He didn't make his mark by trying to be a cultured or classy player, I think our more recent style doesn't highlight his strengths. When Milan are barely attacking he is forced to be a ball-playing defender, and his passes are the most telegraphed you will ever see in football, his left leg is like a golf putter it is so deliberate.
I think we'd see him at his best again in a back four, just defending and touching the ball sideways to someone who can use it better.