo combined?

Silva better than Camo?

Diego better than Nedved in his prime?


Yeah alright, Mr. Bayernist,
 

Eire

Senior Member
Mar 1, 2004
1,096
Whatever about buying ribery or silva am i the only one who considers the purchase of Diego for €25 million ridiculous when we have Giovinco and the money could then be used to strenghten our fullbacks and other areas of the squad where we are weak on players.

I think a transfer campaign where we buy 1 star player(Ribery €30 mil)
And 3 good players for €30-35 million in total should be possible.Players like Lahm, Zapata, Ivanovic are what we need not Diego. i would prefer rakitic to both Silva and Diego he would be cheaper and better suited to our style of play

with some sales maybe Iaquinta and Zebina and Marchionni could be sold we surely can have a budget of at least 60 million

we need these players to take us to the next level this is a huge transfer campaign for Juventus if we are to return to former glories. and most importantly big name players especially younger players are forgetting the image of Juve as a winning club and so seeking transfers to other clubs who Juve should have more pulling power over in the transfer market.

The summer transfer campaign will be crucial for the future of the club, juve may overcome chelsea but i am worried that juve could be handed a footballing lesson by some team in this seasons CL like arsenal gave us at highbury a few seasons ago, And finally show our board that yeah a lot has been done since calcioploi but there is a hell of a lot more to do before we can eat of the top table of european heavyweights again!
 
Apr 12, 2004
77,165
:lol2:

Sorry bro but I just couldn't help it.

Ribery like Dp and Camo combined?

Silva better than Camo?

Diego better than Nedved in his prime?


Yeah alright, Mr. Bayernist,
I didn't mean their skills, I meant the way they played.

Ribery plays like a mix of DP and Camo, and I think Silva could be better than Camo, and I'm not sure what I said about the Diego shit, hold on, I was really drunk.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 10)