++ [ originally posted by swag
] ++
OK... I just finished this book while on vacation (or if you prefer, "holiday"

) recently. Some good chapters about corruption in Brasil and how naive Pele was about everything, the twisted social politics behind Rangers-Celtic matches, and some funny stuff about Nigerians playing in the Ukraine. The author makes a good case for why he is a Barca fan and everyone else might want to be,
his chapter on soccer and Islam is pretty encouraging , and I think he's spot on with his analysis of soccer in America.
But he completely put the blinders on when it comes to Italian football. In fact, I would argue that it easily represents his worst and most myopic chapter in the entire book. Part of the problem could have been timing -- he talks about his experience at the AC Milan clubhouse two days after the 2003 CL Final. So he characterizes Italian soccer today as if it's still stuck in the 1940s with catenaccio and that all matches end 1-0, as if teams like Lecce don't even exist. Worse yet, IMO, is his generalization that Italian football is bankrupt (part true), corrupt (part true), and has no redeeming qualities for which to say anything positive (completely bogus).
The irony here is that he clearly identifies groups of Americans who literally hate soccer (actively, and who are not just passively ambivalent about it) as a gut-level reaction to it without ever really watching the sport. And yet he is 100% guilty himself of pursuing only a one-dimensional pre-/mis-conception about Italian football, chosing a thesis and only seeking out the evidence to support it... ignoring anything else.
I still recommend the book. But you have to ignore the fact that he has barely lifted a finger to look beyond stereotypes in a few instances, particularly around Serie A.