Best Defender in the World? (3 Viewers)

Who is the world's best defender at the moment?

  • Puyol

  • Cannavaro

  • Mertesacker

  • Ricardo Carvalho

  • Terry

  • Alex

  • Cris

  • van Buyten

  • Kolo Toure

  • Carragher

  • Vidic

  • Mexes

  • Cordoba

  • Materazzi

  • Barzagli


Results are only viewable after voting.

Azzurri7

Pinturicchio
Moderator
Dec 16, 2003
72,692
#42
FFS, Cannavaro isn't the same Cannavaro he was in Juventus and World Cup. Yes, he won the Fifa World Player of the year, thanks to us and to his great performance with Italy.

....But ATM, he's no where to be called best defender in the world. Not at all. He's been out of form since day 1 he joined real madrid, and each one who is having the chance to watch crap's team will know what i'm talking about.
 

peckface

approaching curve
Oct 3, 2004
2,357
#43
I watch every game and I don't fully agree with that. I agree that he isn't the best at the moment. Though as I said, the enviroment is a factor to his performances.

Emerson goes forward a lot when the attack isn't working. Gago is useless in defence. Guti works hard but his marking skills aint fantastic. Diarra sits on the bench, he works hard, got good positioning and markig skills but his passing skills are way to sloppy for such a team and often give the opposition counter-attacks.

All and all, when Real Madrid is attacking, the Midfield has to push way up, which causes a huge gap between the midfield and defence (which for some reason defends to deep, perhaps It's Cannas fault? Lets blame Capello ;)) and that aint to easy to defend against, especially not against Spanish teams. The majority of them play brilliant counter football.

Cannavaro was fantastic this Saturday, I think he was m.o.m even though he got the red.

edit: just read throw this, i type like an 80 year old crack smoking grandpa
 

Ascension

Senior Member
Sep 16, 2005
1,882
#44
Nah, I agree with Rab here. Canna is nowhere near his Juve and WC form. Not even close.

Perhaps Napoli is the team he should go to next season. Relax and enjoy his last few years before he hangs his boots.
 

Azzurri7

Pinturicchio
Moderator
Dec 16, 2003
72,692
#45
I watch every game and I don't fully agree with that. I agree that he isn't the best at the moment. Though as I said, the enviroment is a factor to his performances.

Emerson goes forward a lot when the attack isn't working. Gago is useless in defence. Guti works hard but his marking skills aint fantastic. Diarra sits on the bench, he works hard, got good positioning and markig skills but his passing skills are way to sloppy for such a team and often give the opposition counter-attacks.

All and all, when Real Madrid is attacking, the Midfield has to push way up, which causes a huge gap between the midfield and defence (which for some reason defends to deep, perhaps It's Cannas fault? Lets blame Capello ;)) and that aint to easy to defend against, especially not against Spanish teams. The majority of them play brilliant counter football.

Cannavaro was fantastic this Saturday, I think he was m.o.m even though he got the red.

edit: just read throw this, i type like an 80 year old crack smoking grandpa
I really don't care how Capello plays his formation or tactics in Madrid, he was playing an old fashion formation and tactics in Turin too. Yet Fabio Cannavaro was one of the best. I think Defenders don't really focus or care on how their coach is playing the system, at the end, their job is to help their goalkeeper not to concede a goal. thats how they think.

Fabio Capello under Juve = Shitty coach, great Fabio.

Fabio Capello under Real M= Shitty coach, out of form Fabio. There's no question about that.
 

Ahmedios

Senior Member
Nov 11, 2006
5,107
#46
I really don't care how Capello plays his formation or tactics in Madrid, he was playing an old fashion formation and tactics in Turin too. Yet Fabio Cannavaro was one of the best. I think Defenders don't really focus or care on how their coach is playing the system, at the end, their job is to help their goalkeeper not to concede a goal. thats how they think.

Fabio Capello under Juve = Shitty coach, great Fabio.

Fabio Capello under Real M= Shitty coach, out of form Fabio. There's no question about that
.
Absolutely, I agree.

I'm very sorry that a legendary defender like Nesta isn't included in this poll. Injuries, injuries,....that's life.
 

peckface

approaching curve
Oct 3, 2004
2,357
#48
I really don't care how Capello plays his formation or tactics in Madrid, he was playing an old fashion formation and tactics in Turin too. Yet Fabio Cannavaro was one of the best. I think Defenders don't really focus or care on how their coach is playing the system, at the end, their job is to help their goalkeeper not to concede a goal. thats how they think.

Fabio Capello under Juve = Shitty coach, great Fabio.

Fabio Capello under Real M= Shitty coach, out of form Fabio. There's no question about that.
Yeah I thought about that. But then again, that was Italy this is Spain, the game is bound to differ.

I do think lpaying in Italy, with the players in Juventus around him suited him while the Spanish system doesn't. I don't like the "talent disappears over night some times" talk, and I don't think it is because he's having troubles finding a sweet ass condo.
 

JuveAdam

Moggi santo..subito
Sep 12, 2006
1,072
#56
Voted Canna, purely on the "form is temporary, class is permanent" theory. Would have liked to see Zambro up there though! If our lame excuse for a board actually gets off its collective fat a$$ long enough this summer to sign Barzagli, I hope his name will top a similar poll by the end of Euro 2008. With us, he'd mature & develop enough to become a sure-fire starter for Italy by the time the championship comes round. I see him as a long-term replacement for Nesta in the azzurri line-up. A pairing of him & Milan's Bonera is the 1st time I've seen anything capable of replacing Canna/Nesta. Hope both continue their progress, & Barzagli is bianconero by July!!!!!!!
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 3)