Arturo Vidal (84 Viewers)

Zacheryah

Senior Member
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
its not like we are selling all our players, and most of all, do not replace them properly.

pirlo was past it, tevez wanted to go back, vidal? no idea.

but we already brought in dybala for tevez, khedira for pirlo, and i am sure we will
bring a good replacement (or AM?) for vidal aswell.

so you ask me if i’m pissed when vidal leaves? of course i am.
but it is not the end of the world. we will not be pulling a dortmund.
people are overreacting on here.
Quality wise we can kinda support it, but we do lose an edge that only special players offer

- - - Updated - - -

Not really a big fan. But wouldn't complain if we weren't selling anyone.

If Vidal goes i expect better. Gotze, Oscar or Isco.
yeah, but those wouldnt heal the wound of selling vidal


TO FUCKING GUARDIOLA OF ALL FUCKING CANCEROUS GROWTHS FOR FUCKS SAKE
 

Oggy

and the Cockroaches
Dec 27, 2005
7,512
how does winning the ballon d'or make him more instrumental for us? i said in my post he got that for the 98 world cup, we would also receive a record transfer fee for pogba, doesnt mean hes more instrumental
My point wasn't about that, it was more about you warning to people for not posting facts, and in you post you said that Zidane was more about hype and there were better players than him.

However, what I really want to say with the best possible intentions (I really like you as poster and mod) you are sometimes to sensitive when it comes to players/coaches/staff you like and you are warning people for posting harmless comments and voicing their opinions. Some people think Arturo asked to leave, some people think Marotta offered him to BM, in both those statements people are trying to find comfort or justification, and as long it's not offensive towards player or manager it should be ok.

I think selling him will be disaster, he is the hart of the team, however I would be more comfortable if I knew he asked for transfer, disappointed but more comfortable, because at least I would know that our management is not incompetent.

Also everything is happening way two fast, so something important had to happen, and I doubt we will ever hear the whole story.
 

DUKAC

Senior Member
Feb 29, 2012
12,286
Thats not my point.

The point is that we were weaker after zidane's sale, even if that made sense

We are now again weaker IF we sell vidal, and the money doesnt remotely make sense
How we were weaker if we buy three real champions in the names of Gigi,Thuram and Nedved (Salas was a bonus)?I will sell every player every transfer window if we can buy three champions like we did for Zizou.Not to mention that we beat Real that time for a joke while Zidane was playing for them.2003 for example and a year before.
 

PedroFlu

Senior Member
Sep 20, 2011
7,166
Deciding to sell Vidal is clearly the wrong decision.

But if it is made, you can look for reasons why - he asked to? His knee is fucked up? His problems extra-field are too much? He is refusing to renew his contract (which ends at 2017) for a reasonable sum?

What bugs me is that if you decide to sell Vidal, you do it RIGHT. Fucking Dybala with one year left in his contract got sold for 40M because of an action pulled by Zamparini.

If you decide to sell Vidal, you shop him to EPL, PSG, Bayern and Madrid/Barcelona. Shop him hard. You'll get at least 50M for the guy.

Now all of a sudden, the club decides to sell him AND sells him for 10-15M less than it should be???

What the fuck.
 

Pirlo's Beard

Junkie Joe Joyce
Oct 2, 2013
11,411
Yeah what annoys me is we've seemingly fucking accepted the first legit offer we've had. I refuse to believe we couldn't get 50 for Vidal if we whored him out.

- - - Updated - - -

PL clubs would pay a looooooot of money. I don't care if it's arab or oil money, it's money.
This is assuming the offer is more or less the same, obviously more money is the main objective but aside from that BPL fans fuck me off
 

Zacheryah

Senior Member
Aug 29, 2010
42,251
How we were weaker if we buy three real champions in the names of Gigi,Thuram and Nedved (Salas was a bonus)?I will sell every player every transfer window if we can buy three champions like we did for Zizou.Not to mention that we beat Real that time for a joke while Zidane was playing for them.2003 for example and a year before.
In 2002,2003,2004,2005,2006,2009,2010,2013,2014,2015 we have been an outsider at very best

in 97,98,99 we were THE big CL contender, in 01 we were A CL contender
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 82)