You cant measure it that way. Then i guess Rafinha is just as good as Philipp Lahm because he won the CL with Bayern Munich all though he didnt play in the crucial games. Navas is one of the greatest keepers because he won the CL with Real Madrid or?
I dont really get youre logic.
Some players just never get to win the CL, that doesent make them any less a player. Lothar Matthäus lost two CL finals with Bayern Munich, but still he won the Ballon d`Or, the World Cup and European too.