Good
Thuram
Kalulu
Di Gregorio
Costa
Kolo and Veiga also helped a lot, even if they were dry loans. Conceicao and Nico had their moments. Nico looked like a different guy under Tudor, so I think it’s also hard to tell who was the bigger issue, Motta or Giuntoli.
Bad
Kelly was a disaster. Selling Huijsen, especially after not buying Calafiori was stupid. Douglas Luiz and Koop both had a bunch of fitness issues, they didn’t have good seasons but they’re probably better than they’ve shown, so too early to make a judgement. But overall bad.
It’s also easy to forget as a fan that he had a budget to balance, which he did. They’re in a good spot financially, much better spot at least than they were when he arrived.
I don’t really care if he stays or goes, but with a new manager the time to make a change would be now. So if there are any doubts, he should go now. I don’t like the idea of giving him a middle man like Chiellini or another director to co pilot like Massara. Either you trust him or you don’t.